Bought this from AJ’s for $60, looks super awesome, extremely great price since it’s autographed, and it was super easy to buy over the phone and have them ship it to me. Kent helped me through the entire process and was a great guy to work with. Always a pleasure, thanks AJ’s.

DO NOT sell your cards here. The grey haired weirdo in the back room will rip you off. Offered me $50 for a stack of Kobe Bryants and other late 90s era cards that were in great shop. Went to the other card shop down the street and got $600 for 1/4 of them. True story. Do have nice memorabilia, however. Hence the two stars.

This place is a scam! It may be a nice place for little white kids to hang out. But they do not cultivate an environment that is inviting to other ppl. I had to stand there for 5 min before even being acknowledged, and there was only a few others in the store. Do not shop here unless you are young and white. Otherwise you might not even be served

They are friendly and knowledgeable. Many of the current products along with a great selection of older product. All the supplies you old need for card collecting.

Very nice staff and a good selection of stock.

Worst payouts in the city for sealed boxes. Do not go here to sell they will lowball and have zero negotiation skills. They will tell one offer on the phone even look it up online then offer way lower once you bring them in. It’s scam and a joke. If I ran my business like this I would be embarrassed. Shoutout to Jose the new front end employee though. He was really kind. Will not return and will encourage all in those in my collectibles circle to be wary of selling to this establishment

Great service and selection, only gripe would be the prices but thats just how it is these days so cant really hold it against them too much. I really love the cheap wax pack bundles! FOR 5 BUCKS YOU CAN GET 10 PACKS FROM THE EARLY 90S FOOTBALL OR BASEBALL and WHILE MOST OF THE CARDS WILL BE NEAR WORTHLESS, YOU HAVE AN EXCELLENT CHANCE OF PULLING A LOT OF DIFFERENT JOE MONTANA & JERRY RICE CARDS SOME OF WHICH ARE GOING FOR HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS RIGHT NOW ON EBAY. SAME GOES FOR SOME OF THAT ERAS ROOKIE CARDS, LIKE IF YOU PULL A BRETT FAVRE, BARRY SANDERS, EMMITT SMITH, MICHAEL IRVING, TROY AIKMAN OR DEION SANDERS Etc...ALL OF THOSE CARDS ARE ROUTINELY SELLING FOR BIG BUCKS ON Ebay. I Know because I pulled a $600 Joe Montana card plus 3 more of his cards that are going for at least $100! Not bad when you consider 5 bucks gets you 10 packs!

Made me a nice offer for a deceased friends Packers collection. Thank you!

I am going to do reviews on card shops around the U.S. The prices are not the best but they did have a good selection of sports memorabilia and cards I had saw some pretty cool bobble heads. I walked in an saw jerseys autographed by different players. I was only able to get 3 packs. I got 2020 donruss, 2 2019 donruss, and I got a few inserts for 5 bucks. In those packs some of my hits were, a troy aikman numbered to 100, nick bosa, ceedee lamb rated rookies. Very knowledgeable!

Great customer service, but a significant lack of product selection.

A great place to find sports memorabilia. A friendly staff that is helpful. Great selection of Brewers, Bucks, Packers, and other teams items. From bobbleheads to autographed pictures and jerseys.Good prices as well. Most of their autographed items have certification of authenticity. You can find plenty of things to add to your sports collection. No matter what your budget is.

Dont try to sell any of your stuff there the gray-haired guy that does the reviewing will rip you off brought in some stuff to sell offered me a hundred bucks went to the other card shop down the road and they gave me over 400bucks.

