This place is awesome for any pasta lover and lives up to the hype! The food is phenomenal and full of flavor and the pasta is cooked perfectly. The decor is fun and modern with beautiful murals all dedicated to a love of pasta. They have a good variety of dishes from pesto and red sauce to mac and cheese. Their bread and garlic butter spread is delicious with chunks of garlic confit throughout. Friendly and helpful service, first time visiting and ordering was a breeze thanks to the recommendations. Only thing is the prices are steeper than your traditional walk-up ‘noodles’ restaurants but this doesn’t compare (it’s way better) and it’s worth every penny. Highly recommend!
The food was really good. My wife and I are obsessed with pesto so got that. One of the best pesto dishes that we ever tried. We also got the carbonara which was great. The service was very nice and quick, we really liked the staff.Very clean, great atmosphere, overall great experience, definitely coming back for the lobster Mac & cheese sometime.
Loved the ambience here! The food was delicious and fairly priced. The creativity with the daily specials is enough to keep people coming back! Cant wait to explore the menu more.
Very Instagrammable food that is surprisingly flavorless. I was Super disappointed bc I’ve been wanting to go Forever, and I drool over their Instagram on the daily. The noodles were fine, marinara made me nostalgic for grade school. The caprese salad weirdly wasn’t seasoned at all, so it tasted like cold thick-sliced PnS tomatoes with bland burrata and a few nuts. Lots of paintings and tributes to Adam Pawlak on the doors and walls. Ehhhh
If youre looking to take a risk all the way tonight then this is the place for you. Maybe even with someone else who loves a young fast-paced atmosphere. Great filling unique Italian cuisine while staff and servers are friendly and easy to talk to. I will be back and take more time to find better parking next time.
Exceptional staff, amazing, flavorful fresh ingredients...What an amazing lunch!!! Will definitely return.
This review is for the lobster mac and cheese, which is incredible. I’ve had it three separate times and each it time was delicious, chock full of lobster and had a nice, but subtle seasoning. The pasta is consistently al dente and the sauce is creamy and rich, but not overwhelmingly so. 5 stars for quality, quantity and consistency. Highly recommend.
Honestly, I will be out of the norm here apparently but I was not impressed for all the hype Ive heard. It seemed like a glorified noodles to me but more $ and not nearly as tasty. My meal was really bland and my husband and I have made much more flavorful Carbonara at home. The fresh pasta is nice but the dishes we had lacked depth and flavor. Their garlic butter for the bread was actually the best part and I was able to save my dish a touch by mixing some of that in but wont be jumping to go back anytime soon.
First time there staff was great food was amazing
I had heard really good things about this place and I have to say it blew me away. I did a good level set and had the classic Mac and cheese and added chicken to it. Everything from the flavors of the sauce to the texture of the noodles created an excellent experience and I will be back to try different things on the menu!
Wow! Great place for pasta. Had to take the rest of mine home as well as my friend. Great portions. Will definitely be back. Very hospitable employees.
Cafeteriaesque style ordering. It was very good though. Fresh pasta made right near the bar. It was our first time going, and.i think i would return for sure. We were really confused upon entering though, and it took a bit for the guy to actually explain the concept. He was nice though, and looked like he was the only one working up front.
I have wanted to try Egg & Flour forever and was very disappointed based on all the hype I’ve heard. I had the mushroom pappardelle - noodles were fresh but it was so bland I could’ve had a better dish at Noodles & Company. And at the risk of sounding Karen-esque, it did not help that the server who took our order was high out of her mind and what we were saying was not computing in her brain - so much so that her coworker had to come and take over, and she was relegated to the kitchen. Took us 5 minutes to order 2 pasta dishes because we couldn’t understand her incoherent mumbling. It was very awkward. 🤦🏻♀️ She ended up making our pasta, so maybe that was why it was bland. Maybe the other locations will be better?
Definitely a place to experience. They make their own noodles on site. I hade the wild mushroom sauce. Such goodness!
Always top tier food, flavors on point, wish I lived closer so I could go several times a week!
Ive seen mixed reviews about this restaurant on Facebook, so I decided to try it last week with my friend. We both absolutely loved it. The portion sizes were very large, that we took leftovers home for dinner. Everything was very fresh and delicious. Pasta was cooked perfectly. I added chicken to my Mac and Cheese and it was very tender and tasty. I will definitely be back!
Great pasta, yet pricey. $15 dish I could have replicated for a few bucks. I will be back when I hit the lottery.
