This place is the best.The bagels are fantastic and so is the selection and service.I had a Babel Bomb which is a ball shaped bagel stuffed with bacon and cheese.It was as delicious as it sounds!

Best bagels I’ve had on the island. I love their assortment of bagels and cream cheeses. The hot sandwiches are so so good. Love the food and really appreciate the kind service. You can expect a line on weekends but it’s honestly worth it.

We visit family on the island and this is always one of our stops. We love grabbing bagels to bring back home to freeze. Amazing selection and everything is delicious. I highly recommend the scones.

Hands down best bagel store in the area! The staff make sure to keep that line moving all while smiling and making sure you get exact what you want. I’ve ordered breakfast for my office a few times and even my co workers love the bagels and coffee. The weekend bagel specials are unseen anywhere else. I love to support local businesses that return the favor and support the community and Seaford Bagels is top notch with community support!

The welcome here is everything. I was working around the area and needed something to eat. I stoped here and the place is very cute and super clean. Kelly was amazing. I’ll definitely be back. She made me feel so welcomed, was patient, listened to my order and even made delicious suggestions. My bagelwich was mouthwatering & out of this world. Their sliced garlic pickle and green olives?!? Just waow.Thank you!

Always love going to SEAFORD BAGELS.. Best bagels anywhere. Lots of choices, many homemade cream cheese flavors and prices are great.

One of my favorite bagel places on the island. egg sandwiches are amazing.

Very tasty bagels and fresh, Seems to have one of a lower prices around

The best bagel store. Also friendly staff

Fast service from attentive team. The bagels were fantastic. Pulling up, I recoiled a bit because the line was outside the place into the parking lot, almost made me turn away, BUT if the lines are like this, then there must be something everyone wants right? So I waited, surprised at how fast the line moved. The register area gets a bit muddled with just a large group of people with nowhere to go while they wait to pay. Either way, Ive returned a few times, and this will be my go to bagel spot.

There was such a great selection it was nearly impossible to choose what I wanted. I got a bagel with cream cheese and wasnt disappointed. They were VERY generous with the amount of cream cheese. I couldnt even finish it. I ate half and saved the other half for later. The staff was also super friendly

Best bagel shop in the area. So glad Bagel Wagon changed management and converted to an awkward Taco joint, because that forced me to look elsewhere and find Seaford. My new go-to spot whenever back in town. Top notch bagels and a ton of other offerings. Well staffed with fast and friendly service. Gotta love that.

Love this place! My husband and I only go here for bagels. So fresh & great customer service!

Best bagels in the area. Staff is amazing. Heather and Rachel and staff are the nicest people to work with. I have a lot of positive things about the store I can say. The store is Covid-19 safe. Great owner and cares about customers and staff

The bagels are good. The older biter woman that served us made the experience so bad I will never go back.

Nice staff and owner, work well under pressure

Good bagels!! Need more counter people!

I enjoyed every bit of the bagels I had the rainbow with cream cheese delicious 🤗🥨

Dealt with an Isabella, and my god was she so rude! Literally saying disrespectful things about me right in front of me. When I confronted her about it, she just gave me more attitude. What an absolutely unprofessional place. I just wanted some egg salad, and it appears this place hires unprofessional rude employees who were not schooled on basic customer service and human interaction. I’d give zero stars if possible.

Bagel, thinly hand sliced lox, vegetable cream cheese, white fish spread, salmon spread. Buy the tomatoes and onion 🧅 elsewhere but that’s a classic that my family has been eating for ages. They got it at seafood bagels. All of the above and it’s the best quality around the here.

I love their garlic and herb cream cheese on an everything bagel. The strawberry is amazing too.

Excellent bagels and delicious cream cheese. Never had a good cup of coffee here. Otherwise, great place with huge selection.

