First time there. Wow! They have an incredible array of coins, stamps, quality collectible merchandise. Everyone there was helpful and friendly. Buddy the owner took care of us personally. He was very kind and willing to go the extra mile to research the coins we had brought for sale. His prices are fair and very reasonable. We will very happy with our transactions. I would highly recommend this place to anyone who is a beginner, novice, or expert at coin collecting. You will not be disappointed.

Took coins there after my husband past. I had no idea where to start. He was very nice helping me and getting some kind of an idea as to what I had. Will definitely go back

Buddy and his crew are great to deal with. Theyve been in business a long time and can be counted on for integrity in pricing. It helps to do your homework on what you are buying or selling as to realize the professionalism with which they conduct their business.

Appreciated working with Buddy and his honesty regarding my dads large coin collection. Will definitely be back with more from the collection.

This is the place to go if you want to buy or sell coins. Buddy is as fair as you can get in the business. Highly recommended

Had a small collection of old coins that I held on to for many years. After doing a lot of research on line about coin values, I separated all my coins by denomination and finally decided was time to cash them in. Did more research on line about different places that I could take my coins in for appraisal and potential selling. The one place that had consistently good reviews was Keystone. Decided this was the place for me and gave it a shot. Not the most glamorous of places, but I felt comfortable and confident as soon as I started reviewing what I had with the owner. He had a good bedside manner and the prices he offered me for my coins seemed fair based on what I had read previously on line. I walked out happy and confident with my choice of dealers and would highly recommend Keystone without reservation. All around, it was a pleasant experience and wish I had done it sooner.

Very friendly super nice people . Love doing business with them. I recommend him to everyone. Hes the best in LEHIGH VALLEY I THINK NICE

I had sold Keystone coins a few years ago and was treated very fairly, so when I had additional items of coins and jewelry, I went back to Keystone this morning and was again treated very well. Very friendly and professional staff!

I have bought sliver bars there ever year for the kids. Sure the place is not a 5 star restaurant. I bet my next silver dollar they know where every coin. bill. And every gold and silver bar is in this establishment. Great guys. Right on spot price . Everybody needs to make something. Or else no shop would be in business. Common sense. People complaining. Lucky I am not behind the counter. I would mark up the coins just as much as the other stores. Great place here to do real business

Great customer service!Very friendly. Treated well!

The people at Keystone are great to work with! From the owner himself to each one of his employees! Friendly and service oriented!! I have been doing business with Keystone Coin for 10 years now and every time I leave a satisfied customer! I would recommend to anyone who has a few coins or thousands dollars worth of coins to sell to consider Keystone Coin first before going anywhere else. Five Stars everyday!!!

I had coins from a late uncle’s estate that I had no intention of keeping. If I had known the experience would be this easy I would’ve taken them in months ago! Buddy was great and the rest of the staff (sorry I don’t remember your names) were professional and friendly. I wouldn’t hesitate to return there or recommend them.

The owner is very knowledgeable when it comes to coins its what he does he is friendy and understanding what everyone needs to keep in mind is thats its a bessness and a tough bessness you cant expect to get full value on your coines because then the owner would not make any money if you want full value for your coines you will need to sell them your self but I can say he will pay you very close to what there worth the owner is fear and will take care of you right away he got me in and got me right out with cash in hand no run around he is good bessness I would definitely think about using him for all your coin needs

Spoke on the phone prior to going to the business. Very nice over the phone and in person along with being very helpful. Gave a great price that was in line with market values! Would recommend anyone to go here to to business!

I Needed a specific Coin to make a peice of jewelry for granddaughter. I Googled and Found this place A HIDDEN GEM of Coins!!!!Im So Happy to of Found what I was looking for.GREAT PRICES & Really Nice to be able TO DEAL WITH THE OWNER & no hidden costs. I Highly Recommend them. 👍

Best price . Great service. Completely satisfied. Thank Buddy.

Very helpful in making decisions about an inheritance, as a person who knows virtually nothing about coins or the process

Best prices in the area, called 5 stores and they by far had the best price.

