user
Bagels Your Way Cafe
2799 NY-112 # 8, Medford, NY 11763, United States
Appearance
Bagels Your Way Cafe
Comments
Mi
Review №1

The absolutely worse deli I have ever been too. The owners behavior is appalling. I never have been to a place where they spoke to there costumers like that. The staff are unprofessional and don’t know what they are doing. It’s like a bunch of kids having a chat session and get bothered when you make an order. Forget if they make a mistake on your order they will argue with you! The food is horrible also! Do not waste your time take the extra 5 minutes and go to another deli! Shocked this place hasn’t closed down yet!!!!!

Br
Review №2

Owners and staff are completely rude to there costumers. Would not waste your money! The food is just as bad! Some of the 5 star reviews are their staff! Don’t be fooled

Ju
Review №3

Amazing breakfast!! Love the selection!!! Great staff, baseball team came in for breakfast and the team there was very helpful and awsome!!! When at the Island gotta hit the Bagwla your way!!!

Ol
Review №4

Really delicious place with VEGAN breakfast sandwiches! Theyre always delicious and the service is friendly.Update: It appears that the bacon and sausage were mislabeled as vegan and are actually vegetarian. Other vegan products appear to be correctly labeled.

K
Review №5

What place purposely takes their phone off the hook? They are so many staff members behind the counter you cant put 1 person on the phone to handle orders? Some people rely on pick up for reasons. And why would i place a pick up on door dash etc for more expensive prices? **Cant wait for the owner joeys rude responses on this like he does with every other paying customer review. Look through them youll see how he always blames the paying customer, not his staff. ** Only a couple staff here are pleasant to talk to and actually do well.

Ar
Review №6

The food is fresh made and delicious. Dont worry about a crowd online. This place has such a great system to hand out preordered food as well as walk in orders. I was served and out so quickly! Also, they have a number of booths if you want to stay a while.

zs
Review №7

The owner here was absolutely rude. I walked in to see him yelling at his workers. He then yelled at me when another worker tried to assist me and then made me wait to pick up my food that was already sitting on the counter ready. My family and I have spent a lot of money at this establishment for several years. Never again. The behavior I witnessed today was completely appalling.

ja
Review №8

Terrible customer service for a mediocre product, I mean, almost $8 for a bacon egg and cheese? To be made badly? The old lady cashing people was eating breakfast the same time she was ringing, nasty attitude. The sign at the register says, be nice or get out, that should apply to the people working there as well. Too expensive, no order, nasty employees, I know that place has been there a while not sure how, dont waste your money or time, the egg sandwiches were not good. Ill never go there again.

jo
Review №9

Breakfast was awesome. Egg sandwich: creamy cheese, crispy bacon and eggs scrambled just right. Ordered some bagels to go and they are spectacular.

Sh
Review №10

I am happy to see they have vegan options. I got 2 vegan egg sandwiches with vegan egg vegan cheese and vegan bacon. I was charged $22. I new getting vegan options would be a little more but as the picture shows, this is not a $11 dollar sandwich. Cheese not even melted. And please dont tell me it doesnt melt because its vegan, I use vegan cheese everyday and it melts beautifully. Theres no excuse for this and its sad because theres not many deli options for vegans yet.

Ja
Review №11

Ordered through Uber eats. Got a dozen bagels and two coffees. The bagels were pretty good and the food was delivered quickly.

Au
Review №12

Every time I order, even early in the morning the bagels are hard. Never taste fresh. Hard enough that 1/2 way through my jaw literally hurts. Cannot enjoy at all. Deli iced tea is also not your typical deli Ice tea, it’s gross unless you like sweet tea. Only gave 2 stars bc delivery is fast but I wouldn’t order here again.

Ro
Review №13

I’m really disappointed I go to this place all the time and recently it’s been worse and worse. My bacon egg and cheese had no bacon on one side. The time before that they forgot the cheese. I normally don’t judge because I know it gets crazy busy and I wait no problem even if it takes longer but not getting what you even ordered is unfair.

sa
Review №14

Stopped her while visiting family. Great place with a truly friendly staff! The kind of hospitality that you rarely see any more!

Ja
Review №15

Great food. Prepared fast and to your liking.

So
Review №16

Every time I come here I ask for them to let the bagel cool off before buttering it because every single time I come home to a pool of butter seeping through the entire bag with a ruined bagel. When I ask for them to cool it off they say you can butter it yourself. Absolutely rude, what am I paying you for. I always give the benefit of the doubt and they continue to do this

et
Review №17

Open later then any other bagel store around. Always stocked with fresh bagels of all flavors. Excellent customer service, fast service. Food always excellent.

