Indy Garry was a superb salesperson. Gave me information I needed and was really down to earth. I will definitely return when Im ready for another truck. My overall experience was excellent. I drove 5hrs to get there, and Indy made sure I was taken care of my whole visit, even down to offering refreshments while I wait.

Amato Automotive has been a fixture in the Milwaukee area for decades...and for good reason! They care deeply about people, as evidenced by their numerous philanthropic endeavors and are always willing to help others anyway they can.When I approached JR about sponsoring an Oktoberfest event at the non-profit senior living community I work for, he didnt hesitate and stepped right up to the plate. This is just one example of the real commitment Amato Auto has to the people of Milwaukee and demonstrates that they dont just talk the talk, they take action!I want to publicly thank Amato Auto for their generous donation; without it our upcoming Oktoberfest event would not have been possible. Thank you, you all are undoubtedly a true asset to our community.

Antonio took great care of me. He kept me informed off costs and estimates of when my vehicle service would be complete. Outstanding customer service!

I love going to John Amato to get my vehicle serviced. I always get great customer service and always am in constant communication with my service representative. Its never an all day wait they usually get the job done in the time frame you’re given. When me and my daycare waited for my appointment we were welcomed by great staff and she loved the foosball table. I would highly recommend this servicer.

Been trying to schedule warranty service for a month. Nobody called me back. I finally drove there to see them in person and they told me I should drive it to a different location that does their body work to get it looked at. They were helpful but said I needed to call back the repair number to schedule which I did and now they won’t return a call again. Horrible customer service

My experience was pleasant, no worries, and I was very satisfied with the service I received. This is my go to place for my vehicle. Thanks again. I also recommend you people give themselves the opportunity too, if your looking for vehicle service with reasonable prices.

My experience at John Amato was very rewarding. I got the car l Love and the service was great 😀😀

Fixed my vehicle in a timely and efficient manner. Extremely polite and courteous staff!

I got a car from here a few years ago and absolutely no complaints but trying to just see if Im eligible to get a car loan now I dont hear anything back Ive texted and called inde I dont hear anything back. Ive contacted the services on the website and get ill have someone contact you to tell you if you are eligible. All around poor communication from Indee.

OMG! I Love my Jeep. Indy was very professional and very understanding. He took his time with me and didnt rush me into a sell he heard my needs and wants and Im now a Jeep owner proudly from Amato. Thank you Mr Indy G.

I literally only go there because of Antonio in the service department, he is so nice, patient, understanding and very reassuring. Also I wouldnt be mad if yall put more people of hue in the service department so it can be more welcoming to people of darker shades not saying the others arent nice its just you can tell theyre more welcoming to people who looks like them if you catch my drift...but my guy Antonio definitely needs a raise hes top tier and should be treated as such 😤

Perfect experience. Fast. Affordable. And they let our toddlers run around the show room looking at all the Jeeps. I’m very happy they opened this dealership.

I went to John Amato on Green Bay Road meet the sales person Indy he introduced himself soon as I walked in. Very polite and easy to talk to. I told him exactly what I wanted and he had me on my way within 45 minutes in my brand new truck. Very good experience.

Indy Garry is the go to person at Amato. My husband and I purchased our Jeeps there and he always gets us right. Great customer service and great guy. I always refer people to him whenever they’re car shopping.

I feel like Deontay is one of your best employees thus far. He is a very informational and knowledgeable person. One major thing I liked while interacting with Deontay was him making sure all of my questions and concerns were answered and heard. I’ll definitely be referring customers to the company.

Indy made the process seamless, vibrant, and worthy. Buying a car felt more like meeting a dear friend for lunch.

One of the best experiences from any dealership! I’m overly satisfied with my visit at Amato! Thanks to Deontay Vann, great customer service & was able to tell me everything I needed to know about the car I wanted. Outstanding job, keep it up, he could be a GREAT asset to Amato!

Indy is an amazing man! Hes awesome at what he does . First time I bought a car and he made the process smooth and painless

Amato Jeep in Glendale, WI had the resources to get my Jeep in the next day. They drove me to work that morning and although my Jeep wasn’t completely finished, they got it ready for me to take home that evening after work and allowed me to drop it off first thing in the morning for finishing touches.Thanks for the great service.

I came in looking for a specific car and I worked with Ayinde and he helped me find the car I wanted and I was able to stayin my budget. The process was so easy and fast. I highly recommend this dealership. Ayinde was very professional and helpful.

Just would like to know why I cant get the Jack thats supposed to go in the truck

Deontay was such a good help with me trying to figure out what car fits best for me. He truly made me believe in Amato. Thank you so much. !

