Really good looking cupcakes here. They taste great but I wouldn’t say they’re the best in the world. I have had better but these are super delicious. If you’re nearby and in the mood for sugar then definitely stop by here! My wife absolutely loves them!

I ordered a cake for my wife’s 40th birthday party from Sweet Tooth Fairy and they exceeded expectations. The cake was as beautiful as it was delicious. We ordered WAY too much and every morsel got eaten. I highly recommend using them for any event as they delivered exactly what I had hoped for.

Went when it opened years back with friends. That time was good. Went there just today with family.... We wont be returning. Ordered cookies to split, and share.I decided to ask what cupcake would be recommended. The worker said strawberry shortcake so I went with it. The berry was rotting. This deterred my family from trying it, but not I! I cut the rotting bit off, and decided to try it. To my dismay the cake was soggy, and sticky. Then somehow as I was eating the cake it was as if I was just eating undercooked dough. I knew I would have to check for rotting berries in the supermarket. I didnt expect it from a shop.To my dismay as we went through the cookies the chocolate one wasnt cooked all the way, and yet was crumbling. The oatmeal was good until we bit into a gob of what I assume is shortening. .5/10. We wont go again.

DISGUSTING. THEY CALL THEM CUPCAKES AND COOKIES BUT ALLLLL THEY ARE IS STRAIGHT WHITE SUGAR. REALLY BAD. SAVE YOUR STOMACH.

This place is amazing! I took a chance having ever tried it before and ordered enough treats for 30 people. Everything was absolutely to die for. Theyre super flexible and easy to work with, they made sure to ask about the theme of my party so they could make everything match. Will be ordering when!

We love Sweet Tooth, but unfortunately they advertise sweet tooth Saturday buy one get one. We went in on Saturday, ordered everything in twos and when we went to pay the total was full price. When we asked about the special we were then told it isn’t until after 6. No where on the sign does it say this. Also, there is a special everyday of buy 5 cupcakes get the 6th free... we didn’t even get that special. As much as I love their treats, fool me once shame on you-fool me twice shame on me... :(

Thank you for making my babys first birthday perfect, the Whinny the pooh cake was a hit. Im so happy and Ill be back again. 🥰

I paid 50+ for a mutant cake! Check the photos! I went in two weeks before my sons birthday to pick up a dozen cupcakes for a fun flavor choice/taste test. I asked for only the flavors that could be made into birthday cakes and wrote all the names down. When I called in to order the cake, I was told that my sons pick was not available - lame! My son decided to try a red velvet cake instead and when I went to pick it up it looked like this - see photo. The staff looked at it and shrugged (they had been slow on the first day and downright rude on the pickup). Because of time (and the fact that I had prepaid over the phone for this monstrosity) I took it and and my family (except my son) spent several hours ridiculing the cake - that was the most humiliating moment I have had in years - thank you STF, I will NEVER buy from you again.

These cupcakes were absolutely delicious, the fall flavors and combined perfectly. She shop is really cute too with very nice employees. Delicious! #lfthx

We LOVE the sweet tooth fairy! Our favorites are the cake bites. Cutest little shop, delicious treats, and really friendly employees :)

Oh my goodness the cookie dough cupcake is TO. DIE. FOR. They were all really good but the cookie dough one, we couldnt stop eating!! It has brown sugar frosting and is incredible! You will love it! #sweettoothfairy #lfthx

Sweet Tooth Fairy is always a great stop for a sweet treat. I love the cupcakes but they also have other treats too. In love with the cookie dough flavor!#lfthx

Dang this place is delicious. The best gluten free cupcakes and cookies I’ve ever had.

We had never been to Sweet Tooth Fairy before but we will most definitely be coming back! We came here for a sweet treat after dinner and couldnt help but get a few cupcakes, they looked so good! I was still full from dinner, so I figured Id only take a bit but ended eating two whole cupcakes because they were so delicious! #lfthx

They have amazing desserts here. My wife and I had our picture taken with the sweet tooth fairies

I love the sweet tooth fairy! The cupcakes are sooo good!!! I always get my kids birthday cakes here, theyre delicious!!!

Always great food and customer service

Its always so sweet to stop by Sweet Tooth Fairy - I have loved their tasty treats for years. Its always such a great experience to satisfy your cravings for something delicious!

Carrie was amazing! I called in today with kinda of a weird request for a surprise on short notice and she went above and beyond to help me! Even though it was a small order She helped me out and she made the cupcakes adorable!!! I will definitely be go back because the treats are super yummy and because of Carrie!!!

