What ISN’T good here?! My family and I absolutely love Manhattan Sweets. We do wish they they would bring back their cake bars but in the meantime we’re happy to taste all of their other cakes, cookies and cupcakes!

I had one of the most amazing experience at Manhattan Bakery. The server was very helpful, kind and patience. Thank you so much guys my baby Christening cake was delicious. I will refer you guys to my friends and I will definitely come by again ❣

Beautiful and delicious cake! Very accommodating bakery with knowledgeable and pleasant staff. Highly recommend!!

After Stanleys totally dropped the ball and forgot to make my cake, manhattan sweets was a life saver and made a beautiful 1st birthday cake for my daughter in 1 hour! It tasted as good as it looked. 10/10 customer service and taste. Manhattan sweets is my new bakery. Bye bye stanleys.

Manhattan Bakery made the most beautiful Christening cake for my granddaughter that I could have ever imagined! It was a Shore stopper! Additionally they made rainbow cake pops that were honestly out of this world! Best bakery on LI!

A hidden jem, delicious

The sweet lady at the counter was very patient and very helpful. The place was very clean and decorated uniquely and very tastefully. We got an assortment of random treats and they were fresh and worth the trip . I will be returning.

I cant get enough of their beautiful and delicious creations. I go there all the way from Queens and is totally worth it because every bite is heaven!!!

I am going to this Bakery since they opened. I moved from Bay Shore to East Northport 3 years ago and go back to them for every occasion and Holiday. Cakes, treats and gifts are awesome. Even their dog treats are my pups favorite......

This place has the nicest cakes! It *is* pricey but if you want that special effect, this is where to get it. Even boxed with a sticker and ribbon. Got a gorgeous cake for my daughter and it weighs about 5lbs.

Best bakery ever ! I’m never going to get sweets anywhere else this is it ! It’s so good you just want to try everything ! I will keep coming back for more

Always fresh,always special,always rave review whoever experience any creation from Manhattan sweets!

My favorite Bakery! Got a Rainbow cheesecake for my moms birthday and everyone was in love with it!

Favorite bakery in town. Rainbow cookie cupcakes AND the full sized cake are delicious. My other go to treats are the pink & white cookies and the apple turnovers. I have brought the cookies and cream, red velvet and the carrot cupcakes to parties and have been told theyre delicious! The staff is always so friendly and helpful, theres one girl that always helps me when I go there and shes a delight! (Sadly I keep forgetting to ask her name because I have treats on my brain)

Always fresh and new holiday desserts.

Wonderful experience! I placed a birthday order for delivery, the staff was extremely helpful throughout the entire process. The gluten free cake and treats were decorated and wrapped beautifully and they were delicious!

Owner is very rude and thinks she’s awesome. Her customer service is horrific. I would definitely go to a different bakery. They built a name brand but their product and customer service is on a massive decline!!!

Outstanding, delicious, unique, expertly-baked items that are a pure delight. 🎂

The best sweets and customer service! A must visit!

Excellent rainbow cookie cupcakes! Flowers chocolate cake is absolutely Divine highly recommend. Excellent customer service extremely friendly staff!

Owner is rude and nasty. I will never go back. Through all of the 25 plus cakes that I have already purchased from the bakery I have never dealt with the owner. She deliberately would not give me the cake I ordered knowing full well that my party was that day and I would have no cake for a friends 50th birthday party. All because I told her it wasnt like the picture that I supplied when ordering. I told her I would take it anyway, no big deal but she chose to spite me.

OMG. We went to this bakery on a hunch we took. We were not disappointed!!! the people in this place are just amazing! helpful knowledgeable and everything we tasted was good and delicious. we came home with a log cake, cookies, cupcakes and a black n white cookie! oh and the pignoli cookies were put into two boxes after the lady found out I was giving some to my father!!!! she went way above board on my transaction. very very pleased!!!!

Quality and fresh baked products. I will go back.

