A great place for a decently priced pizza for the size. But there are some major flaws I need to address. From the last two photos it shows the stone is not hot enough and doesn’t cook the bottom of the pizza enough and causes it to become soggy and unfold able till you reach closer to the crust. It’s sad since the restaurant advertises as a New York style pizza. Besides that, it isn’t too greasy and is quite quick. As for the sandwich, I would say it was the best item, bread was not soggy and meat was flavorful.Overall, a good pizza for the size and price, but would go else where for a quality experience.

This place is Amazing, food is delicious. Staff is friendly. Super clean inside. My family and I love this place

Went to celebrate a Graduation & Birthday. The staff was so accommodating, and nice. Memories were made at My New York Pizza, thank you. The food was fantastic. Bring your appetite. My New York Pizza will not disappoint.

Great Pizza and even greater customer service, place is nice and clean and the food is great . 14in pizza slice is no joke 🔥

Youre Probably not gonna want any other pizza. Slices are huge and flavors are incredible .and dont forget the wings A¹

My daughter had a school fundraiser at this place. So we decided to go and pick up dinner. My order was taken at 6:09pm and I was told 15-20 min was my wait. 20 min went by and I thought I heard them call my name, I went to check on my order and the same guy now said its going to be about 20 min. I said you told me that 25 min ago. He said they were busy. I sat back down watching everyone after me get their food. Then a lady came and said that the order was never put in and they are rushing my order. The only reason I stayed so long was because I was trying to support the school. After another 15 min I asked again and they said 5 more minutes. At 6:57pm I decided they are not worth my business since Im obviously not a priority as Im there waiting for almost an hour with my 6 yr old daughter bored. So I asked for my money back and left. I asked to speak to the manager and Betty never came out. Terrible way to run a business and will not be going back. **That response from the owner should tell you exactly the kind of service they lacked, just like that unprofessional response. Definitely not fast food, What is your response to every other order after me getting their food?? Nothing was done to make the situation better. VERY UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS

Very good food. Super busy so plan ahead

Great Service and very delicious pizza with well done crispy crust. Way better than any corporate chain pizza place.

A great place to visit if you want a quick cheap pizza with a slice big enough to be a meal. Many ingredient choices, create your type of pizza. A friendly environment. 4.5 stars, I mostly tried the pizza. I wish I had the time to try other things

Fun and kool place to eat pizza good wings are good the beer cold well definitely be coming back.

Amazing pizza spot. This business knows how to cook quality food. I highly recommend their pastrami fries and sandwiches. The pizzas taste amazing and they have wings too! They conduct great business right now during the pandemic and you should get your lunch and dinner from here!

This plane is always amazing delicious... we got the biggest pizza!The dough and the pizza sauce its AMAZING!!!!great customer service!!

Great service!!! Food excellent!!! I drove from El Monte to pick it up!!! The pizza has a good flavor & the wings are good as well!! I had 3 flavors Buffalo, BBQ, & the Cajun Rub.

This place is the Bomb. Heidi can make some bomb Food. She is the best. Thank you I will tell all my friends and family and look forward to seeing us soon.

Called in over an hour before closing and was told that they are no longer taking orders or guest. What? You would assume that as I try to support our local business they would be happy to help. I guess not. If Im the owner I would be concerned. Sounds absurd to deny service and send what can be a long time customer elsewhere. What a first impression..... smh.. this did not sit well me me.

Was here for the Extreme Stangz car show and had the NY Slice, $13 pretty big slice, filled us up. Not too greasy, thin crust, cheesy, I enjoyed it. Yum!

Order ahead so you dont have to wait, even if youre only getting a couple slices! Great pizza and friendly service!

Espania set a new record ate a 30 inch Pie in 16:20, store will.varify they recorded The event, Awesome hosts,Great Flavors,plenty of Seating,to, go orders available,utube the the new pie record will love to attend, the next attempt at lowering the the time.JBMBENTERPRISE.