I’ve been here a couple times and loved the treats but today when i went was very off. I normally get the red velvet cake bites and they are amazing but today they tasted like chalk. The cupcake I got was also, stale and dried out. I’m not sure why these weren’t good because normally the stuff here is very good.

This is a great place for a sweet tooth. The cookies are amazing, especially the ones with caramel. The cookie sandwiches are also good. Five Stars!

We LOVE the Sweet Tooth Fairy!! Its always a special day when the kiddos get to go to their cute little cupcake shop and see all the beautiful, delectable cupcakes. It just makes the heart sing to see such cute little cupcakes, made with love in their display. My daughters favorite is probably the unicorn! Ive gotten this one as a treat for all my friends little girls and they just go goo goo over it every time! We also love the lemon coconut. What a nice little alternative from chocolate! But if youre a chocolate fan, definitely the peanut butter chocolate!!

Ordered up Mothers Day package of cookies, candy & popcorn and it didnt show up until yesterday (May 12th) Package was a mess - cookies were broken, some even out of their package with crumbs in the box. Package was not protected at all nor was it treated well by UPS shipping obviously since most of it was in crumbles. Disappointed and will not recommend shipping out of your company although I know your products come highly recommended by family members who live close by.

I love getting treats from here for myself or gifts. The only thing that would make it better was if they had more vegan options than just the brownie. It is super easy to make not just vegan stuff in general, but cakes too! It’d be cool to see them make vegan cake/brownie pops.

No DIY sugar cookies has ruined this place for me... Usually good service though sometimes a lite unknowledgeable. Desserts are to die for.

This location is awful in comparison to Draper. No friendly workers, stale cupcakes. I went in to get a free cupcake because my credit union gives us a deal where we get cupcakes every once in a while. It is my sons favorite treat but this time it was not a good experience. I wouldn’t recommend this location based on my experience. Go to Draper!

The specialty dessert at the Sweet Tooth Fairy is cupcakes, but everything they make it delicious! They make pies, cakes, cookies, and shakes. The shakes are made with vanilla ice cream and a cupcake of your choice. Pies and cakes are made to order. Their specially over sugar cookie is an amazing experience while their other sugar cookie is average. The other colors are good

I have ordered cakes from the sweet tooth fairy in the past, never had any bad experiences... until this time- one of my baby shower cakes was ordered from here, looked cute, exactly what was ordered... until we cut the cake. It was RAW. We cut the first slice and couldn’t eat it, it got stuck in the roof of your mouth, we could’ve literally made very chewy cake pops out of it. So disappointed to have that happen at a special event.

Not very happy with my recent order. Ive always loved sweet tooth fairy but these cupcakes were not as good as they use to be. The frosting recipe has changed and it honestly sucks now. They use to be original but now there like every other basic cupcake shop.

We usually go to crumble cookie and decide to try something else but it was definitely not as expected or as fresh and warm as crumble. we came by on a Saturday around 5 and the cupcakes were very dry, it was not as expected. The staff was friendly and helpful but the cupcakes didn’t taste like they were worth almost $3.00 each.

This stuff is so affordable and amazing!!!!

Great cupcakes! I loved the variety. The cupcakes are beautiful and reasonably priced. They have great seasonal flavors too.

Love sweet tooth fairy! Lots of different yummy flavors to choose from. They also have a gluten free selection which is nice! They also have delicious cookies and baked goods to choose from.

Their cupcakes are delicious. If youre thinking about getting the peanut butter cup one, do it. Its amazing! Staff has always been super nice as well.

Love -- except where did the coconut frosted sugar cookies go? Anyway, makes my wife happy on the weekend, which makes me happy😉

I got my first cup cakes here the other day and they were so cute and yummy! My favorites were the lemon and the strawberry shortcake. I typically dont like frosting but the frosting on these were so delicious. The girl at the counter was really nice as well. #lfthx

Love this place! Delicious cupcakes/treats and friendly staff. But if you don’t have much of a sweet tooth, be warned—their treats tend to be very rich!

Cupcakes aren’t my favorite, but this place has some pretty awesome ones! Loved the frosting on the strawberry shortcake. Liked the peanut butter chocolate cookie even more

I literally dream about their jumbo cookies. They are hands down the best cookies Ive had in my ENTIRE life. They are dense and moist and thick...and a dream come true :) But seriously.