Went there to cash in some silver coins - checked around, they gave the best price and were very friendly and seem very honest and gave a fair price. Would go back again to do business

Keystone Coin paid more for some coins and bought others that another dealer didnt want. The other dealer didnt want my wheat pennies, silver dollars, roll of uncirculated presidential dollars and a gold cap from a tooth. Keystone bought the wheat pennies for 2 cents, the dollars for $1.10, and the uncirculated Lincoln presidential dollars for, I dont remember how much but the other dealer said they were only worth face value. He also bought the gold cap for $27 when the other dealer said it wasnt even gold.This is the place to go to get a good price. But you do have to be able to tolerate dirt and clutter, lots of dirt and clutter.

I had a really good experience with Buddy who took the time to educate me on junk silver. I appreciated it and will visit again.

Wanted to sell my coin collection. I had done extensive research on the value of each piece of the collection. Called Keystone Rare Coins and set up an appointment to have the collection evaluated. Went in the next day. The transaction went very smoothly. Knowledgeable, polite, and professional! No pressure. No hassle. I received a very fair payment for the collection. Tips for selling coin collections: Be organized! Have the coins and currency separated, organized, and labeled. Be realistic about the value of your coins. Research the value of your rare coins before you sell. You may be surprised to learn that not every old coin is worth more than its face value.

Very good experience. Gave us a fair price for coins and gold.

This is the first time we visited there today. We had a large collection of coins to sell, but were sentimental about. Buddy & Wendy greeted us with kindness and professionalism as we entered the establishment. As Buddy looked over our collections, he made us feel secure about his appraisals of our coins. He was very knowledgeable, and gave us a very great deal over all. We thanked them very much for all their help & honesty. Keystone Rare Coins came highly recommended, & we recommend if you have any questions or concerns about your coin collection to definitely go see them. Theyre very trustworthy!

As the administrator of an estate, I needed to have a small collection of mostly U.S. coins appraised. The attorney for the estate recommended Buddy Kellar at Keystone Coin as a long-standing professional who would use his expert judgment to arrive at a fair value for the coins. That proved to be true.Mr. Kellar appraised the collection without charge. After checking some of the values online, I decided to sell the coins to Keystone; and Mr. Kellar paid a fair price, subject to a reasonable dealers commission. When I had some additional coins to sell, I went back to Keystone to do the deal. So, I join the estate attorney in recommending Mr. Kellar and Keystone. I was very pleased with the service.

Twice I’ve been there to sell and Both time I called ahead . I was quoted a higher price for my silver from the buyer there. I got there and he said he made a mistake . The price he would buy from me was 50% lower then he quoted. The second time I went there I also call 1st. I asked for a quote once again. He quoted me a great price . I even asked 2 times knowing what he was doing. I called back and once again he quoted me the higher price. I said are you sure this is the price per ounce you will pay. They said yes. I got there with my coins and once again he said there was a mistake that he thought it was for two coins. He wouldn’t give me the price quoted over the phone and told me I could go somewhere else and he would match there price. Point is they do this to get you in . They still paid a fair price for my silver but is bad business ethics. I will still go there cause they do pay a fair price I just don’t like the way they get you in there .

Went to other buyers, but they could not match the price from Keystone. No games, best price right up front and very easy to deal with. When you think you have a good deal, you owe it to yourself to get a final price from Buddy at Keystone.

I had a collection I inherited from a family member and it was just collecting dust at the bottom of my closet. I called and asked if I could make an appointment to sit with the owner so they could tell me what I had and the value of it. It was a very comfortable environment and the people were very friendly. I felt they were extremely fair in the prices they offered and they explained everything very well. I would definitely direct anyone to use them.

This small business is great, gave me a great price for my silver and gold pieces. The people who work there are nice and courteous, they are fair, and explain the differences in the quality of products.

I went there today to see what my Grandmothers silver pieces would be worth. The service was very friendly, professional, and knowledgeable. After thoroughly looking at every piece (some were not silver) they gave me a check for over $400! I would recommend this place to anyone who wants a trustworthy opinion of their valuable items.

Went in with some old jewelry and he went though all of it sorted it out and tested some pieces. He also paid the highest price around. Great experience.

The experience with the Keystone was easy from start to finish. We just stopped in without an appointment and the proprietor was cordial and most accommodating. We got the appraisal with no feeling of pressure. We were able to have a smooth transaction from start to finish and we feel the appraisal/sale was honest and accurate. We would definitely recommend Keystone for your coin/gold/silver appraisal and/or sale.

They were very helpful, kind and insightful. We came across old money dating back before WWII and while it has no monetary value he told us the story of how the currency was created and now I can cherish it for its historical value. I will gladly return the next time I come across some interesting coins.