They do good business and have a good selection of items from bobble heads to framed jerseys

Some of the bad reviews... if not all... are obviously not of merit / truthful... Went in today for my 1st time after messaging a little bit with the owner/manager about some items I would like to sell for Xtra holiday cash.I was not treated as if I knew nothing. In fact... I was invited in back while comping certain items... and Mike was an open book about comps and how the store operates with purchasing vs consignment and was upfront about what he could offer on what and why. No secret. We BOTH want to make a little money and they need room to make a little profit as well. I had numerous cards as well as many jerseys that he was interested in and asked for time to look thru all the cards. Then.. went ahead and offered me a price for a few jerseys to help me put a little money in my pocket while he went thru the cards. Staff was very friendly... place was clean and very busy as well. Personally saw some staff members stay cool while dealing with a rude customer or 2, lol. As I said, it was my 1st time.. wont be my last and Im very curious to see whats said about my card collection.I highly recommend this place and the shelves are absolutely stocked with lots of product for many sports. Lotsa goodies in store!!

Very great. Went there today had lots of stuff, staff were really nice and gave me 2 free packs plus two Ryan Braun rookie card thanks person who gave me them 105% recommend

AJ Collectibles has all the sports memorabilia you could ever want! They have so many cool autographs in there. I had a custom made plaque made by them for my son that included several of his favorite players in one plaque where he can display his cards. He spent his own allowance money on it and was very very pleased with the final product. Highly recommend check this store out!!

The best hobby shop in the the area. Great prices, great people. Overall always a great experience. Whether you’re newer to the hobby or a veteran, they treat everyone with the same respect.

Ordered something from them (Through Walmarts Website), Was supposed to come in 2 weeks or so. The company got it to me, exactly what I ordered, (Old Hess Trucks, as a present,) in perfect condition, withing 24 hours. Thats Amazon level impressive. Had to leave a review, which is something I pretty much never do.

Over piced but very personable.

The new store is well set up, very organized and clean with a pretty averse selection of jerseys. the one part that disappoints me is that it would be nice to see changeover in regards to the cards that are in the cases. when it comes to the individual card boxes, it would be much easier for everyone if the boxes were organized more efficiently and if they were more easily accessible to everyone to be able to look through them. Very nice staff overall and a very well run store that makes customers feel welcomed.

Amazing selection and competitive prices. Will definitely be back.Jeff was very helpful and knowledgeable in helping me select several boxes of football cards to open. I decided to open them right at the store! It made me feel like a kid again!!! Ill be back soon to do some Christmas shopping.

Great prices and friendly people

These guys are always the best. We visit them everytime we are in town! Thank you.

Stopped into the shop on are way out of town wish i would have more time. excellent selection i will make sure when i come to Milwaukee to stop by the shop. the owners took my name and number down as i was looking for certain cards. and they were sorting a collection and said they would call if the found any items. thank you for the awesome service

I found the perfect gift for my brother in law here. He is from Jacksonville and there is obviously not much merchandise up here for a team like that...except this incredible store. Staff was knowledgeable and extremely helpful. These guys really go the extra mile to assist!

I discovered this store while looking for an anniversary gift for my sports loving husband. I walked in and was greeted by Jeff. I had a list and he jumped right in and helped me gather things. He was extremely knowledgeable and answered all my questions. My husband was thrilled with my gifts. I took him to AJ’s and he was in sports collection heaven. We are frequent regular customers now. Our Mike Tyson, Hulk Hogan, and Nolan Ryan Autographs are awesome!! We have attended Rip feats and for a novice I am found the excitement infectious!!! Absolutely recommend this place!!! Awesome owners, staff, and especially Jeff who welcomed Me that first day.

I just had a very pleasant experience there. They treated me great and gave me a great deal on some rpa cards. I found them to be very upfront with their pricing, I.e buying and selling. Super relaxed atmosphere. They treat everyone exceptional regardless. I didnt find that the case at Brew Town but I wish both dealers the best. I will def be back. Thank you.

I had just went to AJ’S right before the pandemic and I sold many things to them to be able to get a signed picture for my family. They ripped me off because at the time I knew I was getting a good deal because I just wanted to get the picture. I sold my JA Morant marvels from Donruss for $10 and many other things for $100 store credit but now I looked it up and there is one on bids now for $250. So just in conclusion do not do business with them regarding them buying cards off you. They are extremely unfair and do not even give half of eBay value. I have had no problems with their buying of boxes. Their in store service and employees are extremely rude and do not have good customer service. Selling cards to them I will never again. I know that I am a kid but I wanted to make it known that they literally ripped off a kid.