I came in for an oil change and change my wiper blades, after an hour and a half, I went out to see what’s taking so long. They told me then that they didn’t have the wiper blades in stock and they were on the way to the dealership. They should’ve told me when they found out. Finally the blades came and low and behold they were the wrong ones. It took two hours for this service (unacceptable). Fortunately they refunded my money for the mistake.

I came in to get my nissan moreno looked at for a loud clinking noise, and the service rep, i believe his name was Antonio had amazing customer service skills. He reassured me that my vehicle was in great hands and they will for sure find the source of the problem. And sure enough they did. He did not even get offended when I teased him about his heavy New York accent and how he does not pronounce his Rs.

First time purchasing a vehicle and was super nervous. Bridgette was absolutely wonderful and very informative in explaining the process! I feel so confident in my decision and I recommend you do the same!!!

Indy is truly the best! He was patient, kind, and helped me drive off in a brand new car. If you need a new car, go to Indy!

The dealership was so clean and nice. All of the staff members were so helpful and accommodating. I would recommend them to anyone!!

We were very pleased with the outcome of our Jeep purchase. We purchased our previous Jeep from a different dealership and when back thinking they would give us a good deal since we would be repeat customers. Well, they did not. (Griffin Jeep). So instead we searched around and Amato gave us the best deal. We enjoyed working with the different staff members as they were all very pleasant. We will be back to lease our next Jeep as well (as long as we get a good deal again!!)

Very trusting and reliable staff. Deontay V showed me some really nice car options that in my budget.

Indy is great. I enjoyed my experience buying a car from him.

Great service. I come there all the time. I go out my way for there service. Dodge!

Outstanding organization!! Would recommend to anyone looking for a new or used car. Ask for JR.

Zach kundinger in sales made the experience here so wonderful! Looking forward to coming back here for future car needs.

Great job all around. Great place. Super nice facility

Deonte Vann Did a great job at assisting me to find a car that helps fit my budget and also what best fits my lifestyleAppreciate the help 😁

Deontay has been very resourceful since been given a chance He is a great addition and will be a good once he learnings and grow in you guys family

I had several Jeeps and Vans in the last 10 years. John Amatos center was very professional and efficient in the repair of my vehicle needs.

This team always has great customer service anytime I have taken my truck there!!

Gave fair price on trade in, went extra mile to secure second chane financing and brought truck that was perfect for us no need to search lot. Paul knew what we wanted

My visits lately have been ok.cuwtomer service has changed I would love to see smiles and more help..its always a bit somber when I arrive..

The Service department is really unfriendly and impersonal. My Jeep had an issue and I was told three different things regarding the Diagnostic fee being used towards repairs if I decide to get work done.I didnt end up getting work done so I owed the diagnostic fee which was fine. The guy I dealt with in service was more interested in conversing with associates then assisting me. I needed them to switch my plates from one vehicle to another and they had me drive both my vehicles (one that had already been there getting diagnosed) into the service bay.The assoiciate I was dealing with saw the new car I got and indirectly insuated that it was a downgrade compared to.the vehicle I had them diagnosis that had a bad transmission. Going from a 2014 Cherokee with cosmetic, defects, bad trans, and a basic model to a 2018 Compass Altidue with heated seats, back up camera, beats audio...downgrade? Yeah okay. Guy with the low fro or low fade dont truly remember his looks as much as his meager service.

Called at the last minute and they took my Promaster in for an oil change and tune-uppronto. As an out-of-towner, I appreciated the quick and professional service.

I don’t know a lot about cars esspecially newer ones but Deontay gave me some good info and I think he could other ppl like me too who don’t know a lot about cars.

Deontay was very helpful and did a great job in finding a car within my budget!

Friendly employees. Fair prices for service work. Will be back again.

Great service, excellent feedback and communication on issues or improvements that come up on my vehicle.

Deontay was very helpful and informational. When I look too buy a car again hell be the guy I go to.

Deontay Vann was a very good help with my car search there at AmatoVery professional young man

Everything is so AWESOME about this dealership thus far!!! Service department, Sales department & Courtesy Rides.

Russ has been the best car salesman I’ve ever worked with. Let me know I should fill out the financing ahead of time; cut down time spent at dealership. Michelle in financing was very nice and wasn’t pushy when I declined the various warranty and add-ons. Could’ve been a 5 star if the gas tank was full and a proper detail was done.. Just seemed like they washed car. Highly recommend asking for Big Russ when you visit!