I stopped in last week to order a cake for my daughters 21st birthday, The girl behind the counter, Ashley was so friendly and so knowledgeable. She effortlessly helped me with all the details to design the exact cake I had in mind.The cake came out perfect, it was beautiful and delicious. The guests at the party raved about how delicious it was. I would absolutely use Manhattan Sweets for my next event.

This place is incredible! Everything I have ever had from this bakery has been delicious. I get all our baked goods here now and my family and friends al love it. Cant recommend Manhattan Sweets enough!

Bought a dozen donuts for a BBQ. Purchased assorted speciality donuts. Absolutely amazing.

The birthday cake I bought was delicious. The rolls were spot on good.

Great New York bakery. Do not go there hungry.It is hard to pick from all that deliciousness.The pastries I had were exceptional.Highly recommended.

I absolutely love this place! Aside from having the best rainbow bars, they are at the top of my list of places to buy desserts from because I had ordered cookies to Las Vegas, and it was so hot they melted. They had offered me a full refund! I will always go here when I need a unique delicious dessert!

Saved me in a pinch ! So, I was doing a last minute gender reveal and I stopped in here to ask for some cupcakes filled with a special color for the gender. The women who helped me was amazing!!!! After I was turned away from other bakeries she did it for me and they were beautiful and tasty ! Thank you again !!!!!

The chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate mousse was delicious.

On Monday I bought rainbow cookie cupcakes for my daughters birthday. We usually use our local bakery but I was in search for these specific cupcakes. The place is amazing and the cupcakes were soooooo goooood!!!!!We will definitely be back again! Thank you!

Finally found a phenomenal bakery! Ive been there twice now and tried a variety of their items (rainbow cookies, rainbow cookie crumb cake, doughnuts, linzer tart, ...), with none of them short of delectable. Their cookies and cream doughtnut was a collection of heaven in a perfect circle.Staff was also very kind and welcoming on both occasions, making the experience even more pleasurable.I look forward to going back next time I need any type of dessert. Highly recommend stopping by if you havent yet, you wont be disappointed!

They have so many beautifully decorated cake ready to pick up and the ladies were so polite and patient. The strawberry shortcake and the cannoli cake were wonderful.

Yes, I am one of the boneheads wandering and shopping the island for goods during a pandemic. I needed eggs, sue me. I passed this place on the way to the meat market a few doors down and decided to check it out. I honestly cant think of a better time to get some mental health donuts and boy did this place deliver. I got the chocolate glazed donuts, chocolate and peanut butter donuts and maple bacon donuts. The donuts were super fresh and moist unlike some other fancy baked goods places that shall not be named. The bacon on the maple donuts would have been better had it been crisper but delicious nonetheless. The peanut butter chocolate donuts were excellent, very good balance of flavors. Had a pretty good selection of standard fare, cookies, cakes, cupcakes and those giant claw things. Staff was ok, quick to help. Cant wait to go back and pick up some more end of the world might as well sugar it up snacks.

Best bakery I’ve been to in a long time! Their big chocolate chip and peanut butter cookies are to die for! I cannot wait to try everything else. This is my new go to bakery for sure and I will travel here as I’m not local.

The mousse cake is to die for. A must have for a small birthday cake for a loved one or just because it is on the pricier side though - still worth it

Good quality cakes but very high priced

Everything is to die for. I dont live very close but I drive the distance to come here for special occasions.

This has to be the best bakery we have been to! I have never had Rainbow Cookies that have been so moist in my life. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Wow! The 🌈 cookie cupcakes, 🌈 cookie black + white s, and the cake bites are out of this world delicious! Thank you for making my mouth happy!

They did a 1/2 sheet cake for my moms 75th, and iit looked beautiful, and tasted great. White cake with fresh fruit filling, and tiramisu. Voters ruled on the fruit!

We love the sweets there. Great place for birthday cakes too!!

A Great selelection of quality Bakery goods. Nice staff of knowledgeable workers. They have a rewards program. Unfortunately when you pay cash or credit you do not receive a itemized bill for what you purchased...