Poor service. Not friendly. cocky almost as I stated I green and had been out of it since 92. Came in to buy 2 boxes of football cards. Tried to chat, asked for recommendations by name. Most expemexpe . Dont even think I got eye contact for his two word answer.

My time at AJ Collectables was amazing. I got into a new hobby and found a great place to indulge in that new hobby. Everyone that works there was helpful and didn’t make me feel rushed into buying or leaving. The card selection is insane and they carry tons of different sports. I highly recommend going here for any of your sports needs.

Great place. Took the time to look through my cards and explain the pros and cons of some, which I never thought theyd take the time to do. Dont believe the bad reviews. These people were very friendly and patient while I deliberated. They also had a huge selection of collectibles (and an insane amount of bobble heads). Theres something for everyone there. Im lucky I left with any money...

The owner is extremely knowledgeable and friendly and can probably answer any questions you may have regarding any sport. They have a good clean store in a great, convenient location. Large variety of anything you may need. Very fair when purchasing my memorabilia. Lots and lots of sports cards and tons of bobbleheads Highly recommended

Visiting from CT to see Miller Park. Read good things about the store, so I decided to drop in before the game. I was really impressed... nothing like back at home. Great prices, incredibly friendly and experienced staff, huge selection of cards and autographs. I highly recommend going here if you are interested in the hobby!

Friendly staff and very helpful plus their promotions are nice. They have a nice loyalty program and giveaways as well. I actually won a nice hobby box of illusions football in one of their raffles. Ive been there 6 times already in less than 2 weeks and I live over 20miles away.

Friendly greeting at the door. A lot of great product. Competitive prices. I think its the same only place with hockey cards in the Milwaukee area

Aj’s is the best. I have been to every card store in the area over the last 40 years. Their prices are reasonable, and their selection is very good. If they don’t have it, they will find it for you. The staff and owners are so friendly and genuinely care about their customers. My wife and I have become regular repeat customers. Thanks guys!!!!

Great selection of different kinds of new cards plus a ton of sports memorabilia. A little bit of everything from jerseys and helmets to signed 8x10s and autographed cards. The prices are also very reasonable. Definitely a place to check out if youre a sports fan.

If youre really into purchasing sports collectibles I guess its the place to go. I had some signed favre and Reggie White pictures. I believe that they were artwork prints and not photographs. I went in to sell them but he looked at them and immediately declined. Not sure why because I was able to sell them online quite fast

Awesome selection! Perfect for gifts or your own collections. Everyone is really helpful, knowledgeable and professional! Awesome location too.

Ok variety. Didnt have standard sports items rather items I dont collect

Huge selection of top loaders. There are literally hundreds of thousands of .10 cards to go through. Jumbo pack prices are extremely fair for a local card shop. Aaron was great to talk to.

Any Christmas presents that you may need for your sports lover in the family AJ Sports Colectables is your Store! They have any and everything you could imagine! Plus, the staff is super nice and really knowledgeable! Great store!

Made my first visit of what will be many today. Great shop, excellent selection, AWESOME VALUES!!! Highly recommended

Amazing selection!! Will definitely be back. Great place to buy gifts for the upcoming Holiday.

Drove to store from Illinois well worth the trip.

Amazing card shop. Excellent variety and great prices too. Will definitely be back.

Great place. I love shopping here for my bobbleheads. One of the best around. Would recommend

Had fun even though I didnt win

Every time my family and I go into the store it’s always a warm welcome from every employee. They have great merchandise and are very reasonable on their prices!

Owners were very helpful in finding items I was looking for; it was great to see that kind of customer service. I will definitely return there for any future sports memorabilia.

Great shop! Lots of great treasures to add to your collection and reasonable prices. Friendly staff as well!

Horrible experience. Employee thought i Didnt know my cards and tried to lowball me for a Giannis rookie card autograph for $40. Never again. Place smells too and looks terrible. Brew Trading Co. Is the place to be!!! So many better sports card stores!!! If a 0 star was possible it would be a 0. Never again.