Very nice place to have breakfast love it I will come back again

Seaford bagels is a place that I’ve been coming to for 15 years. It’s a place that I’ve spent most of my Sunday mornings for breakfast over those last years. The staff was always extremely friendly, and the bagels and all their food were always great.Unfortunately I will no longer be going here.Over the past year or so I’ve been treated rudely, and it seems to me that they almost don’t care that you give them your business.Today was the final straw for me. I called up to place an order and was hung up on. I called back and was hung up on again. The third time I called a women answered very rudely. I asked if they were still making eggs, she responded with “yea”I then asked may I place an order to pick up and she responded with “we don’t take orders, you have to come in”I then drove to the store and arrived about 5-10 minutes after the call I placed (I live three blocks away) As I went to place my order they told me they are not making eggs anymore. I replied that I just called and was told that you were.A younger man then answered me,” im sorry we just closed the grill and we are closing soon”.I then asked, you do not take orders over the phone anymore? He replied, “no, we are to busy for that”(mind you their were 3 people in the place at this time) I decided just to grab a cup of coffee and leave. I waited for 5 minutes at the counter to pay while at least 5 workers walked past me and didn’t say a thing. I then politely asked a women if she could ring up my cup of coffee. She did ring me up but it seemed as if I was bothering her. I understand the the times we are in are rough but your customers should always come first. I own a pizzeria, so I understand what’s it’s like to be in a fast pace take out environment. I’m really not one to leave reviews or complain. It really takes a lot for me to complain about a place, but after today I was so turned off. This place was always a 5 star establishment but now it’s a 1-2 at best. The only reason I gave three stars is because the bagels are very good.

Great breakfast selections and the food was delcious 🥯🥞🥐 The really friendly staff helps you super quickly. Looking forward to going back again

Friendly people, great bagels n I love the prices

Amazing egg sandwich and great food in general. Only thing holding back 5 stars in the service is a bit disorganized.

One of the better bagel shops in the area. Get there early- they sell.out.

The absolute BEST whitefish salad!

I drive in from Florida every two months and this is my first stop for bagels.

I will have to visit again..

Best fresh bagels ever had also got 6 free with a dozen!

Friendly and helpful staff...and fantastic bagels.

This is why New York is famous for bagels! Super soft, chewy inside, crisp outside. They are fresh, the toppings are fresh, but a dozen get 18. The promising sign that it is good, is the place is always busy. Perfect breakfast on a Sunday morning after swim lessons!

Seaford Bagels is always my first destination whenever I visit New York. Their bagels here have the perfect crisp that anyone is looking for and it always tastes fresh. There are plenty of sandwiches and bread to choose from, and the staff members greet their customers with a smile. They definitely have the best of the best bread and sandwiches in the city and I am recommending it.

Delicious! Staff is very nice

Great selection and great service

Really good lox and cream cheese bagel, nice staff and good options. The price wasnt bad, the lox was fresh, bagel was soft and I was served quickly. Menu looked pretty expensive and the sour pickle and pasta salad with my bagel were great too. One of the better non-chain bagel places on the island. Recommended!

The best Bagels on the east coast

Excellent selection of bagels wraps and anything you need from a bagel deli.

Bagels/pastries have a good presentation. However,the bagels are never hot/warm as anticipated early am. Secondly, only gripe, chicken salad not that great,dry,egg salad very good as well as egg sanwiches,lox,etc. Cream cheese surprisingly delicious. Now,as for the workers,NOI,no offense intented, very very low talkers,and there seems to be constant repetitive ordering process,due to lack of a language barrier . This place has great potential, providing management/employee future plans to discuss how to better serve the public in a more clear,efficient way. As a business owner/operator, without my customers,whom are everything, as they should be,as owners we would not survive! Safety, mannerisms, and clarity are one of the essential parts of running a business during these delicate unfortunate times. Lets all be well and respectful towards others during this pandemic and be open to learn.We the people can and should make that difference!

Vegan tofu creamcheese & veggie tofu creamcheese are so scrumptious i drive 20 minutes just to go here w my girlfriend. Love it. Great hidden vegan gem. They only have almond milk but thats okay

From breakfast to lunch, all is good. Amazing bagels, amazing cream cheeses and lots to select from. Love the crew that works there too.

Bagels are pretty good, way too many Trump & blue lives matter people in there for me.

Great bagels and line moved fast

This is one of my favorite bagel shops; lots of salads, sandwiches to order, breakfast specials, and a very nice coffee bar!Free parking is behind the store, and sometimes gets crowded, but the bagels are worth it!.the counter staff (there is no table service) is friendly and aim to please, especially if you liked a toasted or scooped out bagel.For breakfast and lunch you cant go wrong!

Awesome great crew

Pretty good!

The best bagels! They need morevegan options. 3.5 stars

Amazing bagels friendly Staff. ⬛️⬛️🟦⬛️⬛️This place is a must go !!!

Perfect texture bagel, clean store, hot coffee, short wait.

Best pickles. I am a fanatic. I have been to many pickle bars. Fresh, crunchy, correct salt content, and seed size. I did not have a bagel yet. Great chicken salad!

The bagels are too damn good. You know what actually? Dont go. Less people in line and more bagels for me.

Great bagel shop. The line can be pretty long sometimes but it moves. Great for breakfast and brunch. The staff is friendly.

