We dealt with Nicole and she helped us out alot. My wife didnt want to sell any of her jewelry but we needed the money. She was honest and helpful with everything. Trully a nice person who has the customers best interest at heart. Thank you again Nicole.

Nichole is always super happy to help. I frequently come in with jewelry and she always knows exactly what it is. You can’t beat great customer service and knowledge! Thank you Nichole!

Super sweet woman helped us out today! We got a fair price for gold and she made it an awesome experience on top of that, definitely would come back here and recommend this shop

Awsome experience here legit gold buyers went in lady with blonde hair and glasses super nice and gave us the best price out of anyone in Pittsburgh and I went to all great experience woth her!!!

Best prices in the area! Fast and friendly service. Will return and refer!

Sold a broken piece of jewelry and ended up buying some sterling silver rings. As soon as i told her my size she pulled out rings that were my exact taste. Nikki knows how to read someone, great customer service- ill be back

Great selection at even better prices! I always go to the West Mifflin location and the staff is wonderful; Nichole is always super helpful and friendly. There is always something new to see and you get a good value for your money.

I shopped around before selling my silver and a little bit of gold. After one phone call, I was convinced that Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh was where I wanted to do business, and I was right. I could not be more impressed with their friendliness, professionalism, service, prices / payout on spot price, and their facility.

Stopped in tonight to see about selling a smashed gold earring, I didnt know they sold jewelry. The manager Nicole was setting up a display and she showed me the sterling bracelets she was putting out. Ill be back when my husband isnt with me. pleasant, very patient staff and quality things

Nicole was very knowledgable and actively talked shop about silver coins and the market. Out of coins but She directed me to the natrona heights location where they carry more silver coins.

I had a broken chain but it was heavy, so I shopped around to find the best price. the gold buyers of Pittsburgh beat two other places by $40 and one place by $80

I had a very postive experience selling gold at The Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh. Very professional, great price and quick. Highly recommend!

Well first let me start off by saying the customer service at this place was awesome from the time we walked in the door. We worked with Nicole who helped us from start to finish. We went in looking around just to see what deals they had as we were actually not in this area to shop. We were just meeting someone down the street. We ended up finding some great deals and got a few pieces. Some of the best deals on watches I have seen in a long time. If you are in the market for a watch for sure check this spot out. Super pleased with this surprise experience, we recommend this place for sure.

This was my first experience with a resale jewelry store. I found a really good quality gold necklace in perfect condition at a great price. The lady (Nicole) who worked there gave the best customer service I’ve been given in a very long time. She didn’t rush me, she offered lots of selections and was nice to deal with. I will go back and shop again.

Best price on eagles an silver bullion. cashier knew what she was talkin about, Ill go back.

I seriously wish i could give one hundred STARS for this place ...I had a MORE than Pleasant experience there today selling my old gold..The people are so nice and honest and Also had the best rate around i would definetly, HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!..Thank You So much guys ❤- Forever a customer - A.J.

Had the pleasure of stopping into the store at the beginning of the week. I was met by two very friendly young women, who were actually interested in seeing what I had... While Nicole patiently took care of me, a young couple were just leaving after he picked up a neck chain that he was extremely happy with, but couldnt talk his honey into anything until they were almost out the door and he spotted a little gold heart bracelet that everyone loved! My point being we all just for that one minute shared a kind of happy with each other!! I saw how fairly they treated other customers and myself; got the best price I could for my jewelry, and I will never deal with another big name store again. Tx ladies!

Sold Gift cards and she gave me a great price for my cards. store is welcoming, glad theyre asking masks to be worn

I have been going to this Gold Buyers for a couple of years now and they are the best! Best prices paid for Gold Silver and gift cards. Also the staff has always been friendly and professional! I definitely recommend them.

I had previously gone to a competitor to sell my wedding rings, and was offered considerably less. The diamond value was not even added into the estimate. I was told that my setting was not desirable. I went into The Gold Buyers expecting the same result. Met Nicole, she was thorough, counted all the diamonds and offered me double what I was previously offered. She also told me that my setting was what everyone wanted! I hope someone finds some joy in those rings. I will definitely be back, but next time I am purchasing, not selling! Thanks Nicole

My wife and I found a beautiful diamond ring on The website, she called and spoke to nicole, she was very helpful, got the ring in the store for us within a day and even took it off the website so nobody else could buy it, also gave us a tremendous price on it, very happy with our purchase and the service

Nice place, Nicole was helpful with silver bullion

Nicole was awesome! She helped me pick the perfect peice was super patient as I changed my mind a few times!! Definitely buying her again when in the area!