Great dealership and the best Service, Nick Kundinger was absolutely wonderful. Friendly yet professional. We will enjoy working with him each time we have to need. He is a real gem!

Im very disappointed in the service department of John Amato. I bought a complete set of 4 tires and the dealership threw away my spare tire which I drove in on. I tried working with Matt in the service department and he straight up ignored me even after he said he would make it right. Then I was contacted via email by Dan Nilsestuen and he asked what he could do to fix the situation. I replied, and he then ignored me. I gave him a month as of today to reply, so I would think that would be enough time.In the future Im getting my car serviced elsewhere.

I had an awesome experience with Ayinde Garry, and I’d recommend John Amato to everyone!!!

Very friendly and helpful staff! I wouldn’t trust my vehicle with anyone else!

Very happy with the service performed by this dealer. I will bring my car back again.

My family have been loyal customers to this dealership but with the last truck purchase will stop us from going there ever again. We purchased a truck with specific options and it turned out the manager dan hid some issues from us and refused to come to a middle ground. He argued and even yelled at us saying he does not care and that our only option is to sell the truck back to him. Even when it came to light the truck had issues he said he does not care and will not touch the truck. We have even tried to contact the store owner or someone higher up than him and left countless messages but they also refuse to acknowledge any of it. Even others that work there have said that dan the manager is rude and disrespectful to paying customers because “all he cares about is his bottom dollar” and simply “doesnt care”. Never ever going back and plead with others not to either. They simply dont care about customers just their bottom dollar

Its was great appointment on time. Car was ready when they said it would be.

I know its not a huge deal to everyone but the girl in the service department was too nonchalant about putting standard oil instead of synthetic oil in my Jeep. I had an appointment for synthetic. Now I have to come back 2000 miles earlier due to their error. That makes a big difference to someone who drives a lot. Without otherwise apologizing she threw a card at me thats good for a free tire rotation next time. Time is money. I will not be returning.The good - Its a nice newer facility.The bad - Its pretty much in the hood. Very close. Also apparently they dont pay attention to the details.

Great service all the way around! My salesman was totally awesome. He went above and beyond to find me a great car within my budget. Very pleasant and polite, took time to answer all my questions thoroughly, great sense of humor as well. I admit, the process was a little more lengthy than I expected, but it was worth every bit of the wait. I pulled off the lot with a 2019 Nissan Altima, and I absolutely love it. Thanks again Robbie Fulton, for getting me right!!

Very helpful and patient with servicing my vehicle. Will do business with them in the future!

Awesome customer service. Second to none.

The service was phenomenal. The sales rep Russell Monroe and the financial specialist Michelle took there time to make sure I was happy with my purchase. Over all great experience very helpful.

They were very honest with me and took care of the problem right away

Walked in and left out with the best experience I ever had at any dealership! Customer service was on point, all questions asked I got the right answers to! Thanks to Deontay I will be coming back to look for my dream car!

I always go to Amato. They have never failed me. No matter what they make the numbers work. Will be back again. See my boy Ayinde when you get there.

You guys. This is not Tim, but his wife Allie. I just called John Amato for a deal that was waaaaaaay too good to be true, and it was, it was a typo online.BUT I was talking to Bridgette Hill, the sales woman, and shes the bees knees, the bomb.com and any other name for a person who is awesome. She was helpful, fun, and in the 5 minutes that we were on the phone together, Im pretty sure we became best friends.If you are in the market for a new car, go to Bridgette, she will steer you in the right direction and get you what youre looking for and more!!

Very professional and helpful Ill be back.

Really wanted to buy from here but the sales person never messaged me back with what I was looking for. Poor Communication.

🗣 Listen when i say Big Russ is the best i mean That.. I read the reviews before i came because my trade was not for the weak i needed an salesman that was not gone waste my time.. I came in at 10:15ish got approved at noon 🙌🏾 & i got the Vehical i wanted.. Let’s just say I’m out here this summer black on black stankin Lancoln as my dad would say.. Stay tune because i do do part 2’s to my reviews.. Remember it cost nothing to be nice businesses are supposed to be nice.. It’s the after purchase & when something goes wrong is what need to be reviewed.. You know after they get your money.. Stay tuned ppl for my part 2

