Great butchers, great variety, custom cuts. A great product sold by super nice people

Pete and staff are the best around! I been going there for years the quality is top notch and the service is fantastic. They acknowledge all their customers on first name basis which you wont find at any corporate run butcher shop. Will continue to shop there strongly suggest giving them a try!

Delicious home made meals. Great selection of burgers. Love their peter luger and steak burgers. Potato salad, Macaroni salad and chicken salads are one of the best. Definitely worth visiting. It wont disappoint

Awesome people. I go every week, and I am NEVER disappointed. Must try ALL their homemade salads, soups, and their spinach dip is unbelievably good. They know your name, and treat you like family. Wish I could give more than 5 stars. 👍

Now this is a real Meat Marget. Still have saw dust on the floor. Very knowledgeable about Meats & different things. Very,very friendly and attentive

Best meat market i been to!!!! The service is awesome and the people are very helpful and friendly. They have a great selection of prime meats and cooked food. They go out of their way to accommodate your needs. I wont be going anywhere else for my meat now on.

I’m giving more stars because it is family owned but I went in for the first time yesterday and they did not have much to offer as far as meat. I ended up asking for baby back ribs which was $7.99 a pound. He brought them out frozen and packaged like any other grocer. I was disappointed but no big deal until I stopped by stop and shop to grab a few things and the EXACT same ribs and packaging were there but $4.99 a pound. I totally understand that stop and shop buys in bulk and gets a better deal and I would not have minded but I went to the market for fresh meat not the same thing the grocery stores sell.

An excellent establishment for the community. They make you feel like family. Pete Sr. helped me out selecting a tender, juicy, full of flavor and completely satisfying steak. The sweet Italian sausages were great as well. I plan to visit frequently this summer.

From the moment you walk in you are greeted with a warm hello. After a few times in everyone knows your name, and treats you like your there only customer. The meat is top shelf from the aged steaks to the pork bones for Sunday sauce. I can’t say enough about this place, just wish more places where the same

Excellent experience.... Perfect customer service.... excellent cuts and prices!! Professional and welcoming!! I will be back in no time. I wish I could give 10 stars

I only buy meat at their shop. Pete & Pete and everyone there are great. Quality meat, great salads and sides, and a terrific and friendly atmosphere. Top notch.

This place makes you feel like family! The service is second to none and the food is ABSOLUTELY delicious EVERY TIME!!!

Bought my Easter holiday jam, it was great. Cooked well, I received great instructions on how to hear it and it was delicious! Thanks

Great selection of steaks, pork and chicken. Prepared foods are delicious. Very nice family working behind the counter.

Awesome local business, very friendly

Great steaks and great service!

I just adore these guys! The best service and the best quality foods! I basically live on the prepared meals because who needs to cook ;) All options from soups, salads and tons more! So happy they are here in my town. They make you feel like family.

I’ve gotten an Italian hero from here twice now and both times were delicious. They give a great portion, and everyone there is so friendly! Really nice people who work here, I would recommend.

Family owned neat shop. Cant say enough about these guys here they are the best around ! If youre really into your steaks like i am, you know how special dry aged steaks and truffle butter can be. One stop shop for all your premade sides and beautiful steaks cut to your desired width. Never have to step in a grocery store again they have all you need.Keep up the great work guys !

Family oriented, friendly, knowledgeable and reasonably priced. First time there and wont be last.

First off, the heroes do not come in small sizes, I figured let me try the full size Italian hero. $25. Overpriced for the quality. The bread was so tough and hard, that the corners of my mouth... the gums were in really bad pain for a few weeks. Thought my teeth had to get pulled. I had to see a dentist because of it. Won’t go back. Nope 👎🏼

Everything I have ever bought here has been excellent quality! I travel from 4 towns away just to buy my meats here!! Great service and on point cooking tips for whatever you buy. Highly recommend

Fantastic service, prices and nothing but top quality. I would never consider going anywhere else. I love this place!

