Great Gelato. Tried key lime pie and tiramisu. Delicious.

This aint real gelato. Its a knockoff brand . Its more like Soft aerved ice cream .

I love the product! They keep changing their hours unexpectedly...

Some of the flavor options were a bit odd, flavor was ok, for some reason the pistachio was not very green or flavorful

I love this place! So so many tasty flavors and allergen friendly

Sooo cold 🥶 love the flavors

Great gelato and ice cream. Really fresh.

Delicious gelato with many creative flavors.

This is a very good gelato spot, wonderful flavors and great friendly employees

Always flies in the store, and sometimes in the display cases. I saw a fly go through a crack and just land in the ice cream. There are many fruit flies that somehow make it into the ice cream, especially the sorbetto ones, so make sure you check before you eat it. Usually the ice cream tastes good, but it’s not outstanding and it doesn’t really taste creamy like gelato is. Also the machines are very loud and it’s hard to hear the cashiers over the sound. Fortunately the cashiers were always very nice and respectful.

Friendly employees, amazing flavors (many are safe for folks with allergies), its really quite a special place.

The ice cream here is soooooo good. Definitely worth the price. You wont find anything like it. I promise you.

Tried this spot for the first time recently and it was really good, lots of flavors to choose from my favorite was def the blue raspberry.. will be back to be sure to try them all

Lots of options of gelato and sorbetto to pick from and the sizes are nice and small so not overly filling!

Best frozen treats in the Milwaukee area! If you havent been here, you owe it to yourself!

Because I saw a good number of great reviews on this place, I decided to give it a try. I walked into the place with it being empty, but customer service was stellar; I was greeted by the ice cream server right away. She was more than happy to serve us the multiple samples we asked for. I had the Salted Caramel, which was creamy, but average. Something you can get at Target prepackaged. My boyfriend got Blue Moon, which he didnt sample. It was grainy, watery, and not at all your traditional Madison Babcock Hall Blue Moon. It tasted more like cotton candy and bubblegum than anything. Lastly, they didnt have a variety of cones. They ones they did have were stale. Despite the quality of the gelato, the server was accommodating, sweet, and had a great attitude ringing us up.

I went here for the first time and sampled everything, literally. The young lady was of great help. Im definitely going back.

Gelato was great! Was disappointed in amount given. 1st night in town purchased 6 small cups at $3.45 and small bowls overflowed with greatness... After bragging all day to daughters basketball team we brought the group of 20+ to shop and portions were 1/3 of portions night before but gelato was great dispite.

Love cold spoons! So happy they are open again. Flavors are spot on and amazing.

So many yummy flavors to choose from. Can taste any flavor.

Very good gelato and convenient location. Clean and good service. Tuesdays you can get a medium for the price of a small and a large for the price of a medium...Mediums are HUGE and almost the size of our kids face!

Excellent gelato at a decent price. The service was great, and the atmosphere inviting. Great for a mid walk snack, or end of a date. We will definitely come back

One of my daughters favorite dessert places in the city. Many great home made flavors, highly recommended.

Cute little local gelato shop with tons of options and always SO tasty! I love walking to Cold Spoons with my boys!

Their gelatov flavors are delicious!

Flavorful gelato. The goat cheese caramel cashew was amazing.

Kind of like an old time soda shop but with flavered icecream. A hidden store for you to visit.

Best Gelato and Sorbeto in Milwaukee. Friendly helpful staff. Get as many tastes as you like.

Came in shortly before closing and got Gelato for a group of friends at the convention center and it was delicious. Nice selection of flavors with some in cartons that are easy to take out.

Its was nice and Nyah took good care and answered all our questions.

Great stop for a sweet treat! Lots of inventive flavors to choose from.

Really enjoyed the gelatto here. Good selection of flavors, and they also have sorbet

Very good gelato! They serve a great variety of flavors and have a great, local Milwaukee feel!

Absolutely wonderful icy treat anytime. It was hot, humid and raining the evening I was there. A couple tables were occupied and everyone was busy spooning this scrumptious gelato and sorbetto onto their waiting tongues. I enjoyed the mango sorbetto... It tastes just like the fruit without the peels and mess. We got there minutes before the Milwaukee Food Tour bus... Definitely good!

Excellent gelato and sorbetto. Friendly staff and all the free tasting youd like. We love cold spoons!

Young counter workers are very hard working and knowledgeable about their flavors. Wide variety of gelato flavors including some additional options like affrigato

I really like the options that they have, the pricing is really reasonable, you can try a little bit of everything before you decide and the staff is very nice.

Awesome flavors and great quality! Will definitely be returning.

Great place, wonderful gelato. Need to get hours updated on Google...i.e. listed that they were open at noon today (Friday), but really not open until 2. Luckily I did not travel far, but should get the hours corrected asap.

So much gelato in a tiny cup! Easy to go overboard on yumminess!!😋

Yum in my tum

Their flavors are great! I especially love the raspberry.

Amazing gelato, convienent location, cute decor. The girls working there were very nice, too. Ill definitely come back.

Best Gelato in mke. Flavors change regularly. Check back often.

Nice workers, yummy gelato and bowls filled high. italian style!

Great gelato

This is a lovely homemade gelato shop. The service is great; samples of the inventive flavors are given freely. Gelato is wonderful to your tastebuds!

Employee was very courteous and congenial! The gelato was delicious!

I love all their unique flavors and great service!

I love the huge variety of flavors that change daily.

So yummy and staff is very friendly!

Excellent flavors. so many to choose from

This place is awesome! A welcome change of pace from the typical frozen custard & yogurt places.

Always a great stop for quality gelato!

Great gelato and people there are very nice

Too expensive, not a lot of variety. Cashier was very nice though, sherbert was good.

Very delicious!

Husband liked it. I did not.

Delicious treat often overlooked.

I tried an ice cream it was nasty they let me trade nice customer service

Great selections and service was great.

Wonderful place, love their gelato.

Fun and enjoyable

Interesting flavors and great service.

Gonna try all the flavors!

Ive been to Italy...this is not gelato. I couldnt stomach much more beyond the first taste.

Big portions and good flavors

Nyah was very helpful

Great all year round

Good quality gelato

Delicious local gelato!!!

Great gelato!!

Great flavors

Hook and go baby!

Delicious.

Good

Ill be back !

Huge portions!

AWESOME!

Gelato is amazing

Delicious,

Yum!

Like it