I just recently bought this 2013 VW Jetta SEL at this location and it was a mistake. The actual buying process was extremely tedious, dont expect to be here for less than 4 hours.I also have been having problems with the backup camera, which I called to address, only to be bounced around different voicemails for 3 days straight and then receive a call back 4 days later.I scheduled an appointment for them to diagnose my problem so they could give me a price quote for a problem that was obviously there when I bought the car and was not disclosed clearly, and was even used as a selling point despite the fine print stating otherwise. There was no verbal mention of a problem, intermittent or not. There are even inaccuracies in the paperwork such as the trunk not functioning when it does.After sitting in the dealership for over an hour, during which time no actual diagnostic was actually performed, I was informed that they cannot even tell me what the problem with the camera is because their technicians dont know the wiring layout of VWs.1/5 stars, I probably would not purchase from this location again and I warn others to be cautious if they do decide to come here.***I would also like to edit my review to reflect that I had set up an appointment with Indy despite the reply saying I had no appointment, I will attach pictures of texts proving otherwise.I would again like to reiterate that there was NO mention of a camera problem the day of the purchase, either by the manager or the sales person I worked with. Yes there was something briefly mentioned in the paperwork, but the problem in question was not disclosed verbally and I was only made aware of that stipulation in the contract after calling for 4 days.Also if it was a known problem why would I be called in to diagnose a problem you already knew of? In fact, the back up camera worked for the first 4 days I had the car. I honestly believe it was rigged to work for however long that they needed it to so they could sell the car.

My experience at John Amato was outstanding. It started with outstanding service from both Al and Indy and was completed with a deal that I was very happy with. The entire process was short and sweet and I never once felt hassled or pressured to do anything. That includes the finance department. Very friendly all around atmosphere. This was the 5th dealership I had gone to in the past 3 months and I will definitely be going back and recommending others to go to John Amato as well.

Al,Matuan and Indy(no particular order) These guys got the job done! When i say they went above and beyond without me having to ask..i mean it. Im pretty sure that i got the best deal ANY dealer in the whole state would give. Im greatly appreciative and very happy... especially in my new candlestick baby! 🔥🔥💯💯Thanks fellas!

I had a great customer service experience and Robbie F. was very diligent and patient in helping me to decide which Jeep would get me the best value for my money and taste. I left with a vehicle that I was proud to own and knowing that I made the right decision based on Robbies feedback. I would recommend this place to anyone that is looking to purchase a new vehicle.

Awesome experience purchasing my new 2020 Ram 2500. From the beginning to the end it was a hassle free and ZERO stress. No haggling awesome price that beat the competition hands down JR Amato, Christie Torch and Derrick Humphrey were the most professional and awesome sales team that I have ever encountered.As a business owner time is of essence and I don’t have time to play the sales game and this is where Amato shined. This deal took less then one hour from the first call to the delivery!Awesome job Team Amato and thank you I’ll be back again for my next one!!

Bridgette was my sales person and she was amazing! Thanks Bridgette!

Horrible service. Never doing business with them again.

I worked with both John Gordon and Robbie Fulton in purchasing my new 2020 Dodge. John contacted me initially after I sent an email showing interest in the car. He then directed me to work with Robbie. The price negotiation went smoothly and did not take long to agree on the price. Also had the pleasure of meeting J.R. Amato. I would highly recommend going to Amato Chrysler in Glendale WI should you be looking for a car. They will treat you well. Good job !!

Nick Kundinger always takes care of me and my car clubs automotive needs! Would trust no one else!

I just purchased my car from here today and I had such amazing service! From beginning to end of the process, JC was the kind salesman you hope helps you at the dealership, who goes that extra mile for customers. I really like his personality as a salesman, he was respectful to me, I felt like I got the royal treatment, even though I bought a used car. He was super flexible about letting me test drive for a few days, gased up and washed my car. I would definitely stop in to see him for my next car. At the end, I had more questions about the forever warranty and the gentleman at the front desk, helped me make figure out the maintenance schedule needed to maintain my warranty for my car, which is not a typical make for this dealership. He sent me links before I left the building which I am really thankful I have so I know how to move forward and keep my warranty. Thank you!!! Today was a good day!

My experience was great Indy was awesome.