Outstanding place, wont find better quality meat from any other butcher on the island its absolutely delicious and clean. The place has a really nice old school feel inside and the owner is one of the nicest people ive ever met. Highly recommend this butcher if your looking for fresh grassfed cuts of meat.

First time curbside pick up last week and it was great. Cant wait to order this week. Loved the gorgonzola, cranberry, walnut salad and the meats were perfect. I was craving a sirloin burger and it hit the spot! I was able to also get a nice crusty italian bread. Thanks for the great service during this awful time!

Extremely friendly, courteous and professional. Have never had a bad experience. High quality meat and love the sides too! Can’t go wrong here.

Great place to buy meat and chat, Pete and Pete are 2 great guys and the food is great stop by you will not be disappointed

Always accommodating and helpful... cookn suggestionsand top quality meat.. just a great local family run butcher.

We got several holiday meals from them. Great food & service is stellar

Excellent selection and top quality meats! Friendly, personable owner who takes pride in his work and customer satisfaction. Well worth the trip. You won’t be disappointed.

Cant say enough good things. They know your name, they know your likes and dislikes...they get to know your family. In an age of digital, impersonal service they epitomize old-fashioned customer service. IMO: they also happen to have the best steak burgers. Happy these butchers serve Islip.

This is my go to place for meat and eats.Pete and his crew are the very best!

Absolutely wonderful service, the people are very friendly. Its nice to walk into somewhere and have someone help you with a smile on their face! They are very willing to help. Also the place looks and smells very clean!

It was like the German butcher from my childhood...there was sawdust on the floor. There was a great selection. The butcher was very knowledgeable and friendly.

Great meats love that they are grass fed and antibiotic free. You can taste the difference. The owners are very personable and friendly. I live about twenty minutes away but it is so worth the drive for fresh clean meats.

Great family owned business clean & friendly service . Top notch in every way!

The owner is a true professional and a great guy. Only quality meats are sold here. Old world style and charm. Family run business with the personal touch.

Outstanding quality of all meats and friendly hometown willingness to satisfy

Everything fresh and delicious! Better than any supermarket!

Best meat market I’ve had the pleasure of going to on Long Island.

Was there once and will definitely go back...just wish they were open mondays.

Ive purchased pork bellies, prime sirloins, smoked pork chops and chop meat from this prime meat butcher. Always great quality and friendly service. Well worth the drive and price!

Stopped in for a Turkey, left with some delicious sopressata, skirt steak, provolone and more! The dry aged steaks looked serious, will be stopping back in for a few slabs of those. Love the old school feel of the place, and they have a great location. Go see the Petes for the meats!

Go here for all your meats! These guys are awesome and every meal I cook using something I picked up here tastes better and I cant take the credit!

Love this place Old-school charm excellent meats friendly service highly recommend it

Wheres the beef?? at Islip Meat Market... EVERYONE should go there. We love it and wont buy our meat anywhere else.

Great butcher! The bacon is memorable, the steaks are magical and the customer service is legendary!

Old world butcher. Best place for picking up meats and more for dinner, bbq, family and friends.The owner is very friendly and gives back to the community.

Great guys love this place !

My family and I love The Islip Meat Market . Its such a happy place ! Great owners .! Never disappointed . Great music too .

Quality Product, Quality Service. Shop local! BEST PRE-MADE meatballs ever!!!!!!!👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

I was absolutely taken back to an era, of bobby socks and poodle skirts were a happening thing. A sense of nostaglia reminiscing about the walls of this gem that has Islip writen all over it. Islip Meat Market sure serves up a nice slab of USDA grade A meat. The gentleman behind the counter was the jolliest of souls that you could ever meet. Pleasure doing my first service with you, kind friend at Islip Meat Market.

Best aged steaks youll ever have stands up to peter luger and Bryant and Cooper

Friendly atmosphere, quality products, super service

Very friendly and they have great meat. I will be back soon!

Erhard ran it as an old world butcher shop which was what I enjoyed. Lets see how the new owners do

I have been purchasing all my meats from this store for over 30 years. My family and guests rave about the quality!! A must...

Amazing quality and service!

Great customer service