Cupcakes are so yummy. Moist and the frosting is not too sweet. The store is clean and service friendly. And there were a few gluten free options too. #lfthx

Best cupcakes I’ve ever had! Especially the Reese’s one. Soft and moist and rich. Also the service was amazing, the girl at the counter had a lot of good suggestions and was so so nice! #lfthx

Meh. This is not a great cupcake place. But it is a cupcake place. So there is that. Look, if you have the time, Cravings in Pleasant Grove is much better. If you dont have the time, well, Sweet Tooth Fairy does in fact sell cupcakes. They may not be great cupcakes, but if ya got the itch and all...

Really good cupcakes. Nice little place to relax and eat too. Theyve got chocolates, cookies, lollipops, ice cream, drinks. I like bringing my daughters here and relaxing while they have a cupcake.

Picked up cupcakes for my birthday today and they were perfect! They have the best gluten free cupcakes around. Thank you Sweet Tooth Fairy! #lfthx

Love these gourmet cupcakes! They are my go to birthday treats for friends, and we LOVE the filled cupcakes! Tried the root beer float and hot fudge sundae cupcakes today and they were awesome! #lfthx

My boyfriend and I usually go here for super yummy cupcakes and cookies. They tend to be on the sweet side but they are a cupcake bakery. I definitely recommend them to anyone who has a sweet tooth.

Unfortunately we were not impressed. The cupcakes were small and the frosting seemed overly sweet. For the size and quality we thought it was over priced. Its a fun location and the service was good but we wouldnt recommend it.

This place is the BEST, everything tastes so good and looks amazing. I would recommend everybody to buy their sweets here. #lfthx

I ordered some of their cake bites online for Mothers Day and they charged my card without ever completing my order then automatically sold out after they told me to try again.

Got the pumpkin chocolate chip cupcake. Asked the cashier if she liked the pumpkin pie cupcake and she said she hadnt even tried it.... common gotta be knowledgeable about your products. Definitely not as good as craving Alicias cupcakes pumpkin chocolate chip cupcake and not as good as kneaders cupcakes either... kinda disappointed. Cupcake was dry and cream cheese frosting was too sweet and gritty.

Their cupcakes are so good! We got a box of 4 and 3 of them were absolutely delicious with 1 that was kinda meh

I was told I could come in and get a free cupcake or cookie on my birthday. I went in today and confirmed this with the worker there. She asked to see my ID to confirm my birthday, which I totally understand. So I showed her. And then I got charged for my treat anyway.

This is the second time Ive tried Sweet Tooth Fairy, and I was disappointed both times. Ive never had such a dry cupcake. And the taste wasnt good either. I couldnt even finish it, which says a lot, since I hate wasting food, especially a $3 cupcake. Do yourself a favor and make your own, or go to Nothing Bundt Cakes. Its WAY better.

I cant eat refind sugar, so when my boss brought a box of these in they look so good. And when i heard its sugar free i ate every last bite. I love this place so much!!!

Sweet Tooth Fairy in Orem has made my day once again. Their cupcakes were superb and the staff was super friendly and ready to help. o highly recommend the peach cobbler cupcake (if it’s available). Basically a dream come true with each bite. #lfthx

Always love the sweet tooth fairy, its a shame I have to drive all the way to Utah county now to eat here!

I love the cupcakes (fairyfetti and red velvet are both fab!) but I do wish they would update their flavour calendar online as sometimes they have different flavours and its hard to know when theyll have what I want.

Sweet and delicious. They have all the goodies here

Disapointment. I was hoping for a warm cupcake and cookie, but it was all cold. Taste was not that great either-i could easily make it at home. Will probably never go back.

Yes! Their offerings are both delicious as sweet! Bring insulin

Stopped in for a treat and ordered 2 Mint Chocolate Catebites, though not expensive definitely overpriced. Took home for later that evening. After 1 bite I threw them away. The cakebite was way to dense, the texture was gritty, it was too sweet and though it was very chocolatey, the flavor was unpalatable. My suggestion is to take your money elsewhere.

I absolutely love the delicious treats here! I am a fairly frequent visitor, but by no means am I known by name. Tonight when I went in the store had lost its usual luster as I was snubbed by an employee. He was friendly enough with the two pretty girls in line ahead of me but apparently a bedraggled mom of two doesnt need customer service. That was reserved for the attractive single girls. Also in the period of time I was in the bakery I heard him tell a little girl who came in after me that she didnt want a specific type of cupcake because it was gross. This location is normally so good, but the employee really ruined it for me.