2nd time visiting and not disappointed!

Best cakes ever!!

The cake was so good, this store is going to be one on my favorites

The icing is labeled as “buttercream” however the consistency is more like a a whipped cream. As someone who does not like whipped cream in any fashion I was thoroughly disappointed. The cake itself was good but the buttercream simply just was not. It was whipped cream with powdered sugar.

The fruit tart is the only cake they make with fresh fruit ( unless you special order). Very unique fruit tart. Nice crust with a layer of jam, thin layer of vanilla cake, pastry cream ontop with lots of berries. Would recommend!

Just finished a 50g pack of Manhattan Chewy Mints..... And the comfort of pleasures it brings to your tongue is undescribable.... Its perfect mixture of sugar and mint in my mouth leave me fishing for more..... Manhattan sweets omg just taste one and taste the pleasure of sweet minty love....Congrats to you artist of flavours

Exciting boutique bakery with excellent customer service. The pastry chef creates the Wow in every bite of any selection. There are treats for your pets and you can purchase a unique gift to present along with your dessert.

Just to say... BEST EVER BOUTIQUE BAKERY!! everything is just perfectly made! The greeting as soon you are in this establishment is just bababoom wonderful! Beautiful decor very pleasant to the eyes! The taste of everything made at Manhattan sweets is just AMAZING BABABOOM PARTY IN MY MOUTH! they have options for people who only can eat gluten free. BABABOOM FOR ME!! The place is super clean. I recommend this bakery boutique 100% kisses and hugs king size. Happy safe 2020 muuuuah

Got cupcakes here for the wifes birthday, were very good. Only thing is this spot is very expensive. $27 for six cupcakes, yikes!

Excellent bakery.

I have to agree with the previous review. I would pass this bakery almost everyday and it looked so appealing. Love the decor of the shop...but woman behind the counter was so nasty I never went back. Which is a shame because I did buy a red velvet cake that was pretty good. I would never give them my business again.

Excellent customer service and delicious cakes

If your looking for a upscale bakery you have found it! They have some of the most delish cupcakes, all decorated so beautifully. A nice selection of cakes, cookies, & some of their own specialty items.Special events... you want to make an impression then have them create a cake for you, All wrapped so pretty, just look for the pink box!

Artsy, beautiful looking dessert thats really tasty. Also, fresh breads, rolls, coffee, special orders.

Nice place with better quality

Excellent service and beautiful treats!

Love everything

I ordered gender reveal pop cakes from this bakery. Not only were they perfect for revealing our surprise, but delicious I couldnt help but eat 3 cake pops. Thank you.

They have amazing variety of pastries, homemade donuts and the best macaroons in Suffolk County! My family and I come at least every other week.

Rainbow cookies were great!

Best damn rainbow cake/ cookies/ cupcakes everrrr in life.

Delightful experience. Everything delicious

They, just flat out, have the BEST cakes around! Great service and great cake, you cant go wrong here!

Exotic pastries and are also priced that way

Love this store they have really nice fancy cakes and many others desserts

A lovely place delicious desserts

Great place a little pricey, but worth it.

Delish had a berry cake was soo good !

Excellent bakery. love it.

A quality bake shop with a nice selection. I pass many other bakeries to shop here.

Their rainbow cookie cupcakes are the best desert to ever exist!

My go to place when I need baked goods in a pinch. Always a safe bet

Best cookies ever!

Yummy, yummy, yummy. Delicious cookies, cupcakes and cakes

Their chocolate mousse cheesecake is to die for!!!

Lovely and creative design

Excellent food

Nice place.very good

The best bakery

Sounds very promising. Looking forward to a tasting

Good cakes 🍰

So tasty, always a treat!!

The rainbow cookie cupcakes are beyond amazing !!!!!

BEST

Beautifully made treats

Different

Yummy!!

Nice staff

Great deserts

Our favorite bakery!