I have been waiting for a long time to go to Egg & Flour, it was well worth the wait!! Delicious food and such nice people. I cant wait to go again!
Fast good, tasted GREAT! Great customer service too!
Wonderful, beyond tasty. ♡I look forward to coming back.
Absolutely perfect every time we go.
Stopped in for opening day and the pasta was awesome; tried the buccatini classic.ghe sauce was great, the noodles were great and we only waited a few minutes after ordering.The interior is spacious and we bought some of their fresh pasta to bring home. The kitchen is open so it was fun watching them make the noldles.
Called ahead to make sure it was kid friendly. “Absolutely!” Was the response. They welcomed my chaos with nothing but smiles and even turned on a movie for my 3 kids. How awesome to sit and enjoy my meal and awesome music with the help from the staff. Thanks for lunch!! Kids loved the food! See you again soon. :)
Absolutely DELICIOUS! Some of the best pasta I’ve had. The decor is really neat. Staff was very friendly. Can’t wait to visit again
Adam thank you!! Great food but even better. Adam took the time during a very busy time to meet and chat with my daughter and his biggest fan who came down from Rhinelander to celebrate her birthday 🥳. Greatest effing pasta!! And a good guy. Staff was great too!! Thanks 😊👍
This place is actually really amazing! Walked in, had very friendly staff, the mushroom pasta was so delicious. Adam is a star, and great customer service. Wanted to rate one star so those looking for what’s wrong with it know there’s nothing bad to report here!!!
Simple foods and flavors, exquisitely done. Tried a variety of pastas along with a Caesar salad. The portions were MASSIVE, and the pesto was some of the best I’ve ever had. PLUS, a punchcard where the 8th is free?!?Will be back soon. Very soon.(Pictured: Basil Pesto Campanelle, Garlic Butter Angel Hair, Tomato Cream Rigatoni, baguette with garlic butter, Caesar salad)
Delicious, quick, and reasonably priced!
Went to bay view location. Very cool artsy feel, employees where nice and very fast to get food out, noodles where perfectly cooked dente, bread was fresh along with the mozzarella and aioli tasted great. Good pricing $50 for 2 meals appetizer and drinks
Absolutely fantastic pasta place tucked in Bay View. I got the lobster mac, which while a bit pricey, was worth every penny. Big portions which ended up serving me for dinner later that day. Also got the fresh baked bread with mozzarella, pesto, and what I assume was homemade garlic butter, which was fantastic. You also get a free punch card which leads to every 8th bowl being free. I will definitely be back (to fill the punch card) and enjoy the great food.
The pasta was really good! Just an FYI if you are going out for a nice dinner this is more of a counter place. You order at the counter and pickup at the counter. Pasta doesn’t come with anything....and the prices don’t reflect that. They also want you to tip and the machine suggests 10, 15, or 20 percent when you aren’t being waited on! We were star stuck and had to try it out!
First time visited the collective and was disappointed in carbonara. Went to Bayview location tonight and had a wonderful experience. Food was amazing. We had a great interaction with chef Adam. He apologized for our last visit and made a point to assure our food was fantastic tonight. Awesome experience we will be back. #burrataoneverything
Great Bay View spot and vibe. Not a fan of the al dente style noodles, and a little pricey but still pretty good pasta. Love the carbonara, give that a try!
The staff is friendly. The place is kept really clean. I’ve gone there twice now and I really want to like the place, but haven’t been too impressed. First time I went I got the rigatoni with added meatballs for 20$ and it was just okay. I felt like this was partially on me, the huge ball of cheese in the middle was a bit too much for my personal taste and the rest of it was good but not something I’d go out of my way for 20$ a bowl. Portions were good though and it did taste fresh. So I tried going again hoping it was just a fluke and I tried a more simpler dish. I got the angel hair dish and I couldn’t even take a second bite. I got it in a to go dish and drove 5 minutes to my house. When I opened it up, The dish was sooo dry. It was a compact bowl of dry angel hair noodles pressed together in a ball with a slight garlic taste. I couldn’t even get my first bite down, it was so dry and flavorless. I was really disappointed. This place has potential, I’m going to give them the benefit of the doubt and say maybe I just picked two bad dishes ? Their specials always look good but I’m reluctant to try it again. The price is good if it’s a dish you like but it’s expensive if you’re playing trial and error.
Wonderful experience, taste and staff. Need more stars!
Very quick and Good Food.
Always delicious! Orders are always correct. Friendly staff when placing orders by phone. I love that they have a loyalty program. I highly recommend E&F!!!