Tasty cupcakes and other treats. This is a kid’s dream come true. My daughter loves the cookies

The icing is a little on the sweet side for me, but the flavors are really great. Cute little shop. I love the cookies and cream cupcake.

Usually not a huge sweet tooth but this place was delicious. A little pricy in my opinion but over great!

Looks great, tastes meh. Cookies undercooked. Cupcakes very average . Cakeballs too small to even be satisfying .

Love how many flavors there are to choose from! And all the flavors I tried were delicious

Yummy cupcakes!! My favorite is the red velvet! Clean store with nice staff! #lfthx

The cookies are big and indulgent. The atmosphere is so pleasant too.

My husband and daughter bought me cupcakes from this place. They were so good that I went back for more. I give them 4 stars because I wish they have more GF selection that is all. But it is pretty good!

Definitely not impressed. Brought my daughters in for a little girls date & probably won’t be returning.. The girl behind the counter treated us like we were an inconvenience, & the food wasn’t great. My daughters cupcake was gooey, my other daughters unicorn cookie (which she was really looking forward to) was stale & hard, & my lemon bar was pretty much all crust & whatever lemon they had put on it was hard as a rock & just not good. Definitely disappointed.

This place is GREAT I called in a last minute order and they had exactly what I needed.

Super cute shop and very tasty cupcakes! The kids loved coming and picking their own cupcake

Expensive and not that great.

Rating on behalf of my kids- they both loved the smores cupcakes and the mini cake pop bites. Cool they offer a gluten free option as well! #lfthx

If you go here you need to try the red velvet cake bites. Those are one of the best items on their menu.

Seriously closed more than 10 minutes early, I would be happy to give a description of the employee that closed early and wouldn’t let us in. This is not how it works when you run a business and have posted hours. To add onto that the hours are wrong online and says they close at 9 which also has caused inconvenience at previous experiences.

Great selection! I got a cookie and some cupcakes. All were delicious!

Tried these cupcakes today and was Not dissapointed! Fresh, yummy, and affordable. Store was cute and clean. #lfthx

The cookies were absolutely amazing and the vegan brownies were some of the best that Ive ever had!

Customer service is above and beyond helpful and quick. The aroma is to die for.

We used to come here, but they stopped making the double fudge cookie (chocolate cookie with chocolate chips) in favor of more jumbo cookies, so theres no reason to anymore. Real bummer that they got rid of those.

Shared some Sweettooth Fairy cupcakes with my little sweeties tonight. The peach cobbler cupcake...seriously amazing!@sweettoothfairy#lfthx #stforem

Their cupcakes are AMAZING!!! Same with the cake bites. I recently had the chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake and WOWZA it was yumlicious! #lfthx #STForem #sweettoothfairy

Amazing cupcakes! Absolute best!! Super sad provo location is closed! Open one in Spanish fork!

2 stars because the cake bites were their saving grace. That aside, they icing has gotten way to sweet. The last time we purchased 6 muffins from here the icing was still grainy and 2 of the muffins had straight flour at the bottom and most of them I could taste patches of salt and somthing sour. All of these are signs that someone in the back is not mixing the icing or the batter long enough to get everything incorporated into the mixture. The deciding last straw were the rude employees. If I ask, whats in this muffin? the answer had better not be, I dont know, like chocolate and penut butter and stuff? I dont think Ill be back.

Good gluten free cookies 🍪😁

SOOOO Very sweet. when I get a treat I dont want my teeth to hurt! flavors were full but too sweet. I am a baker by trade, so kinda have a nack for whats sweet and whats sweet but really good..........if something is too sweet it looses flavor. I bought a cupcake and cookie the store down the street is way better~ home made feel with not too much sweet but alot of flavor.

Their cookies and cake bites are good but a little overpriced. They are so sweet that it makes you really want water but they dont have any free options.

Especially loved the smores cupcake! #lfthx

Love this place! The cake pops are to die for.

I always have a great experience here and I love everything I have tried!

The cookie dough cupcake is to die for. Whenever Im in town I make it a point to stop by and get one. The cake bites however are a waste of your money. I dont suggest them.

Free birthday cupcake!! Spending 3 bucks on a cupcake is a joke

The cupcakes tasted kinda wierd to be honest.

Really love their cupcakes! Just wish they would make black and white cheesecakes more often.

Their cookies are great and prices are fair.

Birthday cake was an hour late and did not come as ordered. Staff was rude when I was annoyed.

Great cupcakes and cake bites!

The worker was rude and unpleasant. The cupcakes were alright though.