Great selection and prices!This place really has everything. The atomspere is awesome and the owners care about their customers. Autographs, supplies, bobbleheads, old and new sports cards. This place really is the midwests leading sports card and memorabilia store.

AJ sports collectibles it’s a great locationWhere you can find all types of sports memorabilia and merchandise plus they have an awesome staff keep up the great work guys

The best card shop in town! Great selection, fair prices, and super friendly atmosphere! Their rip fest is a must attend!!!

Very helpful! Kids had a blast in their store! Workers were awesome!

Great experience, whenever I had a question or wanted to see a product behind the counter, they were very helpful. Packed a Mitch trubiskey Jersey auto #d to 25

Huge amount of autographed jerseys at really cheap prices. Staff was very knowledgeable and helpful with all of my questions. Thanks for the Reggie! Ill definitely be back soon!

I thought it was a GREAT place, these stores are dying it was nice to see one open.

Nice place but I dont trust there theory of collecting

Friendly service and the place has a down to home feel to it

I will be doing reviews on every card shop in the greater southeastern Milwaukee area. I have been a collector for 30 years. I have seen many card shops come and go throughout my collecting days. I have no bias to any card shop. I have visited and purchased from all of them.AJ Sports Collectables is first up. I am giving them a 1 star. The customer service is not what they preach all over facebook. Jeff the guy who runs the shop is not too personable. In fact, I believe this guy had a card shop back in the 1990s. He did not survive long. His prices were crazy high. This guy will lowball you for your collections. I have seen it a number of times. He bought a Jordan rookie for $200 and they now are selling it for $1000. I understand a shop needs to make a profit to survive but, at least offer a customer half price of ebay value.Value. They claim all over facebook they have the best prices guaranteed. What is the guarantee? You have some of the highest prices around. I would highly encourage you to shop around.Integrity. They will sell your cards that you open from packs on ebay for you. While I do like this aspect of their shop, I do not like how they encourage their customers to shill bid on items. Just pull up their ebay completed auctions and look at some of the bid history along with the % of the bids by buyers. I will give you one example, look up the NT Trae Young patch auto /25. If fact, they have Megan bid cards up in there auctions (I will be posting on blowout forums more in depth about the insane shill bidding occurring with this shop).Watching their videos on facebook crack me up. The one owner Aaron reminds me of a con-artist. Every product is good according to him. He will also lowball you on cards. I watched him buy a book of 1963s Topps from two younger guys, he basically said you do not have much and all the high numbers are missing. He gave them like $40.00. The book at Hank Aaron, Willie Mays etc.I also wanted to inform customers how they get a lot of their autographs. They will buy autographed items from people with no certification in hopes JSA will pass it. I saw them post a huge poster of an autographed Michael Jordan. Jordan only signs for Upper Deck. If it does not have an Upper Deck certification it is 100% fake.In conclusion, I have no affiliation with any card shops (trust me, my next review will be the boneheads a few miles East of them). You can clearly see the integrity issues with this shop. I do have one last question since they seem to always reply back to negative comments, where you guys the ones that claimed you were going to open up some bobblehead museum? Whatever happened to the donations people gave you?EDIT: Looks like they are trying to sell the National Treasures Trae Young 12/25 RPA again. Last auction was May 4th and ended at $2,281.55 I am providing pictures with all the shill bidding. Look at all the 0 feedback bidders and the high percentage of bidders bidding on their items. Classic shilling. Newest auction ended tonight for $1,875 with a high bidder with 0 feedback. Trust me this card will be for sale again. The bidder with zero feedback, has 66% bid activity with AJ’s. Case closed!

Best prices and such a fun place to go

A lot of variety, not just cards. Bobble heads of all sports and sizes. Jerseys too, even autographed items. Great play for a sports fan/collector

This place is awesome!! They have cards for football basketball and baseball.

Great selection, great prices, and the staff was very helpful. Will definitely be a repeat customer.

Great place to trade in cards and complete your sets. Cant wait for the new location!

