Seriously one of the best homemade desserts. I always was off with timing when In the area, but luckily got there early, before our dinner reservation and ordered 4 different flavors: fig crumb, chocolate PB, PB campfire & death by chocolate. I can’t even pick a favorite because each tasted better than the next. The owner was super nice and look forward to going back 😍

This Place is amazing. Has the cherry crumb, it was delicious. Would Highly recommend. Owners are extremely pleasant on the phone and in person.

Excellent shop for whoopie type cakes of a variety that changes in a delightful way. The owners are super friendly and the shop is open Thursdays through Saturdays. Good price and great flavors reign! I favor the crumb varieties, but have tried about a dozen others: delicious!

This place is out of this world. I think I am turning into a shuga pie with how many I eat! Good thing they’re only open 3 days a week or else it’d be dangerous… have tried a different flavor each visit and have never been disappointed. Delicious, delectable treats that fit right between your hands!!! Shuga pie shop is the perfect dessert!

Amazing experience for my mouth. Everyone in the family loved it. Im glad its a bit of a drive for me or else I would be 700 lbs. I tried to go a few weeks back around one but the line was so long so I left. Today, I got there at 4:15 and there was no wait.

Deliciously addicting & cooked with compassion! *No animals were harmed in creating these delectables delicacies🤤

First of all, I didn’t get the guy at the windows name but he’s the sweetest person ever. So nice, took time to explain the different flavors & seemed genuinely happy to be there. The pies are FANTASTIC, I ended up getting a bunch so we could do a taste test and we loved all of them. The nutter butter & upside down pineapple were our favorites.

So incredibly yummy!! One bite of these ‘Shuga Pies’ and I was transformed back to my childhood! My husband got me an assortment of these delicious pies for my birthday and each one was more scrumptious than the last. He also couldn’t stop talking about how nice and helpful the owners were. This will absolutely be our new birthday and any special occasion go to!

Worth the wait on the long line! Get here early because they sell out quickly. The owners are the absolute cutest. 😍

The owners of the store are so nice! Also the cake pies are *chefs kiss* delicious. 10/10 recommend

Found this bakery 5 years ago. Best plant based bakery there is. Picked up my Birthday Cake that my wife ordered yesterday. YUMMY!

Finally got to visit the Shuga Pie Shop. Delicious!! You must make the trip, wait if you must, and most of all enjoy!

Im loving this place. The cake is absolutely moist and delicious and their flavor combinations are awesome!👍The walk-up window is so fun.

Can’t STOP.....These shugapies are so Good and addictive...They are freshly made,Melt in your mouth Delicious....and...The owners are so Nice and Friendly....Hope Shugapies pies are Forever🥰🥰🥰🥰

Wow!! Just horrible. Horribly delicious. Tried the chocolate peanut butter and it was so moist and creamy. Even with diabetes, it was so worth it.

Amazing little shop. Everything they make is delicious. Michelin and Terry are amazing and always take time to speak with us (and our dog Rex) and make us feel welcomed and right at home.A hidden secret that you need to visit. Its one of our favorite places, and definitely Rexs favorite.

These are our Sabbath Treats!Theyre worth waiting for...Get yours before they sell out each week!

Wonderful regular and vegan pastry. Everything great!

Abso-lutely Fantastic!

Omg....these r the best ever!!! You wont be sorry!!😉

Excellent!! Service & items!! $3.50 each & they are huge!! (& delicious!!)Check them out

Picked up our shuga pies last weekend for Memorial Day and we had the best experience! I explained i hadn’t been there before and the employees and the owner (i think) were so helpful they told me all the flavors they had left and made it a point to tell me they had vegan flavors and informed me if a flavor i chose was vegan or not. We got holy cannoli, rainbow cookie, birthday cake, death by chocolate and cookies and cream and my whole family loved them we will be coming back!

Simply delicious

Shuga Pie shop is a must-stop if you are in the area. Their cakes have a very home-made feel to them, which brings home so much nostalgia to a Pennsylvanian who grew up with Amish whoopie pies around the home, and they have so many flavors, the most difficult thing you will experience in the day is choosing which ones to consume.Maybe order a bunch and bring them to a potluck or family function, so you can chop them up + share and try many flavors.My only disappointment is that they are not more accessible to us in Manhattan, but we heard rumor that they will be putting up a website soon that will allow for purchases and shipping of their delicious delights all over the country! Get excited!And a bonus - this business is run by very nice people who are passionate about their creations! They work so hard to ensure the customer will be happy and are glad to spend time telling you about the area and recommending other local haunts to check out. Thanks for being such lovely people.

Amazing