Drove out with the wife and kids to find a NY style pizza since I seen one on TV and was craving to try one out. Its was good for what it is. Not 100% sure if this is authentic NY style since Im not familiar with NY style pizza. I probably could have rated it a 3 but I feel it was a fun enough experience for me and the kids. The pepperoni pizzas were a bit over cooked and my ladies Alfredo chicken was a bit doughy. The salad was good but the ceasar dressing tasted like it had thousand island mixed in with it but maybe that was authentic ceasar dressing I really dont know but I know I did eat it. My girl got a calzone but it came out by the time we were already done with out pizzas, and our appetizer garlic bread came out after our pizza too. The garlic bread was heavy oiled and the marinara sauce was fridge cold and a bit watery. I would say their prices are a bit overpriced but not by much. The server was a nice young man. But maybe some inexperience all things considered I still had fun eating a giant pizza slice and spending time with my kids and wife. Food is probably a 6/10. The environment 7/10. Menu would make me return. They have beer on tap I would like to come try with some buddies. But I would/ will definitely come back with my kids, since they enjoyed the pizzas. We came and sat down it was empty but there is large seating arrangements and plenty of TV with games on. They had basketball on one baseball highlight on another. So next time I might just catch a game with a beer and pizza with a couple of local friends. Its a bit on the adult level you wont find kids games and prizes here, but a buncha beers on tap and some pizza to wash them down.

Got the lunch special NY cheese pizza slice, salad, and drink for $9.99 she graciously upgraded my normal house salad to a Caesar salad without charging.The Caesar salad was great. Tasted authentic and the home made Caesar sauce was deliciousThe pizza was unexpectedly massive. I just barely finished it. Tasted great as well

We been here before the pandemic and we had a great time. Today was a litter quiet, yet great pizza and Betty is awesome with here aKind demeanor and great service. Thank you we are very appreciative.

Seriously the best pizza I’ve ever had! Really close to my home so I’ll defiantly be here like once a week! Sooo good and very reasonably priced!

This is our go to place for pizzas. For a large thin crust veggie pizza, they have the perfect flavor. Have been ordering here for more than a year.

Best pizza in Fontana!!

This pizzeria is a gem hiding in plain sight 😍 for starters the food is delish. I’ve had their pizza, Caesar salad, wings and onion rings (not all in one sitting of course ha!ha!) their salad is always fresh there is nothing more that I dislike than when you get brown lettuce on a salad. Luckily this is not the case here. Their chicken is delish and so is the dressing. The staff is always courteous and efficient and even though this is a sports bar I believe to be family friendly but keep in mind that I have visited during the week during the day. I have no clue how it is at nighttime and on the weekends. When I have visited I’ve taken my kiddo and she enjoys the pepperoni pizza. I have seen other families with their little one eating here as well. I totally forgot to take pics when I’ve gone but I’ll be sure to take some in the future. Overall the ambiance is great, the food delish and the staff courteous. It always appears to be clean and it’s a great place to grab a bite to eat alone or with friends.

The decorations are fantastic for the sports fanatics!! I ordered the 14in slice and 6 wing. The wings were pretty good and the slice needed some cheese and pepperoni lol. Over all not a bad experience.

This is great pizza! My picky kids rave how good it is. Busy place which says a whole lot. We will be repeating customers.

This is a real pizza joint! They serve a giant 14in slice and have some amazing wings. Staff is extremely friendly and lots of TVs.

By far one of my top 5 pizza places around! Just had the pleasure of trying their new “machete slice and it was off the charts delicious. Great balance of spice and traditional pizza flavors. The sandwiches tho Oof Maron..forget about it” delicious as well! Hats off to the chef! 🙏

This was my first time going and the experience was wonderful. Very friendly atmosphere and staff. Great food too. I ordered the 14 inch giant slice of pepperoni and sausage pizza. Simply delicious. A must reccomended place 👍👍👍

Great N.Y. style pizza. Thin crust great tasting pepperoni and sauce! Delicious wings. They also have lunch specials. Beer specials during football

Pizza was good service was a little slow but not too bad.

Great pizza...employees were wonderful

Great place to catch a Galaxy game

Im sorry but we were barely greeted. Then passed off to a 2nd person to repeat our order to. Our bread was toasted to edges burnt. For 9.99 6 sandwiches customers should be asked if they want their bread toasted or not. Not open inside. They have 2 tables outside, not clean or comfortable, no trash can outside and left over cups on tables. Sandwiches were ok and fries decent. Their was a gnat in my beer

Chicken breast club sandwich & fries 😋

No offense when I took a bite of the pizza...I thought I felt some delicious toppings and cheese on it however I felt as though I taste it flat as cardboard.