As
Review №18

Not only is there food terrible there costumer service is even worse. The 3 owners and staff there are beyond rude and are disgusting to there costumers. They have a bunch of teenagers running around fighting in front of the costumers also! Would not waste my time or money!

Be
Review №19

They forgot something on an order, which happens. I called and let them know. The manager delivered it to my house within 30 minutes. Great customer service and the food was fresh and delicious.

Jo
Review №20

Standard bacon egg and cheese on a roll, but with a premium price. Youll pay almost twice the price of any other deli in the area.

Ka
Review №21

I gave this deli another chance and just yuck. Who puts cubed turkey in a breakfast wrap? And i ask for spinach they charge me for an omelette. There is like none on wrap andoverloaded with chedder cheese. 2stars fir how hard the guy works at the front. Girls needs attitude check as I heard her call another customer stupid. Smg skip!

Mi
Review №22

Order an everything butter bagel got a plain cream cheese bagel instead. Order a Poland spring sports bottle, got a tiny polar spring bottle instead. Order two chocolate chip cookies they were chocolate chip w peanut butter chunks (person who wanted these is allergic to peanut butter). Order sat outside my door for over 10 mins w no email/text/call to let me know it was delivered. Thankfully Grubhub refund the entire order but Honestly how do you get all 4 items out of the order completely wrong? This place needs to slow down and pay attention to what they are putting together. Everything besides the water had to be tossed out.

Ch
Review №23

The thing that stands out to me about this establishment is the kindness that it seems they extend to patrons. Sounds cliche but it really does go a long way when I walk into an eatery and I am politely greeted (especially in the covid era) and the employees seem to be genuinely decent human beings. You can get a bagel or a sandwich at a lot of places. You continuously patronize a place for the attitude and ambiance. I just left and a young woman at the register gave me a tip on how to enjoy a crumb cake I bought with my lunch. Its the little things that stay with you.This place nails it every time and I hope they get every bit of business from the DMV in the same shopping strip. The food is good too. Keep up the great work.

MA
Review №24

Pretty good bagels and other tasty things, lots of options.

Ca
Review №25

Do not eat from this place, numerous times order was wrong, then they argue, then try to make it right . Don’t trust them

Li
Review №26

Wonderful sesame bagel with cream cheese. Best in a long time. My pup enjoyed the last small bite.

Mi
Review №27

Pricey but still good

Se
Review №28

Never the one to public shame or talk negative about an establishment. But enough is enough. Besides being the most overpriced bagel shop in America. For the third and final time I was not impressed with the service I received when I walked through the door, and my sandwich was terrible. For the third time in a row now I received my eggs over easy. The eggs were overcooked, not runny. The cheese was cold and not melted, and the bacon was also cold and chewy. If I’m paying $10.00 for a eggs sandwich and a medium coffee, I shouldn’t be given an attitude when I call and then told to come back.

Mr
Review №29

Denied a Hero at 245 because of cleaning chemicals on a slicer. I worked in a deli for over a year. The woman was just to lazy to have to clean the slicer again, which takes about 5 minutes.If the store closes at 330, then clean the slicer at 330.

Jo
Review №30

Every one just standing around in the back while the line built up and the one person we were able to get there attention they were very rude

Em
Review №31

Very friendly staff and delicious food! Only downside would be that this place is on the more expensive side BUT I still choose to go here because of how good the food is and how enjoyable the experience always is.

Ch
Review №32

Random pick for the morning that you cant go wrong for the value.

Hu
Review №33

Bagels are good. Guy at the front doesn’t has a mask fitting perfectly and just speed out. While cases are rising in Suffolk doesn’t give me much confidence in a shop with a guys mask not covering his nose or mouth.

Ga
Review №34

They have a growing amount of vegan options! Best place on long island for breakfast options!

Jo
Review №35

Best food, best people!!

Bo
Review №36

Great bagels! Always hopping, too!

me
Review №37

We would always order our egg sandwiches from here. While on line today to order my sandwich, i noticed many of the employees behind the counter were not wearing their masks properly.. many below their nose, some barely covering their mouth, including the workers on the grill. I was going to say something, but didn’t.. I’m not the type to usually complain. When i got my sandwich home, there was a long hair cooked into the cheese. I called immediately to express my concerns, however the gentleman that answered the phone seemed as if he couldn’t care less of what i was saying. I am now at a bagel store down the block, where all employees are properly wearing their masks and the employee on the grill had on a hair net. Pleas beware of covid exposure and hair in your food if you go to bagels your way in Medford.

