OH. EM. GEE. I love absolutely everything I’ve ever tried from Madison Market but today I tried the special-the Cubano goes to Italy- and i NEED it permanently in my life. Hopefully this becomes a staple menu item because it might possibly be the best sandwich I’ve had in my life.Matt made the best pumpkin spice latte, so perfect for this fall day!!Can’t wait to try the wine bar soon!

The people are super friendly and the food is beyond delicious. My wife and I order lunch from there regularly (highly recommend the Italiano and Sicilian sandwiches). I’d pay $100 a sandwich they are that good.

Finally made it to this place and it was really worth the wait. Pizziolo Pat is a Pizza God. He is a walking wealth of Pizza information. His take on a Neopolitan Pizza was fantastic. Which is all in the dough and the process he uses to work the dough to bring you a crisp neopolitan Pizza. This could be the best Crust in this division. The spinning oven at 900 degrees delivers perfection. This is a Pizza that does not travel well, so I suggest you eat it right out of the oven. I am not even getting into the rest of the Market. It is amazing. Which includes Homemade Gelato.. I would need a few hours to really analyze, but for now, the Pizza is a 5 star Experinece. They deliver exactly what they promise with their Margherita Pizza. I cannot wait to go back. They will rank high on the Pizza Hunters App.

Wow, just WOW! I am gobsmacked by the quality of food and drink at Madison Market! Not to mention, the friendliest staff Ive encountered in recent memory. I will be returning over and over and you should too!

My daughter and four grandchildren and I had a delicious lunch at the impeccable Madison Market. During the pandemic we had gotten wonderful take out but it is now a pleasure to eat there in person. Madison is indeed fortunate to have such an extraordinary restaurant. Rocco Iossa, proprietor, has brought the best of Italy to New Jersey, even the best homemade gelato.Susan Barba

Over 2 months ago I placed a catering order with Madison Market with email correspondence confirming the order. Today, 48 hours before my daughter’s first birthday party, I was contacted through text by the owner saying how they could not support the catering order and simply blaming it on a recently fired employee, taking zero responsibility for the situation. When I told him this situation would permanently affect our relationship going forward, it was clear he did not care. I have never dealt with such disregard from a business and sadly enough I might have no choice but to cancel my daughters first birthday party given that restaurants are already tight on resources and I have less than 48 hours to figure out a plan B. Completely unacceptable and unprofessional.

Great selection of food, including desserts. Freshly prepared sandwiches that are delicious. Great selection of honey, and other bottled oils and sauces. Indoor and outdoor seating too.

We would not expect to find such a great food hall here. The pizza is better than pizza parlor pizzas. The chicken salad is light and flavorful.

Shopping at Madison Market is such a pleasant experience. They have an extensive offering in just about every department, but the selection isnt overwhelming like at huge chain stores, which means I can shop with efficiency.

Yummy potato, egg and fontina cheese sandwich, I cant wait to go back and try the pizza

Excellent capuchino. The croissant was fresh. Great service and the selection of wines are outstanding. Great place to have lunch or dinner with a great selection of pasta, pizzas, soups and sandwiches. Thank you for being there.

Absolutely delicious pastries!!! They’re so beautiful and taste like heaven. I could live on the cookies and milk pastry alone.

Definitely try their pizza!!! My go to is their Margherita Pie (little extra sauce) - tried their dessert today in their bakery section - excellent options including their gelato.The service was excellent - kudos to the team working Tuesday evening when I stopped in.

Love the store. Good quality products. Very clean. Great lighting and food is delicious. The 1 hour drive was definitely worth it. I will definitely return.

They have breakfast sandwiches and theyre great! Strong Coffee/latte game and a full market really top it off.

This place is the best! Reminds me of a European Market thats in my back yard!

Just tried the new FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH...OMG ITS INCREDIBLE! Another delicious addition to their already amazing menu! Keep up the awesome work Madison Market!!!

Great sandwich with quality ingredients.

I recently tried their taylor ham breakfast sandwich. One of the best Ive had in twenty plus years in NJ. Fantastic wine selection and lunch / catering options

One of our favorite places in the area. ALL the food here is incredible! Make sure you try the pizzas and the coffee. Best place in town. Love the management and team as well!

They make really good, high quality stuff there. I love their sandwiches and desserts.

Never in my life have I seen such atrocious service. I heard it from a reliable source, that this business lays of workers without just cause and then has the nerve to ask those employees to not complain! I will be returning to this sorry excuse for a market when hell freezes over.

The coffee here is the best in town. The place is very clean and organized. The pasta, pizza and bread are also all very good. We have been going at least once a week since they opened.

Amazing addition to the Madison / Chatham food scene. After moving from NYC a year or so ago, I thought it would require a commute to the city to get great pizza. Not anymore, Madison Market pizza is the best around! Best coffee in the area, too!!

Beautiful new gourmet food hall and market located with plenty of parking behind Walgreens in Madison. Offering some pre-prepared meals, wines, meats etc., a wonderful espresso bar and gelato. The smell of fresh baked bread and croissants in the parking lot is amazing.

The chicken cutlet sammich was very tasty! It was pricey but for a town like Madison, it is reasonable. I would recommend it

6/27/20 Takeout dinner: Prompt courteous knowledgable phone person, reasonable prices, generous servings of interesting food. The Lasagna Verde was excellent! Their gelato was the perfect finishing touch. Will order again often. Very impressed with Madison’s newest dining experience!

Nice place....great quality and prices to match.

Beautiful, high end market joining the Madison community! Elegant inside, the market offers a meat counter, deli, bakery and fresh pasta station. Plenty of freshly prepared foods too! Service is very friendly!

Very impressed so far. We went today for the soft open and are excited to go back next week for the full open. We got some pastas and other groceries we hadnt been able to find elsewhere. We also got a pre-made prochetta sandwich which was delicious. The interior is really nice and I could easily see myself coming back here for a quick lunch or to sit down with a coffee.

Went there a few days ago, food was okay but the service was slow and and the food was way overpriced. Do yourself a favor and go to the diner across the street better service and quality for better price.

A much needed place in Madison. Everything we have tried so far is great.

Yummy chicken sandwich. Fantastic coffee. Super nice place.

Portions for eggplant parmigiana were incredibly small for $14.85! Very pricey.

Very cool market with fresh homemade pasta, pizza, and other delicious treats!

Only expensive food choices

Great addition to the town. Liked all the food variety and vibes.

Wow, just wow. The place just opened up. A full deli case, coal fired pizza AND gelato? Yes, please!

Love the attitude and cappuccino and croissants are amazing here!!!

Great people, great service!

Amazing pizza for a great price!

Best sausages I ever tasted

Remarkable place, with great workers

The gelato is WONDERFUL!!!!!!

Killer pizza!!!

Pizza margherita