First time in. The ice cream flavors were unique and delicious. They have an ice cream walking sundae, wish I’d have seen it sooner. They have a tiny shop of Knick knacks and some cookies and ice cream sandwiches I wish we’d have tried. The outside patio is great and dog friendly.

Great assortment of flavors and cones. Two scoops was a lot, and the ice cream was dense. Its right by the water and had a nice outdoor patio and some indoor seating. Definitely worth the trip and not unreasonably priced being 4, 7, or 10 for 1-4 scoops.

Lots of flavors to choose from....traditional and more. Service was good as even though it was crowded, they got us out there fast. The inside sit down area was packed but pretty noisy with small kids so we would have passed anyway.

Love going here after a boat ride I love the sherbet and the point system ever dolled you spend you get points and can eventually get a free ice cream.

Always a favorite. Best ice cream on Indy’s north side.

Crave was so delicious! The salted caramel pretzel was my favorite! And the staff was very good responding to our large group. To top it off, the location is perfect next to the marina!

Super love the ice cream! The staff here are so awesome and enhance the atmosphere a lot! Highly recommend this place! Its a beautiful hidden (not do hidden) gem!

The ice cream here is near perfection!❤ Since recently moving to the Geist area I can assure you that this is some of the best ice cream around. Not only do they offer a variety of choices flavor wise. But also in Ice cream cakes, dipped cones, Ice cream sandwiches and a decently sized collection of cookies. Crave is definetly a top spot to eat at and its location near the water is more than perfect! Crave is worth its weight in gold 👍😍

Excellent, consider it best in town, competition is fierce too, I am partial to cookies & cream as well as black raspberry

Among the best chocolate dipped cones. Everyone enjoyed the ice cream. Nice ambiance.

Wife wanted ice cream sandwiches for her birthday, sick of getting coldstone and handels wouldn’t do custom ones. $6.25 an ice cream sandwich seems crazy, but Crave allowed us to order custom ones so we ordered. These are massive. At least twice the size of any others we had. Cookies were great. Ice cream was great. Can’t wait to try this place again

Friendly employees but very small portions compared to other homemade ice cream stores.

Great shop, very clean and friendly workers. Love the vegan chocolate and birthday cake ice cream.

Fantastic Customer Service and very Friendly Customer Service

The ice cream was delicious and the scoops are really big.

Their ice creams were too good.

Had the Black Raspberry ice cream on a sugar cone. DELICIOUS!

We love going here and the ice cream cookies are fantastic! Unfortunately when I went in today, no one was abiding by the social distancing, and when I was looking in the cooler for my selection, an entire group came and stood directly behind me. With no real enforcement, it just worries me. I will keep coming because I love the ice cream and will totally support local, but will wait near end of the night

Always an enjoyable experience at Crave!

Quick service and great treats.

One of our favorites. Ice cream, coffee, baked goods, flavored popcorn & popsicles.

Absolutely horrible customer service. Placed an order online for pickup. When I got there I was told it would be a few minutes which is understandable as it was busy. After 20 minutes I was told that they gave my order to someone else and that there was nothing they could do. The girl taking orders said that she fulfilled the order so it was not their issue. Its your mistake, you should fix it.Follow up - The owner did contact us to make it right after the fact, which was well appreciated. Well just chalk this up to the stress of this new world we live in.

Love this place, right off the lake, great flavor selection and friendly staff

The ice cream here is phenomenal, very creamy always packed full and great flavors.

Loved this place from the first taste. staff treated us so nice. the bill was reasonable. similar to a place in denver i loved.

This ice cream parlor is absolutely amazing! The staff is so warm and welcoming, and that coffee flavored ice cream is to absolutely die for! This place is a must-visit in the Indianapolis/Fishers area !!!

Love the ice cream here!

So yummy! Kind and efficient staff. My daughter loves the cheddar popcorn and they sell Nicey treats!

The Vegan Birthday Cake and Vegan Chocolate Ice Cream was AMAZING!!! All you need is a scoop of each. Which wasnt bad at all together.... They were also very creamy with no after taste what so ever!!

Best ice cream in Indy!!!

Very filling. Similar to a cafe in Las Vegas I liked.

Hands down our family favorite! Try an ice cream sandwich!

Its all in the name!

Cute little ice cream shop. The best flavor is the Birthday Cake, which I would never order myself. But I tasted my daughters one time and it was sooo good. All the others are mediocre. Prices are quite high for ice cream. For the price I would expect something special. They do have a large outdoor seating area which is great for summers. There are a few other local ice cream shops that are much better tasting in my opinion.

Not to bad. I have had better in a place close by. But still very good.

Best vegan ice cream!!! We tried the vegan chocolate and birthday ice cream together and let me tell you it was great! I will definitely be back!!

Best time to go is mid day (avoid nights when its super busy and packed in the strip mall)

What a cute place! It has various flavors of ice cream as well as cookies, and popcorn. It would be a great place to eat outside on a warm night.

THE WILD CHERRY CHEESECAKE ICE CREAM IS A 10 OUT OF 10!!!! FABULOUS!!! I REALLY ENJOYED EVERY BITE. THE CHOCOLATE MALT BALL AT THE BOTTOM OF THE CONE WAS KILLER! A++++++++

Our first time ever going! We really enjoyed it! Cant wait to come back!

Fantastic treats!

Good place for desert after Woofies restaurant Gieste reservoir side!