Kr
Review №38

I’ve come back to amend my old review. After several more visits and several *really freaking delicious* sandwiches from BYWC, I am here to say that they’re a fabulous shop and I highly recommend popping in for a yummy hero and a giant iced tea! Staff is friendly and accommodating as well!

Fr
Review №39

Standing 2nd on a 2 person line for over 15 minutes no one even acknowledged us on line,kept walking past us working in other orders. I understand when someones busy but to at least acknowledge and say well be right with you nothing I ended up leaving without ever being served. Ive been there a many of times this is not just an isolated problem. But on the positive note their food is very good fresh and I love their bagels.

vi
Review №40

Love this place go all the time before kids tourneys or a lazy subday m9rning for breakfast.... Onmy down fall when calling in order could take forever ringing or they dont answer at all

Ya
Review №41

$8 for bagel w/chicken salad??? Are you guys serious? Super overpriced place. Dont recommend!

ho
Review №42

Great home fries, these alone keep me coming back. Otherwise mediocre place that makes some really ridiculous mistakes sometimes, but overall good. I mean, look at how they cut my sammich in half today...

am
Review №43

Was in the area for work. This place is not worth the local hype. Even the plain bagel was tasteless and over baked. I do not recommend.

Ma
Review №44

This was very odd. I asked the counter person for well done home fries . She told me “I’m sorry I’m going to be honest with you, the owner is not letting me cook the home fries well done, he’s taking them out as quickly as possible because were busy”. Dumbfounded. How do you allow this. Regrettably will not be going back.

K
Review №45

People they are Pleasant and the food is excellent. Ive been there several times and no complaints yet. so go down there and give it a try you wont be disappointed.

Ve
Review №46

My go to sandwich/bagel place! Breakfast is always on point

Ma
Review №47

This place used to be incredible. I paid over $60 for a few breakfast sandwiches and the food was COLD and the cheese on the egg sandwiches werent even melted - when I spoke to the manager, I was told that the driver came late but he said most of the time the cheese isnt melted unless you want it that way... what??? who says these things about a hot morning egg sandwich and paying over $60 ? No more. I am not returning there again.

Ch
Review №48

Went this morning for 2 egg sandwiches and 1 cup of tea= $17???? i have never been in a more expensive bagel store, even in NYC. Absolutely not worth it while I stood there and waited for the counter help to stop chatting with one another and help the 4 people waiting to pay . Arrogance abounds at this store

Da
Review №49

Went here yesterday service was super fast ! Even though they were very busy they were organized and friendly. They have vegan cream cheese !!! I got the vegetable vegan cream cheese it was very good. We also had an egg sandwich on our order that was good !

Ar
Review №50

Their bagels are delicious and the service is very good. They serve a variety of foods as well!

mj
Review №51

Great service, 5 star

Da
Review №52

Good food, but some of staff is very rude.

Th
Review №53

Very good food. Very busy!

A
Review №54

Quick and accurate.

Ch
Review №55

Amazingly efficient and polite for a local bagel store on a holiday!

Jo
Review №56

Excellent service and I can get spreads there that I cant seem to get any place else. Friendly service!

Ja
Review №57

Best eggs ever, Great friendly staff

Ro
Review №58

Ok A little high priced. Must be big rent.

je
Review №59

Always in a rush they can’t even allow you to think on what you want to order, and when u ask a question they never ever answer your question they so focus on just talking in a fast paste that they don’t take the time to hear you out that’s extremely annoying staff needs to slow down and hear our customers

Re
Review №60

Food was great and the staff was very friendly. I had the pleasure of working with a new employee today and she was very sweet and helpful. We just moved in to the area and will definitely be making this our new bagel spot.

Li
Review №61

Cozy little deli out here on the Island! You can tell how good they are by how busy the place is! The pastry case beautiful. An omelette, toast and a drink for $7. Good deal!

mo
Review №62

Awesome, dont let the long lines scare you off. That means great food awaits. The staff is great too, friendly awesome the line gets long they move it along quick. Britney and Rob are great always a smile to greet you. Even if you live a ways away its worth the drive.

ra
Review №63

This is an excellent place for bagels and or breakfast. The bagels are perfect in their chewiness. They do good breakfast sandwiches, I have not been here for lunch. I love their egg salad, too.

Pe
Review №64

Good breakfast wrap, but I was a little disappointed with the chicken cutlet hero I got for lunch, it was supposed to be a Philly style hero, and there wasnt enough cheese.