This location is overall a definite 5! Very clean, professional establishment that offers great hours and gives you a good deal for anything you are trying to sell. I have personally dealt with Nichole and she is great! Friendly, helpful and makes each time you visit very quick and to the point, which I appreciate. Would highly recommend to anyone looking to sell or buy items!

They give the highest pay outs on gold. I went to three places total they were 18 dollars higher. If thats not reason enough, go there because they have this amazing furry guy helping out! great local shop-5 stars

Fantastic experience at Gold Buyers!! Nichole was great and took her time with me to hear what I wanted in a ring. She gave me a bunch of options and was very patient until I found the perfect one. They have such a great selection of jewelry and the customer service is excellent. I highly recommend Gold Buyers to anyone!

Very friendly staff. Nicole was awesome. Ill definitely be going back. Fair prices

Always noticed the store window was cute but never made it in until today. The prices were so great on sterling silver jewelry, I bought a few gifts to give my little cousins and one for myself with turquoise. the lady working showed me her favorites which ended up being what i bought. will go back

Went in the gold buyers of pgh in West Mifflin today for the first time. Was welcomed right inside the door by the most unique greeter. A big, shaggy yet very friendly dog . ( He was behind the counter for those of you who don’t appreciate a cute dog). Anyways the young lady working was, but contained her composure and was very nice. I was waited on quickly, and given a price in minutes.I didn’t have to think twice . Their price was 80$ higher than the previous buyer. And $80 is a lot when your only talking a couple hundred to begin with. So I was pleased and would suggest anyone looking to get some extra cash definitely give them a shot .Eric W.

A pleasant experience, best price for selling gold, and very friendly staff. Its a relief to find some honesty in the jewelry business. A wonderful selection of beautiful pieces, no need to go anywhere else. Nichole at The front desk is a pleasant person who always greets you with a smile and treats you like a valued customer.

The staff here is amazing and very quick and precise

I love this place for both buying and selling!

I recently went to Legacy because I was looking for a wedding band for my non traditional engagement ring. After visiting TONS of other stores, I ended up leaving Legacy with two wedding bands for my self! My engagement ring is and unisual shape and two thin bands, one to be worn above, the other below really looked awesome! The staff was friendly, but not pushy, and I really felt like she was being honest. The shop is very open and inviting and the prices are truly fair. I was so glad I stopped by.

Nice place to get coins and gifts

(Mary) Nichole was THEE most honest, professional and down to earth person Ive ever met in this business. She not only helped me but made me a customer who will go back. GREAT prices and honest help. I would recommend this place to anyone, buying or selling, she seriously has the best prices around! This place is the real deal.

I only sell to the Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh. The staff is warm and friendly and I trust them to give me a fair value price for my pieces. I recommend them to everyone and I have personally never heard a negative remark.

I recently sold some of my jewelry at The Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh. I was hesitant at first but the Sales Associate I worked with, Nichole, took her time and explained the appraisal process to me in detail. I was very happy with the end result! Appreciate the professionalism and A+ customer service. I will definitely be back to shop!

I always thought Gold Buyers was just for selling your jewelry for cash-boy was I wrong! A friend was wearing a beautiful ring and when I asked her where she got it she told me Gold Buyers! She also told me to ask for Nichole because she was super helpful. She was right again! It was like Nichole had known me for years-she was showing me things that I absolutely loved at prices I couldnt believe!!! Its now become my go to for one of a kind, unique fine jewelry-youve gotta check it out yourself-and ask for NICHOLE! 😊

My watch and jewelry buying experience was enhanced by the knowledge of Nichole Davis. Nichole took the time to educate me on the real value of gold vs the market, clarity variances in gemstones, and how to care for my watches! I also received a higher price for the items Ive sold than any other competitors in Western PA! Ive referred countless friends and family members in the past and wont hesitate to do the same in the future. Thank you Nichole!

We went in to get a ring and the lady working was extremely helpful. She showed me a lot of rings and gave me a lot of information about the different types of ring. We bought a beautiful ring and will be coming back for all of our jewelry purchases. NEVER GOING BACK TO KAYS OR JARED.

Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh, West Mifflin, is the best! Theyre very efficient, friendly, and pay top price for your jewelry and gift cards. Nichole is always a pleasure to deal with, shes very knowledgeable and helpful!! I recommend this place and location to anybody needing to get rid of jewelry or gift cards, or to shop!

No need to look elsewhere- BEST PRICES around! Nichole was very helpful, knowledgeable and so fun to work with! We will definitely be revisiting Goldbuyers of Pittsburgh!!!