Went to keystone. To start off, raggedy looking establishment. Nothing looks organized everything is old and dirty looking and the staff there match. The customer service is terrible. Some of the women there always have an attitude, and have spoken to me rudely. The owner is unorganized, tends to be unresponsive when called, and shady with business dealings to say the least. He tried to swindle me out of my money and got defensive because I knew better. Id go to a trap house before going to them. If I can offer them a suggestion get a new owner, preferably one who doesnt try to scam you out of your hard earned cash,clean up and practice being nice to people and maybe youll be able to elevate that sorry excuse for a business into something respectable. :)

When I went to sell legitimate gold bars from various precious metal sellers owner tried telling me they were fake, they were not, sold them to A&D on airport road no problem, he examined them and pays cash in higher amounts then keystone will. Do all my business with A&D from now on.

Owner was very accommodating, helpful and honest when looking at coins my parents had collected. He patiently looked through them all and found only a few were worth a little bit of money. Not even worth his time, in my opinion, and I apologized over and over yet the owner was very polite, helpful and kept telling me it was all fine and he was happy to help and do anything he could to help me out. I would definitely recommend him to do business with and if I have to do any coin collecting business, I would go to Keystone Coins. Thank you, Buddy!

Had a collection from my grandfather. I called and they were willing to meet me same day. They were very professional and very personable. Definitely would recommend coming here to do business

A really good experience working with Buddy at Keystone. He offered me a fair deal & Ill gladly return. - Jane in NC

The staff at Keystone Rare Coins are very friendly and polite. They were patient and considerate to all my questions. Buddy was very helpful and very knowledgeable. I would recommend anybody and everybody looking to buy/sell gold or silver to see the staff at Keystone Rare Coins. Very easy to get to.

We had some old coins, the value of which we had no idea. We simply walked in the door at Keystone Rare Coins and were very politely greeted and then directed to sit down at a desk. In short order a very kind gentleman took a close look at our coins and asked whether we were looking for an appraisal or to sell. We replied that initially we just wanted an idea of the values. He kindly offered his opinion of value and invited us to come back if we wished to sell or if we had any further questions. We could not have been more pleased with the service.

Very fair and honest

The people there are extremely nice but I had stamps I wanted to be looked at I had some that weren’t in my book but he said since I had a beginners book of stamps he didn’t even want to look at the collection and now I’m stuck because I have some George Washington stamps that I can find a price for

I highly recommend Keystone Rare Coins. The staff was professional and courteous, and waited on us promptly upon entering. Five stars all the way around for our transaction. * * * * *

I have been a customer of Keystone Rare Coins for about 5 years. I have always felt that their prices, both buying and selling, have always been fair. They are right in line with information that is available online and they are willing to explain the details of the items. I will continue to patronize this business because I know they are one of the few honest shops around.

Maybe a good place to sell, not the greatest to buy. I paid 3 dollars over spot for my silver and Im not even sure it was the current spot price. If you gotta have it here and now its a good place to buy but there are much better prices online.

I recently brought in my old gold jewelry. They were very friendly and answered any questions I had. I got a great price. Better than the other price I got. I would definitely send someone there.

I called for a quote and didnt even get through my first sentence about a gold coin and got hung up on. Go figure! I sure am not taking my stuff there, now or in the future!

Best prices in the valley. I will only go to Keystone with my broken jewelry because they offer the most money and the staff is very well educated at what they do and they are all about the customer and customer satisfaction. Highly recommend to anyone and everyone!

This is an excellent place in Lehigh valley to sell and buy gold and silver and rare coins. Ive been doing business with them numerous times and they are always helpful and honest people. I highly recommend them to anyone.

I took silver & jewelry items to 3 local vendors. Keystone Rare Coins paid top dollars!

Owner is great to deal with. Gives top prices compared to other dealers in the area. Very friendly and knowledgeable. A++++

Pleasant transaction. Very happy with the amount I was given for my items. Thank-you!

I found them online when I was looking for a company to liquidate my fathers coin collection after he passed away. I was truly clueless in how to process everything my father had, knowing that he was an avid collector, not all of which was worth anything. Buddy, the owner, met me at my fathers house, helped me to sort through what he had. We brought the items back to his shop and he and his staff, who were very sweet, went through all the items. I believe they treated me very fairly and helped me make sense of the chaos. They took a very difficult time and made it just a little bit easier for me. I would highly recommend them to anyone who is left with the difficult task of dealing with a loved ones estate.