Oh my god, where do I start. From all the sweet deals here and the TJ watt auto /10 to all the juiced boxes. This truly is the best card shop in Wisconsin.The other shops and companies are so jealous that they are really giving 1 stars and making up story’s that aren’t even true. Aj is a super nice guy and same with all the other employees. They are so nice, donating cards to chairity and don’t even get me get me started with pack wars. They hit you up with free drinks and pizza and subs such a good vibe. Although I haven’t been able to make it the last couple times. The first time I ever went to one, I got a homie long signed jersey framed worth about $450 I got a derrius guice rookie prism gold base /10 sold for $130. And a mystery box valued at around $70. And a bunch of more base inserts and numbered cards. Guess how much I spent? Less then $100 no other place has this good deals, good customer service, or good and authentic products. I am so happy I found out about this shop. Because it’s the most fun I have had collecting.Thanks for the fun memories and I hope to be back soon. To the best sports card store in Wisconsin- Aj’s collectibles 10/5 stars

Love thier new store it is were my son and I get our vitnage cards from. The guys in store are very helpful.

Super great owners and super great product. amazing place all around

Nice and helpful staff, Cool store with awesome stuff, and amazing signings. Everything about this place is a thumbs up.

Was taken aback when I went to the store looking for bobbleheads. One of the gentleman working was definitely not a fan of them as he told me he hated bobbleheads. Very unusual for a place that has so many. Needless to say I will be taking my business elsewhere.

Jersey selection was nice and at reasonable prices. If youre looking for jerseys and bobbleheads, definitely the place to look. I have collected sports cards for 10+ years. If youre looking for sport cards....... go somewhere else. shelves were empty, no selection. tried to trade in some cards of value, was low-balled because I was new to the shop. Went to a different shop in the area and traded in the same cards for a couple hundred $$ more than I was offered here.

Great card and memorabilia shop. Fair prices and fun place to crack cards.

The only card shop in Wisconsin that you need to go to!! Friendly, knowledgeable staff!! Great selection!!

Love this store. Have anything you might be looking for. Good prices and helpful staff!!!!

Great prices and selection. Definitely will be back

Great store. Good selection and friendly staff!

Nice to be welcome Everytime you come in and the person there knows what you collect and lets you know where it is!

Great selecion of bobbleheads

AJ Sports Colectables is your Store!!!They have any and everything you could imagine in Sports memorabilia’s!!!!The staff is super nice and really knowledgeable !!!What a Great store for that Sport Fan in your life !!!!!

Amazing service and great selection.

If you collect bobbleheads, this is the place to go... period. Always a positive experience when dealing with AJ Sports Collectables, online or store front. Jeff was very helpful in the store.

Been in there three times shoulda quit after 2.....doesnt really care about what you have...hardly looks at it and is no help. Plenty better card shops around

Very nice guys, great store!!!! Plus many extras like pack wars and random box giveaways!

Simply the largest sports collectable store in Wisconsin!!! If they dont have it, you probably dont need it, seriously!!!!

Great selection of amazing sports collectables, new and vintage sports cards.

Great place would shop there again!!!

Great place awesome selection of cards and everyone is soo friendly definitely go there if you need cards!!

Fun place to collect cards, bobbleheads and supplies.

Great selection and fair prices. Ill be back for sure!

Looking for a gift my son wanted and found

Awesome place none better in the area!!

Lots of bobbleheads to choose from but rather overpriced. I will however say this store is rather unique to Milwaukee.

Perfect sports shop and my favorite to go to for my hobby fix

Great shop with amazing collectibles!! Check it out!

Nice shop friendly staff.

Good selection of McFarlane Sports Figures. Reasonably priced as well.

This place is awful.The guy running the place treats everyone stupid.Dont ask questions cause you will be talked down to.If i knew what i had i wouldnt be in his shop.Dont know how the place is still open.Its a mess in there and it looked like sumone robbed the place.Never will go in there again and wont have worry about it cause it wont be open long.Took my cards and sold them for 1000$ to another store.

Pretty good overall selection.