Extremely overpriced ice cream. The Georgia Peach was just OK but the Key Lime Pie tasted like air freshener. No waffle cone sleeves either. If it had not been so difficult to park we would have simply gone elsewhere. Their chocolate is likewise insanely priced and isnt impressive for the price.LiftOff Creamery is a much better option.Also, to the Kilwins rep: Thanks for the predictable its not us, its you response. I will buy you a double-scoop of that key lime pie if you will eat it without being grossed out. It seriously does taste like air freshener. First time in my life I didnt like a key lime pie product.
It was just ok. Definitely had better got the $
Staff is always friendly and welcoming. Selection is consistently full, never bare or picked over. If you are downtown, this is one of those must stops on Mass Ave. They represent the brand well!
Will not disappoint! By far the best ice cream, chocolate and service in town! For those who complain about the price, you get what you pay for, and Id like to pay for quality!
First tried this place in Florida. Never realized there was one in Indy and it didnt disappoint. Bright and cheery when you walk in. Friendly staff and smells delicious. Their ice cream is amazing and their homemade chocolate treats are out of this world.
I felt like a kid in a candy store when I walked in . . . Well, maybe an old man in a candy store. The store has a nice selection of chocolates, ice cream, and fudge. The staff was very helpful in making a selection and they were patient with me in making my selection (too many choices). The store is well laid out with many packaged items available to be purchased or given as a gift. I would like to have one of the 10 pound candy bars, but its a little out of my pay grade.The chocolates, fudge, or ice cream I have had on each visit was really good.
Great tasting icecream! Homemade type ice cream with some other homemade confectionary. Great after dinner summer treat :)
So Ive been here a few times now. Im not a huge fudge person, but I have sampled there salted caramel fudge which was delicious. What I really go there for are the caramel apples. Ive had their apple pie caramel apple which is the bomb! I also bought their salted chocolate caramel apple recently. I havent eaten it yet, but Im sure it wont disappoint.
The most delicious icecream you will ever eat. Lots to choose from, plus different toppings, and other sweets.
$7 for one scoop of ice cream, that is worth $2 and tasted extremely bland? Not worth it!
Yummy fudge, great chocolates and the ice cream was great. They only let you taste test the fudge so its hard to decide which ice cream to get
Great shop with a variety of confections.We got ice cream, taffy, cookies and peanut butter cups. Everything was tasty.
Olivia was awesome and recommended the s’mores and kilwin’s tracks when I asked for the 2 best flavors. Fantastic choices because the s’mores may have been the most marshmallow-y ice cream I’ve ever had (and I’ve had a lot of ice creams in my life). It’s a great, authentic flavor that took me back to a fresh s’mores over a bonfire. The tracks was great too, with the peanut butter cups and tons of fudge. The ice cream itself was more on the smooth and creamy side, which is good after a long day of bike riding through storms. I got this before dinner and I might get some more after. 5/5
Good ice cream but rude service.... It is a pity I dont think would be back there.
Always great service! I highly recommend the Traverse City Cherry!
First visit. Ice cream was ok. Have had better.
The ice cream was great!
A rude treatment not worth to describe... Ice cream OK.
Love the sea salt caramels. Yum. 💓
OMG. The chocolate here is the best. Ever.
I love their Chunky Strawberry ice cream. A little expensive but good.
Delicious ice cream and a very homey, welcoming store :)
The mos incredible of INDY
Excellent shakes. Perhaps the best Ive ever tasted!
Just walking in and you are in a sugar high!! Chocolate, treats and ice cream!!
Deeply disappointed. Fudge is hard and the peanut butter in the buckeyes tastes generic.
It was okay. A little overpriced but okay.
This is some seriously good ice cram! It is very creamy and they don’t skimp on the flavors. My chocolate sea salt Carmel literally looked like a candy bar mixed with ice cream, it was SO good. The portions are generous for a decent price. As well, the store has various candies/truffles that are also very tasty!I could have gone without the calorie count on the ice cream flavors LOL but overall I can’t wait to come back!
Just stop by. You will net regret it... yum
Amazing as always. Perfect Apple Pie ice cream is seasonal, so get it while you can, it has chunks of apple and pie crust in it. A lot of both. Imagine a slice if apple pie with a scoop of ice cream on top, now, make that an ice cream flavor. Carmel corn is amazing, and the english toffee is also on point. Try the sea foam, its as if the toffee was brought to boil, stopped, let harden, the slice into 1in chunks, dipped in chocolate. Perfection.
So happy Indy has a Kilwins! My family would always crave it after having it in Naples, FL. By far the best ice cream, fudge and other sweets in Indy!