OMG!We found this Fontana gem and let me tell you the pizza is just delicious 🍕We had the Mexican Pizza and is to DIE FOR!We most definitely found the spot in Fontana

Finally found authentic N.Y. style pizza in Southern California! Pepperoni slice was a giant 14” that was thin and flexible! I like it a little crispy on the bottom and it was! Spice and sauce was spot on with a dash of oregano and good thin pepperoni too! We ordered a 6-piece wing extra crispy and they were! Hot sauce was just like real Buffalo wing sauce! Yay! Even the blue cheese side was good! Great job and thanks! @mynypizza #nypizza #ilovepizza

I have been wanting to try this place and i did and it was not what i expected not traditional ny pizza is a spin on it and not what i wanted....some may like it but not for me. The big slice looked and tasted old the heart shape pizza was better. If your looking for the real ny pizza this is not that its there own spin on it.

If you havent been here you are missing out. Delicious food and great customer service

This is the place to get wings and pizza in the IE .. Fontana to be exact. Give up on wing stop and bww .. Try this place. Will not be disappointed.

Pizza is delicious. One slice usually feeds my 12 y/o and its always worth the wait

Food is good, but every time we order online and arrive 5 min after said time we always have to wait another half hour because they never started it.

The food is great, its why Ive had it a few times. Its the service that I have an issue with. My order has never been ready on time whether during a busy weekend rush or at the end of the night on a Monday its always a wait thats never explained

Place is great! Food, drinks, atmosphere, everything totally worth the price

1st time buyer, amazing quality, friendly staff and a plethora of topping options. 14inch slices are truly an experience for all to enjoy

Well i love there pizza and betty & jose are. Really good friends of mine and they care for everyone that comes and getts pizza from n.y.pizza that why tjey are the best pizza in town dont forget n.yPizza is the greatest pizza place in fontana and thats the truth onest ingen ok

We got the big slice of pizza and mild wings. It was actually pretty good and filling for two people.

My Favorite place to get pizza. The only thing I would suggest is to pick it up. Doordash has a tendency to be late. But when the restaurant delivers they deliver quicker then door dash.Try it you wont be disappointed and if you are call me and Ill eat it for you 😉

This was my first time here n Im pretty sure I will be visiting again..Very clean n the pizza n chicken wings are very yummy..The staff is friendly and helpful when ordering..Me and some Friends went to watch the Lakers game n we are deaf so they understood that..Good place to watch a Lakers game IT was actually full of fans watching the game..Thank you for everything..

To expensive, 6 inch sandwich French fries and soda almost $19 crazy

This pizza is great! The pizza is different than most places and a great choice to feed a lot of people. The ranch is pricey however. They only sell them by the small cup for $1. Tried to buy a larger portion a few times now with no luck.

Meat lovers it was delicious

We got the giant pizza and while is was huge and fed 6 of us, it was kind of dry and not enough cheese. The staff was friendly, but we probably wont be back.

Great place! Pizza was amazing and I love the super large slices. 🙂 My N.Y. rocks.

Delicious and great service too. I will be back!

I was a little skeptical when we ordered the gimmick size 28 pizza that we did, but man was I glad we did!! This thing had amazing flavor and was actually cooked very well for its size. It was flavorful and crispy all the way through! It fed roughly 11 individuals, kids and adults. Would HIGHLY recommend. Sad that I live in KY but will be adding this to our go tos when we visit California!

Not only is the pizza huge, its delicious!! When I think of authentic pizza, this is what I picture! Worth the drive!

Its the small things that count for me!! I ordered delivery today to my job, the spaghetti and homemade meat balls. It comes with a side salad and garlic bread. I asked for parmesan cheese and ranch dressing neither came with my order. I also asked the person who took my order to make sure the delivery person had change so I could leave a tip and of course he did not. The spaghetti was not that good either, it was basically noodles topped with canned tomatoes with melted cheese on top and sliced frozen meatballs on top of that smh. The garlic bread came in a pizza box.

Pizza was good. Try the chorizo pizza. Its spicy and delicious. Wings were also very good. Definitely a place to come back and eat with them family

Great food, very tasty, the times I been there, the wait is always a little more than theyre expected ready time

Excellent pizza and cheese steak sandwich 😋

14 slice is one of my favorite. Not to mention the michelada AHHMAZING!!! Tried the wings this time and also very delicious 😋

I come from Ontario to get this Pizza atleast once a month the Pizza is crazy good, plus the Wings are 🔥 as well ! Alot to choose from, I love how Family Oriented it is and I will keep coming back for more!...........