Disgusting!Poor Customer ServiceShady Business PracticesUnorganizedSexist BehaviorNot Following CDC Business Guidelines

Keystone Rare Coins recently provided me with a great experience selling my silver. They made me feel very comfortable and gave me a great price. I would recommend them to anyone.

We have sold jewelry here and have always been treated fairly and with respect by their very friendly staff. I value the expertise and the service. I went in today to purchase a sixpence for our upcoming Irish wedding.. Guewhat??! Got it for free!

They were wonderful to me with customer service. and very fair in the price they paid me for my late husbands coin collection. I didnt know allot and they didnt take advantage. I recommend them to everyone!!

Very helpful and knowledgeable. Great customer service and extremely informative!

These people are lowballers.. They wanna offer you $20 for 8 silver coins dated back to the early 1900 . remind you the price on silver is $15.42 a ounce and each one weights 10 grams each. Save yourself some time and dont go there.

I was left a lot gold and silver jewlrey from my husband mother. When we decided to sell we went to three other local buying locations. Keystone was by far the paid the highest amount and was the most professional. Would highly recommend them.

This place is amazing gave top price for a silver tray and the guy was so nice.

$42 below spot is the best they can do for 1oz gold. Just FYI

Excellent customer service and fair appraisal. First place Ill go to when I have more to sell.

Best price for my gold jewelry, and a pleasure to deal with.

Staff was friendly and honest.. Definitely recommend!

Man these guys are kind of mean. I came in looking to buy either some silver dollars or half dollars, basically for one purpose. Im thinking of taking a magic course this year, and wanted four decent sized coins to play about with, to learn some slight of hand moves with something more substantial than a quarter. I wanted not great coins, just something I wouldnt care if I wore down, scratched up, etc.. I explained this pretty clearly, and was looking for some scrap silver, basically.I didnt tell them that my wife and I actually do have a small but decent collection of good Sliver coins, and Ive bought coins before. Maybe I should have.Well let me tell you, they treated me like I was a bumpkin. First they tried to up sell me silver proof dollars, which was not really my goal at all, totally not my needs. When I said no to that, they offered me Kennedy half dollars, at about 25% over spot price, by total weight, when I know darn well they are only 40% silver. So they wanted $7.00 per coin on a coin whose melt value is about $2.10. I could take a markup, but that was ridiculous. Their attitude was also awful, they basically made it clear I was wasting their time just even being there. I mentioned the percentage of silver, and that I both looked up the spot value before coming out, and expected a a mark up, but the attitude was the price is the price, and they also made it very clear that they sold LOTS of bags of these and that my trying to buy just four coins was a real pain in the arse, and why was I wasting their time? With the implied, if you are buying only a couple coins how dare you negotiate or criticize our prices?Almost I even agreed to buy the coins, It isnt a lot of money, and traffic has sucked recently. It would have been worth spending the extra ten bucks for my purpose just because I had already driven out. But they dont even take credit cards? I didnt take any cash, and I wasnt about to write them a check, with their attitude. Im kind of glad I they dont take credit cards, after thinking about it, very glad I didnt spend any money there. Let me be clear, for the first time I ever walked in, and a small transaction? I am not obsessed over the price. The entire attitude was sour.Well, poor customer service, sketchy vibe too. Too bad for them, we have considered looking for a place to sell our nice small set of Morgan and Liberty dollars all in good condition. Or also, alternatively to add to it, and fill some holes (which Id prefer) depending on how the finances go this year. I think it is going to be the later. So I was kind of auditioning them with a small transaction. I hoped to find a nice reputable dealer. Lets say they did not meet my expectation of someone Id do future business with.Id stay away. They made it clear they dont want my business, so they arent going to get it.

They are basically theives! They wont even offer spot prices. DO NOT waste your time if your looking to sell your silver. I was offered more at a pawn shop. Horrible people.

Ive done business with them for 20-25 years,and they are reputable and honest .I have gone to other places to sell and buy silver, gold, buillon, jewelry,etc.and they are the best ! Most of the other places I have dealt with are unethical,dishonest,scam artists who havent been around the area for 35 years !!!

Buddy was very fair. I would go again .

This guy tried to swindle me when I caught him he tried to give me 50 extra bucks who does that

Place is a rip off