They have a very friendly and welcoming staff. The dark chocolate peanut butter cups have the creamiest peanut butter, they are so good. The chocolate covered marsh mellows are also delightful.
Hot chocolate was good but small and pricey. The insult was that the chocolate buckeyes were $2.00 a pop and they were smaller than usual.
Love this place. My favorite ice cream place downtown!
If you need to satisfy your sweet tooth this is the place between the specialty chocolate, the fudge and the ice cream this is the place of smiles.
Dont go here for ice cream! $5 for one scoop and its nothing special. 😩
Yummy. Lots and lots to choose from. Busy area though. Prices were good. Very hard to park
One of the best dessert places I have ever been to, great Ive cream that is made in house, NOT ORDERED! Their customer service is great, owner is very nice, their fudge is super good, as well as the rest of the items they have. Ive tried at least half of their ice cream flavors and for those who live in Indy, its wayyyyy better than subzero. This is a mist try place and a place I will continue to go to.
Service is always excellent and the ice cream amazing. Also try the dark chocolate sea salt caramel truffles! 😋
I don’t usually eat Kilwins but I usually travel to the location in Lake Worth Beach, FL. I am glad they finally put one in Indianapolis. This is hands down the best ice cream in the world. I will definitely return when I get the chance
Got strawberry ice cream which was very good. I still prefer Handles ice cream in Fishers. Loved watching them make the waffle cones that was fun
We always look forward to visiting them in Saint Augustine Florida . Very excited to see one here in our town. Best icecream hands dodo. Homemade fresh waffle cones. Candy etc
Great service and delicious ice cream! They have a great variety of flavors and they have all kinds of other sweets like fudge and even carmel dipped apples!
Have you have a couple dk chocolate turtles now and then.
Good intensely flavored ice cream and treats. Clean and nice atmosphere but FYI only seating is a couple of outside benches.
Amazing ice cream and unbelievable fudge. Best dessert destination in Indy by far. Chocolate-covered Twinkies too! Love this place!!
The ice cream was nothing special but the waffle cones were pretty good. Customer service was great! Happy, smiling workers.
Great customer service, my son loved the place!
Lovely icecream shop with all assortments of chocolate and fudge. Emily and Sean were attentive and helped us make a great choice!
Plate sizes arent huge, some may view as over-priced. Staff, environment and plating are unrivaled. Very nice, high quality restaurant
Reminds me of going on vacation in Norther Michigan. So glad. They had Superman flavor.
Excellent local ice cream shop! Staff are very friendly.
Visit the shop today on Mass ave.in downtown Indianapolis the buckeye were awesome so was the ice cream waffle amazing staff and owner highly recommend this ice cream shop to anyone.
$$ 9.00 for 2 scoops of ice cream..omg
This place is sooo needed! Finally a legit dessert/ice cream spot that isnt the nitro place with lines a mile long. The staff is the absolute best here, honestly just the nicest people and willing to let you sample fudge or ice cream. I usually come for the ice cream - its creamy and amazing! Great array of flavors to please anybodys palate. So dang happy Indy has a Kilwins now!
Some of the best ice cream ever. I will definitely return here and would highly recommend it
Prices are way too much. Almost $5 for a single scoop dishBut they have good ice cream.
This place was awesome. Wish they had them where I live.
We love Kilwins. We visit the one in Pier Park, Panama City Beach, Fl. I was disappointed there wasnt any sugar free ice cream. Also they didnt have any specials.
Some of the best ice cream in town the place is always clean and the staff is amazing !!!!
I really wish they had seating.That being said, their ice cream is out-of-this-world phenomenal and their staff is always friendly and atyentive!
The mint fudge was better than heaven
Hannah is awesome! Great service and great ice cream.
Great icecream and the best fresh made waffle cones. Just a bit over priced
Very busy when we were there. Ice cream was delicious.
The ice cream here is very, very good. The price is quite high (higher than I would like), but you get what you pay for.
Love Mackinac Island fudge icecream here, its incredible
Delicious ice-cream, friendly server!
The ice cream is amazing just get it
Super friendly staff and great ice cream classics.
You havent had ice cream until youve had Kilwins, and dont get me started on their fudge! So yummy!
Always a big fan of Kilwins! I just hate it when they don’t have my flavors in rotation...
Extremely expensive...but very good
Toasted coconut ice cream is amazing!
The best fudge, ice cream, and chocolates in Indy 😍
Worth every penny. Well done!!!
My favorite place for ice cream, love it
Great ice cream, friendly workers.
Good icecream, great staff
Love this place
Wonderfully delicious treats!
Great fudge
Best ice cream shop in town!
This place is awesome!
Cake batter ice cream is to die for
Amazing ice cream
Great ice cream, but a tad expensive.
Good ice cream but VERY expensive
Goood!