Been going here for over 2 years now and it is the best ice cream. We compare it to places when we are on vacation and even in Indiana that we have been to and Crave really is the best we have had. Great service as well!!

Best ice cream treats around

I would just like to say that my ice cream experience here was AMAZEballs. I received cookie dough ice cream in the regular size. Let me just tell you, i have never had better ice cream. They so generously provided me with the biggest chunks of cookie i have ever seen. even though i got a small cup, it was bottomless. so satisfied. i thank you for this wonderful experience that i will remember forever. im keeping the cup. xoxo gossip girl.

Crave has great ice cream with a wide selection. It is always great to visit with my son and enjoy some delicious ice cream. I personally would recommend the Black Cherry if they have it or the Wild Cherry Cheesecake, but any flavor will be good. They also have a wide variety of honey based treats which look quite good.

Lovely staff and great ice cream. Dont forget the cookies!

I work right next to CRAVE Ice Cream Social and love it so much! You guys always have the best quality, homemade items and ice creams! Ive never had anything that I havent loved. Plus your employees are always so sweet and helpful. Thank you CRAVE, I love supporting your small business!!

Wonderful ice cream, and caring staff. This a an amazing business that supports other local businesses as well. :)

The ice cream was good, but the service was pretty bad. There were lots of people running around behind the counter without actually serving anyone. Cant say I plan to go back.

We found this ice cream shop over the summer on our date nights. Now whenever we are in the area, we try to stop. Lots of variety, and I love the mint chocolate chip. Next up to try are the ice cream sandwiches with homemade cookies. They look delicious!

The best ice cream maker...

Wife thought the ice cream was amazing, and I was surprised as well.

Loved the selection and love how everything is made in house.

We loved thier icecream! They are definitely going to need to expand. We walked in there and it was becoming packed. Friendly service. Very patient even though they started getting a full place. We also enjoy having thier icecream delivered too. Not melted and looked and was amazing.

Found this place on Google and decided to give it a try. Im so glad I did because it was the best pistachio ice cream Ive ever had. The ice cream was so flavorful and had a great consistency. Ill definitely be adding this to my list of ice cream places!

Always friendly and the toughest decision is which ice cream to get. I like that as adult i can get a kid scoop size. Helps me feel better calorie wise.

Awesone thick milkshakes. :)

Friendly staff, tasty flavors and more than enough sweet selections to choose from. Both cup and cone versions of ice cream are worth trying.

About 6 bucks for a sprinkle waffle chocolate dipped ice cream with two scoops. I would go again, cute little bistro with indoor/outdoor seating and wonderful staff.

Our granddaughter loves Crave ice cream so we took her for a treat tonight. It was very very good.

The best ice cream I have ever had. I love the added touch with each waffle cone. Beautiful atmosphere, friendly people and generous portions.

It has the best ice cream I’ve ever had. They are so nice and it’s really good after having Eddy’s or dinner around the area.

Great neighborhood ice cream place. My wife and I love this place. They also sell cookies, coffee and a variety of other treats.Theres out door seating that looks on to the Geist reservoir.

Great ice cream! Awesome service! Prices are reasonable and variety of items in store. Treats for everyone

Our first visit but what a great place, exceptional and friendly service, plenty of ice cream flavors and nice sized portions....we will be back many times

Great ice cream shop a stones throw away from Geist Reservoir! You can sit inside or outside on the patio. The ice cream flavors are delicious but they also have other pastries and treats.

Great selection of flavors, delicious ice cream! The owner is so nice. I take my granddaughter here nearly ever week.

Good ice cream. Nice place and clean inside. Outdoor seating. A little pricey but what ice cream isnt? :)

One of my favorite ice cream spot. Great taste and selection!

Very good ice cream here and the staff is nice. Rewards program is nice, but have to spend $100 to benefit from it.

Excellent

Great little sweets place off the beaten path. 👍👍

Our favorite lake ice cream shop

Best little icecream shop around. Great icecream and friendly staff.

I tried the Brownie Sundae with German Chocolate Cake ice cream. A must visit place.

Great experience every single time we go. Kids crave Crave!!

Tasty ice cream. Friendly service. Safe place to be in a sudden downpour outside.

My kids love coming here

Really good icecream. We have an icecream shop closer to us, but we drive past it to go to Crave!

Very good ice cream! Oversized portions.

Best vegan ice cream

Cute. Good. I would recommend joining their club and the Lemon ice cream.

Excellent real ice cream vanilla cherry chocolate chip is my favorite

Great staff, great ice cream

Enjoyed sitting outside to eat ice cream... but table was so hot it burned our grandkids.

A charming ice cream shop with friendly staff! So glad they were open until 11pm!

Amazing ice cream and treats at a fair price

Ice cream taste good. Nothing special

Great ice cream!!

The peanut butter cookie sandwich with fudge graham ripple is AMAZING. The cookie alone is worth it, really.

We have been to Crave many times. Everytime is a wonderful experience, the staff is so friendly!!!

Great icecream and customer service!

Love the friendly atmosphere here and the ice cream is delicious!

Great ice cream and great location

So good. Cookies are amazing.

Great graham cracker & fudge ice cream

Ask for turtle ice cream and they give me chocolate with waffle cone pieces... Dont think I need to say more about their service

Outstanding ice cream and amazing atmosphere.

Got to love Goods ice cream!!!