This is one of the best bagel joints on the south shore! If you’re looking for a deli, this isn’t the place you want. But if you’re looking for fresh, soft, amazing bagels and bagel sandwiches this is where you want to be. The line out the door says it all.

Great place for breakfast if you are into bagels. You can sit down and eat there if you want.

Great food awesome staff. Everyone us super friendly.

One of the best bagel establishments hands down. Prices are great and everything is s fresh as it gets. Thank God this is close to me..

Great bagels. Owner is a really nice guy.

My family and I have frequented this bagel store for many years. We have had nothing but great service, big smiles, and amazing bagels. This establishment is made up of people who are hard working and always kind.

If you like egg, cheese and bacon on a bagel, this is your place! Fresh, made to order and delicious. . All the bagels are great as well.

Good service! Very friendly and accommodating...

I’ve been coming here for years and I’ve about had the last straw with this place. Extremely rude staff, and consistently gets my order wrong, and very slow service. I usually ask for a plain bagel w cream cheese and they never get it right. It’s strange how they can’t get such a simple order right over and over again. I’ve watched the staff be rude to not only me, but to other customers as well for things that is CLEARLY the staffs fault. Staff really needs to work on their people skills as I will not be coming back anytime soon.

Poor management skills and rude attitude from the old-day manager who cannot perform her basic tasks.

Seaford Bagels will always be great. Fresh eggs, fresh meat, fresh cream cheese, fresh everything and excellent service on top of that. They are the best for a reason.

Great long time local bagel store

Lights are on, staff is in, hours are posted, but I got no service. Might try again sometime,, maybe

My family has been going to this place for at least 21 years. The bagels are great but the people seem overworked. There is always a line but it is definitely worth the wait.

This used to be great, but now every time I come in for the Friday, Saturday and Sunday bagel specials I ALWAYS get short. Theres NO 18 bagels!Im changing bagel shops.

Worlds Greatest Bagels. I rarely eat one that isnt from here. I would wait months at a time when I was living out of state to come back for hot Seaford bagels.

Love this place great service good bagels and coffee

They always make my breakfast sandwiches to perfection and the coffee is never burnt.

Been going to Seaford Bagel for 15-20 years.Still have a large virioty of bagesl types and flavors. Also, cupcakes and cookies. Highly recommend. Go now!!!

My heart beats for Seaford bagels. As a native long islander now residing in Florida, you dont realize how spoiled you get living around the best bagels (and pizza) until you move away from it. Needless to say every time I go home my first stop is here. Theres nothing better than a hot (NOT TOASTED- hot right out of the oven, if you ask they will tell you what bagels are hot) everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. NOTHING BETTER!

Great service, best bagles around! Salads are also good. Coffee is better than most places.

Kelly. Rachelle and staff amazing. Best bagel store in town.

Good service and reasonable prices. Nothing to write home about.

Best 🥯 bagels ever!!

Good bagels, great price and very friendly counter staff.

Great bagels, everything here is good. Friendly staff... highly recommend

Great bagels, salads and service! Excellent selection of bagels and cream cheese.

Always loved Seaford Bagels! Went to get lunch here when I worked in Massapequa Schools and on weekends when living in Wantagh. Ive since retired and live out east. Whenever Im in the area I go to this store! Great food and nice, cheerful staff.

The absolute best bagels on planet earth. Egg sandwiches are amazing. Wonderful service.

Very good food and a very nice staff!

Excellent, fresh bagels and friendly service was awesome

Delicious food, great prices, and friendly staff!

Pricy but good, parking here is very tight, busy most morning great selection of bagels and fresh spreads, and coffee galore, plenty of staff working in the am..tables to eat at, but might have to wait for them to open up...4 stars .....5 stars if the cost was appropriate....

My favorite place to get all my bagel needs! Everything is so fresh and tastes amazing. They even have complementary coffee!

A great bagel place with amazing bagels

Wonderful place. Excellent bagels sn DC great staff

Best bagel joint in Seaford/Massapequa area.Egg everything bagel is a must try!

Would be a better place to get something to eat, but the workers there, have no manners and are very rude... Not a Bagel establishment, where I would like to spend my money...

Very good. Thanks

Best bagels around.

Best beagles around with friendly, welcoming staff and owner.

Good bagels, good selection, friendly service

Best bagels anywhere. They get busy but worth the wait

Always fresh and delicious. Theyre busy for a reason, dont worry the line moves.

Great Bagels! Long line moves quick.

These are some of the great Long Island bagels. They always satisfy the bagel craving.