Ca
Review №65

I have lived in this area for years, in search of a great morning spot. This gem has been right under my nose the whole time. After trying them, I go no where else when Im near my home. Great food, very efficient and friendly staff. The crowd speaks for the food, me being out in minutes with my did speaks to their service. Love this place.

An
Review №66

Always my place to get my bagels... the staff is the best and the bagels are always fresh. Thats the only reason I go back...As the years go by I have noticed the owner has become cranky as he works the register and takes the payments... he needs to be more pleasant to the customers and to his staff.

Ke
Review №67

You like raw eggs? This is the place. Then when you tell them the sandwich has raw eggs in it, they try to tell you its cheese. Solid choice for those on a raw diet

Je
Review №68

Food is great. Every time I call to place a order for delivery they tell me to order from Uber eats. Which is extremely over priced compared to Regular menu prices, plus the additional charges over 10$ Between fee’s and tip. After placing my order via Uber eats I called to let them know the site doesn’t allow you to choose a coffee with your breakfast sandwiches. That I would like coffee with the each. He replied you will have to place another order separately for the coffees (which would cost me 20$ for what should have been included). That really annoyed me and quite honestly they lost a customer. For three egg sandwiches my total came to $42.00! The fact he couldn’t add the coffee’s that are Suppose to be included In the first place is just bad customer service. Very disappointing.

Ro
Review №69

They do vegan stuff too, cool spot!

Mi
Review №70

I ordered a bagel with 2 eggs, bacon, and cheese and a small coffee, nothing else. $7.86. My jaw dropped! I asked the woman at the counter if she made a mistake and she stated she did not. Very pricey for a simple breakfast sandwich. Most places between $5 and $6. This is Medford, not Manhattan!

pa
Review №71

Great food Large selection

Cr
Review №72

Best place to get an egg sandwich! Staff is always friendly and place is clean, when Im in the area its a must for breakfast although they have lunch too!

MJ
Review №73

Really good food here so far. not sure if all locations are owned by same person or franchised but stay away from Selden location. terrible.

Ka
Review №74

Drove all the way from Shoreham because they have vegan bacon egg and cheese 🤑 so worth it!!

El
Review №75

Rude Manager/Hair in foodWent there on a few occasions and the food was good but unfortunately, my husband ordered eggs and bit into a long string of hair. Tried to bring it to the manager’s attention without alerting other customers but the manager said to my husband that it was not a big deal. Of course it is! It’s a big deal to find a long string of hair in your eggs and it’s in your mouth! The manager again said it wasn’t a big deal and that he would make another batch of eggs for him. The manager never apologized and my husband told him that he was being rude and the manager then proceeded to ask if it was a money issue? The manager said that he was in business 27 years. Why would he even say that? We got our money back and as we were leaving he taunted my husband by yelling have a nice day. We had just gotten our food so I don’t know why he treated us the way he did. This happened today, 3/26 at around 11:00 am.

Co
Review №76

The absolute worst bagel store . They take forever and the bagels are just mediocre . Horrible slow customer service and they don’t answer the phones in the early morning

Ly
Review №77

Always loved this place, great baked goods and bagels, went today, 5/16/2020, the employees are not wearing masks properly, said something and they said they cant breath, I wear a mask all day everyday, find one that works, stop the spread

He
Review №78

Everything flagel with eggs, avocado, peppers and pepper jack cheese, ABSOLUTELY PERFECT! The food is made with love and care! The staff is happy and efficient.. great experience, highly recommended!

N
Review №79

This bagel place makes great egg sandwiches. The sandwiches come out quickly. The coffee is nice and strong, and always made to liking. The staff is very friendly and always there to help when a problem arises. I stop in every day for work,and have yet to be disappointed. Try out the everything flagel for an overdose of seeds!!

Pa
Review №80

I usually dont give reviews but Im new to the area, and went to this location twice after seeing the ratings. On my first visit my server was great. She was charismatic, managed my order well, but the only complaint was that my fried eggs were very runny...yuck!!! I really hate runny eggs. However, on the strength of her service I decided to give this place another try. On my second visit I got a young man this time and from the second after I gave my order, I knew I was making a mistake in returning. He looked like he had a long day already and it was only 11am. I was specific with my order and he rewarded me with a bagel that was burnt (I mean BURNT!!), fried eggs semi runny (I told him to please fry out the yoke), and an iced half & half with coffee...smh!! Thanks guys, on to the next bagel shop.

Jc
Review №81

They still make bagels the old fashioned way here. A dying breed, unfortunately. Nice people, good service, & a killer breakfast special.