Very nice shop, picked out gifts at great prices after I sold my broken chains. even wrapped the gifts for me in holiday paper

I have dealt with Nichole many times. Always friendly and helpful service!

I love this place! They are so personable and pleasant to work with. Great prices on jewelry!

My husband worked with Nichole, an associate at gold buyers to find a unique antique engagement ring. For a few months Nichole kept in constant communication thru pics and texts every time they received new inventory! After he found the perfect ring, the search was on for a matching band. Nichole kept her eye out closely and soon found a perfect match! She even went as far as taking both rings to a closer location to us to make it more convienant during such a busy time in our lives!! Great customer service!!! Went above and beyond!

Absolutely terrible customer service experience. I called ahead prior to confirm they would purchase a Home Depot gift card. Upon arrival, I noticed a sign stating they paid 75% on Home Depot gift cards (per person, per day), which is what I was told on the phone.I have just recently moved to Pittsburgh, so I havent transferred over my drivers license yet. I was informed by a member of the staff that their store policy is to not buy gift cards from anyone with an out of state ID. While this was disappointing since I drove all the way out there after calling ahead, my boyfriend was with me and he had his PA drivers license, so he offered it to her.She began conferring with another employee sitting toward the back. Then, without even looking at his ID, she told that us that purchasing our gift card would empty their cash drawer and we should go somewhere else (they recommended MaxPoint and National Gold Buyers).She stated that they would both pay the same amount (75%) for my card. I told her that Im not from the area and asked her approximately where they were located or what time they closed (as it was currently almost 6 p.m.) and she informed me that she didnt know and I should Google it.The drive out there and back was a complete waste of my time. I find it hard to believe that the purchase of my card would have emptied their drawer since their entire business model is based upon purchasing such things. While I completely understand their store policy, I found their demeanor completely rude and unprofessional. I will never go back there.I called several other stores in the area and I was told that as long as my ID was valid (not expired), it wasnt an issue.I ended up going to Gold Rush in Dormont on West Liberty (Maxpoint). While I did concede 5% (they paid 70%), it was completely worth it. They were friendly, professional, and quick! In addition to highly recommending them, I will definitely go there again in the future.If youre looking to sell your gift cards, appreciate good customer service, and consider your time valuable, I highly recommend going to Gold Rush and steering clear of the Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh.

Nice selection of jewelry at competitive prices, always pleasant staff. I enjoy shopping here.

I had the wonderful pleasure of the assistance from Nichole during my adventures at The Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh in West Mifflin. Nichole explained in details, while she was determining the value of my gold that I brought in to be appraised. Nichole, gave me a fair and higher value then the gold buyers I had tried. After the gold buying experience, I was so delighted with the amount of value, that she then showed me beautiful gently worn jewelry. I not only purchased a gorgeous gem stone gold ring, but I also had extra cash!!! One stop shopping and a delightful experience and atmosphere!!! Thank you Nichole at the Gold Buyers of Pittsburgh in West Mifflin!!!!

Great service great prices!

Awesome and friendly staff with amazing prices! Thank you! :)

I bought my wedding band there (mens) and I got an incredible deal! It is white gold, with two tones, half of it brushed and half shiny. It also has 10 diamonds in it. This must cost about $1,000 at mall stores, but I was able to get it for less than $200! They cleaned it for me and it looks absolutely brand new even though it was pre-owned. No one knew at the wedding and it looks amazing next to my wifes ring. Why spend more? The service is top knotch and they have a huge selection of all kinds of gold, silver and diamond jewelry. More people should know about this place!

Great store but need to sell coins

Lovely, educated staff, as well as a wide variety of merchandise. An all around enjoyable and pleasant experience.

Very well priced items and they will work with any budget.

Super deals honest employees and just a really neat little place to visit.

After shopping around for the best prices...Gold Buyers offered me the most bang for my buck...clean store...friendly service and amazing payout!!

Great people very nice store never had a problem getting rid of old jewelry or gift cards

This place is great, friendly and very trustworthy. 💯💯💯💯

Lovely people, great experience overall. Competitive pricing!

They even give extra money for the diamonds, not a lot of places do that. Thank you so much, I do want to say your far better then the one on McKnight Rd.

Friendly, knowledgeable staff. Will definitely recommend to friends and family.

Always happy with the customer service and what I purchased.

Got a great deal on a diamond band. Great customer service!!!

Only place I go to there very professional and know what there talking about. Great service every time I go in.

Best service and Kim the best very nice and polite

Honest and fair

Always pleasant and fair!

A++++