The freshest pasta and the variety of options makes this place great. Check out their special menu items.
The food starts to get a little pricy when you start adding on things but its still a large enough that you could get 2 meals out of it or share with someone. Love the bread and get the cheese to go with it.
Pasta was delicious! The pasta special and pappardelle with white cream sauce were so good. The carbonara was just okay. But you cant go wrong with homemade pasta.
Awesome. The carbonara is off the charts.
Just ordered for the first time and the food is just stupid good. How they make the chicken that moist? To just fall apart like it does? Is simply incredible. Keep up the good work guys!
Not what I expected.Pasta was underdone on 4 different meals.Server kept saying its because its a fast restaurant which is no excuse for undercooked food.Nice Interior tho
FRESH! and Delicious!! Awesome staff as well! Will definitely be coming back here...
1. Just really, REALLY, good food.2. Affordable for any budget.3. Employees are very polite and have great customer service skills.4. Social Distancing Friendly.
Food was prepared fresh and pasta was good. Very clean, Covid safe. Pricey for what you get, but kudos to the food. They should serve the Lobster Mac & Cheese every day not just Fridays!
No frills environment, but delicious pasta dishes! Ill definitely be back.
One of my favorite local gems! Pappardelle is a great goto. The daily specials are also a great choice to take advantage of! Bucatini is very delicious! Service is very attentive, the staff is very happy to help out with any suggestions.
Super yummy! Fast and friendly service! Will definitely be back
Wow wow wow!! So delicious! We’ve been watching Hell’s Kitchen every week and have been dying to give this place a shot. When we heard Declan would be in town this weekend we knew we had to go. 100% will be back again just like we hope Declan will be too!!!!
I love this place! The bucatini with cream sauce is my favorite, hands down. But Ive never had a bad dish. So go wild & enjoy the entire menu. Cheers!
Place was awesome! Found 2 seats right away Pasta was delicious and as soon as we got our food we were able to see Adam and Declan. We got a chance to talk with Declan but not Adam he was busy behind the counter but we will be back to meet him!
I was very excited to try this place, based off the fact that the owner is now opening a 3rd restaurant and he’s a local bay viewer. But sadly I was let down not one, but two flavorless “signature” pasta dishes(angel hair and the rigatoni) I and my friend had. The side of bread we ordered was bland and the $8 dollar add on meatballs were below average at best. Dry and tasteless. There are 10 better food options available in Bay View for you to choose before Egg and Flour. I would not be fooled by the good reviews I see on here, as Adam has his work cut out for him for him to make his restaurant depict the numerous 5 star reviews he’s received.
Sevice was great, but Gordon Ramsey would have not approved of the pasta I was served. I ordered the pappardelle Bolognese all my noodles were stuck together. Most of the time I try not to complain, because you never know what you get back!
The food is so amazing here! A nice piece of heaven for your mouth!🤤🤤🤤
These guys seriously deserve a 5 on service alone. They went above & beyond to find us a table on a specific night when reservations were necessary (they typically arent needed). Extremely grateful since it was a bit of a drive to try their food.Would love to see Adam open a Mexican restaurant after he crushed the challenge on HK. MKE could use some elevated Mexican fusion.Only knock on Egg & Flour would be that it is a bit on the pricey side for pasta.
Not.... What I expected. Id hate to say it but, it really reminded me of elementary school lunch that costed me $23 instead of $1.50..... 2 stars because it filled me up, but Ill prolly end up ordering a pizza later. Sorry but.... I really expected more.
Everything is delicious. The staff is super friendly and helpful. Highly recommend it.
As a vegan looking at their menu, its a bit hard to figure out if you can get anything made vegan. Bacon, cheese, butter, cream, meat, lobster are all over the menu and the one item labeled VG isnt identified, so is it Vegan? Vegetarian? Gluten-Free? Cant tell. Luckily, when I walked into the place and asked at the register if they had anything a vegan could order, they piped right up with YES! There are actually three vegan options! So I got the item labeled VG, the Creste Di Gallo - Basil Pesto/ Walnut Pesto (VG) Parmesan $10. Delicious! By the time I got it home, however, it was a little dry, but the flavor was still all there and then some. Definitely need to eat this as soon as it comes out of the kitchen, so Ill try something else next time. The Bucatini my friend had was very good. I cant wait to try the other two vegan options. I hope this place sticks around a very long time! They are a welcome addition to Bay View. Reviewed on 8/11/2020
Awesome place. They gave a great variety of different pastas and some different ones. Check out the Facebook page.