Je
Review №82

Friendly service, good selection of food items. Food and beverages shouldnt be papered while wearing the same gloves that handle money and register. Other than that, its good and quick service

Je
Review №83

Great bagels and egg sandwiches, fresh baked goods, coffee is always fresh and delicious deli iced teas. Excellent service. My favorite place for breakfast or lunch.

Br
Review №84

Cute beagle shop with a great staff. The prices are fair and their homemade fries are amazing. I would say they are just better than most of the other beagle shops in the area

Li
Review №85

Excellent food! Nice staff. Their catering orders are amazing. Very happy with service.

Li
Review №86

The prices are way too high. Basic deli. Tuna is disgusting brown. They say white meat tuna but it is definitely not and not home made. $11.00 for a tuna on on whole wheat. Where do they get off charging this much,. Never again!!

Th
Review №87

Dam good food, great service. Tons if homemade cookies here. Does not dissapoint.

Al
Review №88

When I’m too lazy to make my own breakfast, I go this cafe 100% of the time. Amazing customer service/vibe. The food is delicious and it never fails. Keep up the good work guys!

Ke
Review №89

Awesome really take care of their regulars. Always polite and fast. I come out of my way passing 5 other bagel places to come here. Five stars all the way.

Dr
Review №90

Friendly staff and the food is not bad at all. Would be four stars if the wait time wasnt so long. It was not terrible but for a bagel with cream cheese while it wasnt busy still ended up taking 15 minutes after I placed the order.

Fa
Review №91

This place has my favorite bagels, such a selection. The staff are friendly, my son loves going there. We actually go out of our way to get bagels from this place.

Za
Review №92

Can be a little pricey depending upon what you get but the bagels are the best in the area. Sandwiches, omlets and food are always great. Usually a long line but it usually moves quickly. Staff are usually friendly.

An
Review №93

This place has the BEST home fries. I absolutely love how good their food tastes. Staff is also friendly.

Mi
Review №94

Very good sitdown breakfast of coffee, eggs, bacon and a bagel with cream cheese. Wait not bad. Price even better.

Av
Review №95

I got a GF bagel it one was soggy two you can’t even swallow it was that gross

Al
Review №96

I walked into this store for a cup of coffee and did not feel welcomed. The staff is beyond rude and had a problem giving me a cup of coffee with creamer in it. 3 people walked past me, knowing I was waiting to be helped, but did not bother to ask if I wanted anything. The lady who was standing in front of the register had her head turned talking to someone who I guess was very important because she did not look up until I asked if I was allowed to order something. Ive never been talked back to in a restaurant/store before and the young girl who made my coffee seemed to be not so pleased I was asking her for something. Will never go back.

De
Review №97

Excellent, friendly service and awesome bagels. Returned home to Indiana with a dozen. Nothing like New York bagels!

An
Review №98

Excellent...so many choices and options..they truly make it your way. And the apple turnovers are GIAGANTIC!!!!! and they taste as good as they look..primo

Br
Review №99

Cockroach infested restuarant, found a cockroach in a chicken sandwich I had ordered. Even when calling in for a refund they claim the bug came from somewhere else and that it was my fault there was bugs in my food? I dont understand why they do not get an exterminator. The food isnt half bad here but if youre going to be infested with cockroaches at least refund the affected sandwich. Eat anywhere else but here. A woman named shelly confirmed the deli had roaches however when I told her about my sandwich she all of a sudden began to deny it

PV
Review №100

All about music of any kind but annoyingly too loud especially in morning, we left with a huge headache, and must be why my roll for egg sandwich was not toasted as asked, she probably didnt hear me!,also annoying the gazillion items on menu wall, no possible way to read it as your being rushed to take order, finding new bagel /egg deli.

Information
41 Photos
100 Comments
4 Rating
  • Address:2799 NY-112 # 8, Medford, NY 11763, United States
  • Site:http://bagelsyourwaycafe.com/
  • Phone:+1 631-758-6467
Categories
  • Bagel shop
  • Bakery
  • Cafe
  • Deli
  • Takeout Restaurant
  • Vegetarian cafe and deli
Working hours
  • Monday:5:30AM–4PM
  • Tuesday:5:30AM–4PM
  • Wednesday:5:30AM–5PM
  • Thursday:5:30AM–5PM
  • Friday:5:30AM–3PM
  • Saturday:5:30AM–3PM
  • Sunday:5:30AM–4PM
Service options
  • Delivery:Yes
  • In-store pickup:Yes
  • Takeout:Yes
  • Dine-in:No
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot:Yes
Dining options
  • Breakfast:Yes
Amenities
  • Wi-Fi:Yes
Planning
  • Quick visit:Yes
Payments
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
Similar organizations