Really good pie, I recommend it. They placed a side of sauce in the pizza box, I swear its like gold... delicious. Also ordered garlic knots, and garlic bread also really good. This was our first time there, were trying different pizzas from our area and I must say this was one out favorites. Will be back, but next time I will order from their website instead of Google better prices. Think we found our new pizza spot.

Had to try this place out, and yeah its FN great!!👍👍👍👍👍

Great food and excellent service

ComeOn NOWW! 🧐 THIS FAMILY / PIZZA JOINT HAS BEEN HERE FOR YRS ALLREADY!! IF YOUU HAVE NNOTT BEEN HERE FOR ONE OF THEIR Lunch deal$ a 🍕 HUUGE SLICE OF PIZZA w/ a SODA.OR a Bud-Light (Ugetachoice😃) orSTOP BY and pick up THEE LARGEST NY PIZZA IN FONTANA.. (Great for parties) w/ a FRESH SALAD to feed THE FAM & FRIENDS.. U WILL HAVE ENOUGH..

Great pizza!! Awesome service. Big guy with the beard was really cool!!! See you soon

Best pizza around. Pastrami pizza is AMAZING

Great quantity poor quality. Huge slices of NY style pizza with no flavor, tastes like card board.

Great big pizza, friendly staff.

Love this place!! Deffinatly my go to for Pizza. Everyone is always very friendly, the food it amazing they dont only have good pizza! I deffinatly recommend giving them a try if you havent already.

I Love The Pizza Here It Is So Good And The Staff Is Really Nice

Best pizza and wings around.

The food is good ! Staff is friendly ! The servings are really big I recommend this place

I order a large pizza but what I got was a larger size. Supposedly they made a mistake and made a larger size. But the only reason was that it must of been some order that never got picked up because when I got home the pizza was old, cold, and the ends were hard. Its my last visit here. Its unfair for them to do this and karma should be coming your way and shame on you guys for tricking a hard working person who only wanted to treat her kids. How rude!!!!

Hi!. Ok its my first time trying out this place and actually my best friend from Burbank came down to Fontana so that we can try this place out. 🍕 looks super delicious and cant wait to bite in.

Great ambience and quality food. Love the seasonings on the garlic fries and enjoyed the pizza.

Pizza was very delicious, it did not disappoint. Pizza lovers this is your stop.

Went there a couple weeks ago and got a calzone, an order of garlic knots and an order of jalapeno poppers and they were delicious. The owners were extremely helpful. Great customer service.

Had a dash order pick up from here. Very Clean. Food smells awesome. Will have to try in order to give more stars.

Great pizza and salads. Quality service in-house, carry-out, or delivery (via Grubhub, etc.). Good beer for enjoying some sports in house! Gotta love the giant slices, too (I like the pastrami one). We also regularly get the veggie pizza. Salads are always fresh, well portioned, and balanced with toppings.

Very nice and delicious

This is where you get them very large sized sweet tasty pizzas.

Great food!

Food is good service needs improvement given it 4 stars 🌟 for the food

The pizza and wings are great. I love this place and it is my go to for pizza. The only reason why im giving 3 stars Is because they’re never accurate and their estimated time. It goes from 30 mins to over an hour. Just tell me an hour in case it does take that long if not even better cause I’ll think “damn they’re fast”

Best pizza sports bar around town. Trust you wont be disappointed.!

I got the pizza to go when I picked up the box I thought the box was empty. Not for me.

Awesome! My first time trying this place and the family loved it!

We phone in ordered and they said it would take a half hour we arrived a little early half hour came and went it took an hour and I ordered wings pizza and a Antipasta salad the pizza was a little greasy the wings were kind of dry and the salad was watery but we did Eat everything it was OK just not that great

Got a large pizza delivered today. My office is 5 minutes from the restaurant. This was probably the worst pizza Ive ever had. It looked and tasted as if it was made yesterday and sat out. How is it not fresh when Im so close? Bad. Sorry for the bad review. Ive heard that the food is good here.

Not Good.... Well, we asked for the pizza to be cut in squares and we wanted extra sauce because we dont like dry pizza. We respectfully asked the girl on phone to PLEASE double check on these simple requests. The pizza was cut in triangles (not squares) and there was hardly any sauce on the pizza (dry pizza). Very disappointed.......

Tha BEST wings, pizza and Stromboli, wonderful staff, fast service. We wont go anywhere else for wings, great variety of flavors too.

Pizza is so good

Love this place.

To long of wait too expensive for one slice

Love that pizza.