This post is going to be a lengthy one so bare with me. From day one working with Amato it has been a headache. Towards the end of February, someone totaled my boyfriends fairly new Subaru WRX. A few weeks later, we saw an ad for Amato for an even newer WRX, with a LIFETIME powertrain warranty. The toss up for a new car was between them and another dealer in Illinois, but we chose them strictly for the WARRANTY. Fast forward to the purchase of the car, which we bought from Bridgette Hill. We went through Michelle Ziegler for financing, and it was very unprofessional. Between us and the couple behind us in line to speak with Michelle, we all agreed she is very unprofessional and flirty with the men who come into her office. Her top buttons were undone and she constantly felt the need to go out of her way to make comments regarding my boyfriends impressive tastes in cars, and even flirted with his dad. On the way home the tire pressure light went on, we noticed the detailer cut the window tint, and he even left the razor blade facing upwards on the floor! Right where I sit, how perfect. We contacted them about this, was given no response by multiple people. Let’s fast forward even more time, we tried to contact them regarding the LIFETIME POWERTRAIN WARRANTY that was given to us, and they said to contact the warranty company. We did, they said given the fact that it was a Subaru, that dealer can’t help us (even though they sold it to us), and that any aftermarket parts on the car voided the warranty. At the time of purchase, Amato sold us this car with 3 aftermarket parts already on it. So they hyped up a warranty that was already voided prior to purchase. When this was brought to their attention, they basically couldn’t do anything about it due to “not having a Subaru Technician, they cannot help us with a Subaru”. So keep this in mind when buying a car from Amato, the warranty may not actually exist even if it’s advertised that it will. Not only has working with Amato been a headache, but it has caused even more stress after totaling a dream car. Never again would I choose or recommend John Amato Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram of Milwaukee.

LOVED MY EXPERIENCE HERE TODAY!! Walked in to get an oil change on my Wrangler and RUSS got me a brand new Jeep with all the fixings for even less !!! 10/10 customer service from him and he made sure I was veryyyy satisfied! I’m too please 🙌🏾🙌🏾

Very impressed with the professional service I received from Antonio today. Im big on customer service and he offered great customer service.

2nd Ram Truck Purchase this year from Amato and both times the service and staff have been flawless! Smooth and effortless.. I’ll be back soon for another truck..

This company is amazing! I am so incredibly impressed by their integrity and commitment to customer satisfaction! Such a wonderful business!!! We bought a car from them from out of state and needed to return it. Needless to say I highly recommend them! Buy your car here, they care about their customers and are worth your trust!

Great service. Always helpful.

Excellent service. service department goes above and beyond for anything you need. very understandable staff. friendly shuttle service. overall experience was absolutely amazing!! definitely worth going here or a dealership for your needs!!

Did get what I want😔 but I love my truck.... thank you indy

My experience and John Amato has been nothing less that spectacular, every time Ive had my truck serviced there the staff is very friendly and concerned to fix my needs. The work has been completed in a timely manner and have never needed to return for the same issue. Big thank you to the staff!

Deontay was a great help, hes an awesome asset to Amato

My experience at Amato has been hands down the best experience I’ve had in a long time. Bridget in sales has out done herself not once, but twice. She zeroed in on my family’s need and we left with everything we asked for and more. If there is a need for an upgrade or a trade, see Bridget in sale and she will take care of you.

Did not do my alignment correctly had to go to Jerrys on sherman

I am a proud customer of a 2017 Ford Escape, Ayinde (Indy) was great along with Martaun. Very down to earth sales men. A joke or two with a smile made my day being tired coming to them after work. Thanks you guys for your great service.

I just purchased my car from here today and I had the absolute best service! From beginning to end of the process, Indy was the kind salesman you hope helps you at the dealership, who goes that extra mile for customers. I really like his personality as a salesman, he was respectful to me, I felt like I got the royal treatment. I am really thankful for JR and Indy for helping me to achieve the vehicle I was going for. Thank you!!! Today was a great day!

First I will like to thank Big Russ which was my sales consultant, he was excellent I give him 5 *****, he put me in the vehicle I wanted, he went above and beyond in making sure, me as his customer was happy and satisfied, which I am, he’s amazing 🤩 folks if you’re looking for a sales consultant who will get you what you want Russ is your man, the overall experience was excellent from the front desk to finance department. 5 *****

This was my first time having service work done at John Amato, and I was very impressed! All the employees I interacted with were courteous and professional, and the communication about my vehicle was efficient and prompt. I also feel they were not in it for the money and made customer service a priority.

I had the pleasure of working with Al & Russell, they were both extremely knowledgeable & professional! A big kudos to them both for their great service and finding the best automobile for me! A BIG thanks to them both!

Purchased a 2020 Jeep for Cash. Vehicle was shipped and arrived without Title or any original documentation. Contacted dealership several times but was given the run around by a salesman who tried to convince me I didnt need a title to register the vehicle. I called and asked to speak with JR, the general manager, but he never answered any of my calls and does not accept voice messages. I texted him and got the same results-NO RESPONSE! Still waiting on the title while they have been paid in full for a week! BEWARE

We’ve had problems in the past but this time they were very clear this time and communication was better.

Costumer service was amazing . I was highly satisfied with the quality of my experience. I would like to give a special shout out to Alex Hughes, he was a wonderful sales associate.