Adam Pawlak needs a staue at the corner of Lincoln and Howell!! The best pasta and atmosphere 😋😍you are treated like family!! Must get the ravioli😋
Food tasted flavorful the taste of everything is nice however sadly to say the noodles where under cook and made the whole experience a bit underwhelming not sure if it is there thing or not however if your not a fan of under cooked noodles I would suggest you ask then to cook then twice
Not what I expected. Have seen a lot of their posts and diners reviews and this did not live up to perception. Pasta was underdone. I do al dente where it is firm with a chew but this was actually hard,. Towards the end the pasta had softened up, but I would not expect someone to order food let it sit for 15 mins and then eat. Carbonara was not good, mushroom parpadelle was good with a nice fresh pop of basil. Overall could have made fresh pasta at home with my own ingredients and it would have been better and less expensive. Not usually this critical but this was a disappointment.Place is super cute, really loved the neon and murals.
By far, the best mac n cheese in town!Only a available on Fridays.Did I mention the baguettes? OMG! Delicious!
The Egg & Flour restaurant Is a wonderful creative twist on pasta. You will love the varieties of pasta and more that they come up with. The staff are super friendly and can explain every dish perfectly. The chef, owner, creator is Adam Pawlak, who is also cooking up a storm on the 2021 season of Hells Kitchen. Be sure to check this place out as they will surely become a Milwaukee classic and a place to visit when you have guests in town or just want a delicious meal. They have various locations including a location in Bayview (on KK near Lincoln) and inside the Crossroads Collective (corner of North and Farwell) on the east side. 
The Bucatini with cream sauce (alfredo) was creamy and excellently season with a nice dusting of parmesan which accented the sauce perfectly. I would recommend adding a protein as I had the meatballs which were seasoned great complicating the Bucatini sauce. The Bucatini had nice bite but I will try the shells next time. Its nice to see they have a loyalty punch card program as well.
Tastefully made pasta. Energetic atmosphere and workers.
Very tasty meal. Will be back!
Tuscan chicken was pure perfection at lunch today. E&F never disappoints.
Everything’s great. Adam is awesome.
Food is delicious. Portions are enormous. More options for those of us who are lactose challenged would be much appreciated!
Plenty of food, food is always excellent. Friendly atmosphere. Love this place.
Fantastic pasta! We had the classic shells and classic bucatini with cream today, and both were delicious. Staff very friendly and helpful. You get a lot of food for a good price, and the establishment seems to be operating very safely and efficiently in the midst of covid. We will definitely be back!
Great experience every time I come. Food is great! Great vibe, clean, friendly service and located so close to my screen printing shop! 🔥
I love this place! The food never disappoints!
Super fresh and delicious. A little on the expensive side but portions are large.
Pesto sauce was great and the grilled chicken was super tender and moist!
The Lobster Mac and Cheese is amazing!
Lobster Mac-n-cheese was the best I have ever had! Go on Fridays!!!!
New favorite noodle place, but gets very pricey fast. I tried that cheese ball and bread on the menu as well, very odd...it was almost like mozzarella cheese on the outside and a liquid in the middle....still tasted ok on breadMy favorite noodle dish is the cream sauce with black pepper and ill add in chicken...👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽 delicious
The smell alone when you walk in is worth 5 stars. Im a total ding dong and decided to try it when Im on a temporary gluten free diet so I only ate the caprese salad. I got 2 words for that salad: dope af!
The best freshly made pasta in the area! Come check it out for their tasty regular menu offered as well as the special pasta of the day Mon-Fri! I’m never disappointed!
Great food and service!
Good food
Pesto pasta was awesome
Was ok need to try more food
Service was great it was just the food. The taste was just not for me and not something I’d crave. Pretty expensive as well.
Not impressed. Pricey for what you get. I ordered bread & burata, ceaser salad, green salad, bucatini, and rigatoni. Bread was greasy and you get a hoagie size roll for $8 with the burata.We ordered takeout, and they put everything in the same bag. By the time we got home, salads were warm and all the croutons had absorbed the dressing. Wouldnt order salads again. I can make better ones at home.They charge $5 to add meat to your pasta. So we paid $5 for two meatballs. Once I got home I noticed there are three different bucatinis on the menu and they never asked to specify which one I wanted. Needless to say, I got the wrong one. Pasta want bad.All in all, I would never come here again. Way too expensive and the food was not impressive.
Excellent flavor. Had enough for 2 meals. Great quality.
Very impressed! This place smells and looks very clean! My food was delicious.